New York City
Northern New Jersey
Search Better With
Shop for a Broker
Open House Planner
Saved Listings & Folders
Stats and Figures
Manhattan Condo Market Index
Here's someone who knows a deal when she sees it. LOL!
"An East Village woman claims she can take over a $291-per-month rent-controlled three-bedroom apartment because she tended to its two elderly inhabitants for four years — even though she’s not related to them.
Now the landlord is trying to boot her.
Margaret Hearn, 48, began living at 345 E. 12th St. in 2008, when she became a full-time caretaker for sisters Margaret and Josephine Ruta, whom she met at church.
Josephine died in March. Margaret died last year.
When Hearn returned from Josephine’s funeral, the apartment was padlocked. Her brother cut the lock, and she has moved in.
“I was emotional. I had just been to a funeral, and I felt I was losing it, and this happened,” Hearn said, adding the landlord “wants to remodel the apartment and charge more.”
Similar pads in the building go for $4,400 in rent.
Hearn — who also keeps a rent-controlled $747-a-month studio in Gramercy Park — says the landlord, 339-347 East 12th Street Investor LLC, filed to evict her in May 2012.
Phillip Wartell, a lawyer for the landlord, did not return calls.
by nyc law, marggie is entitled to take the place
landlord can buy her now though, i think the market price is at least 50k now
she has 2 rent controlled apts? obviously the solution is to give her 2 more since she's so entitled duhhh
There's nothing I hate more than misinformation.
NOT true caonima. That's for a judge to determine. See definition of family member below.
Fact Sheet #30: Succession Rights
For rent stabilized and rent controlled apartments throughout New York State, a "family member" of the tenant may have the right to a rent stabilized renewal lease or protection from eviction in an apartment under rent control when the tenant dies or permanently leaves the apartment. For a detailed explanation of "family member", refer the "Family Member-Definition" portion of this Fact Sheet.
A family member has the right to a renewal lease or protection from eviction if he or she resided with the tenant as a primary resident in the apartment for two (2) years immediately prior to the death of, or permanent departure from the apartment by the tenant. The family member may also have the right to a renewal lease or protection from eviction if he/she resided with the tenant from the inception of the tenancy or from the commencement of the relationship. If the family member trying to establish succession rights is a senior citizen or disabled person, then the minimum period of co-occupancy is reduced to one (1) year.
The first family member to establish succession rights on or after June 20, 1997 is not required to pay the owner a vacancy increase. (See Example #1)
However, the owner will be entitled to collect the vacancy increase from the next family member, called the second successor, who is entitled to receive a renewal lease or to remain in possession (See example #2). The vacancy increase for the second successor also applies to apartments subject to rent control (See example #4). Once the vacancy increase is applied to this second successor family member, a subsequent succession situation is again created (See example #3).
Tenant A vacated a rent stabilized apartment on August 1, 2006 paying a legal rent of $800 under a lease to expire on January 31, 2007. Family member B, who has lived with A as a primary resident of the apartment for three years, is entitled to receive a renewal lease for the apartment commencing February 1, 2007 without paying the owner any vacancy increases. B signed, in B's name only, a two-year renewal lease starting February 1, 2007 with a 7.25% rent increase and the rent became $858 ($800 + $58 (7.25% of $800)).
Continuing from Example #1, family member C began to live with A and B shortly before A left and continued to live with B. If B were to leave the apartment after two years, and C were entitled to receive a renewal lease on February 1, 2009 in C's own name because of the succession rules, C would be required to pay to the owner the vacancy increase. If C chose a two year lease, the legal rent would increase by 20% to $1029.60 ($858 + $171.60 (20% of $858)).
Continuing from Example #2, if C vacated and family member D became entitled to a renewal lease as a successor, D would not have to pay a vacancy increase as D is now the first succeeding tenant to C, who had received a vacancy increase.
On June 1, 2000, in a rent control apartment, Tenant A, whose rent was $550, dies. The son, family member B, because of succession rules, continues to occupy the apartment at a rent of $550. If B were to permanently vacate on October 1, 2011 and family member C had succession rights to the apartment, the rent of $550 would be increased by $242 (44%) to a new rent of $792. This increase is the sum of the vacancy allowance of 20% (20% x $550 = $110) and the longevity vacancy allowance of 24% (40 years since the last vacancy increase x .6% x $550 = $132). The apartment would still be under rent control.
Family Member - Definition
"Family member" is defined as either a spouse, son, daughter, stepson, stepdaughter, father, mother, stepfather, stepmother, brother, sister, grandfather, grandmother, grandson, granddaughter, father-in-law, mother-in-law, son-in-law or daughter-in-law of the tenant or permanent tenant.
The definition of "family member" also includes any other person(s) residing with the tenant or permanent tenant in the housing accommodation as a primary resident, who can prove emotional and financial commitment and interdependence between such person(s) and the tenant.
The following are to be considered in determining whether emotional and financial commitment and interdependence between the tenant and such other occupants existed:
a) longevity of the relationship;
b) sharing of or relying upon each other for payment of household or family expenses, and/or other common necessities of life;
c) intermingling of finances as evidenced by, among other things, joint ownership of bank accounts, personal and real property, credit cards, and loan obligations, sharing a household budget for purposes of receiving government benefits, etc.;
d) engaging in family-type activities by jointly attending family functions, holidays and celebrations, social and recreational activities, etc.;
e) formalizing of legal obligations, intentions, and responsibilities to each other by such means as executing wills, naming each other as executor and/or beneficiary, granting each other a power of attorney and/or conferring upon each other authority to make health care decisions each for the other, entering into a personal relationship contract, making a domestic partnership declaration, or serving as representative payee for purposes of public benefits, etc.;
f) holding themselves out as family members to other family members, friends, members of the community or religious institutions, or society in general, through their words or actions;
g) regularly performing family functions, such as caring for each other's extended family member and/or relying upon each other daily for family services;
h) engaging in any other pattern of behavior, agreement, or other action which evidences the intention of creating a long-term, emotionally committed relationship.
The determination is not limited to any one factor, and in no event would evidence of a sexual relationship between such persons be required or considered.
"Tenant" relates to any person or persons named on a lease or rental agreement who is or are obligated to pay rent for the use of the housing accommodation.
"Permanent tenant" relates to individuals, who have continuously resided in housing accommodations located in hotels as a primary residence for a period of at least six months, or a hotel tenant in occupancy pursuant to or entitled to a lease.
"Disabled Person" is defined as a person who has an impairment which results from anatomical, physiological or psychological conditions, other than addiction to alcohol, gambling, or any controlled substance, which are demonstrable by medically acceptable clinical and laboratory diagnostic techniques, and which substantially limit one or more of such person's major life activities.
"Senior citizen" is defined as a person who is sixty-two years of age or older.
Minimum Residency Requirements
The minimum periods of required residency will not be considered interrupted by any period during which the "family member" temporarily relocates because he or she:
a) is engaged in active military duty;
b) is enrolled as a full-time student;
c) is not in residence at the housing accommodation in accordance with a court order not involving any term or provision of the lease and not involving any grounds specified in the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law;
d) is engaged in employment requiring temporary relocation from the housing accommodation;
e) is hospitalized for medical treatment; or
f) has such other reasonable grounds that shall be determined by the DHCR upon application by such person.
On the Notice To Owner Of Family Members Residing With The Named Tenant In The Apartment Who May Be Entitled To Succession Rights/Protection From Eviction (DHCR Form RA-23.5), the tenant may at any time, inform the owner of the names of all persons (other than the tenant), who are residing in the apartment. Or, the owner may at any time, but no more than once in any twelve months, request from the tenant the names of all such persons.
The following information pertaining to such persons should accompany the names;
a) if the person is a family member as defined above;
b) if the person may become entitled to be named as a tenant on a renewal lease or become entitled to protection from eviction upon the passage of the applicable minimum period of required residency;
c) the date of the commencement of such person's primary residence with the tenant; and
d) if the person is a senior citizen or disabled person as defined above.
New York City Rent Stabilization Code, Section 2523.5
Tenant Protection Regulations, Section 2503.5
New York City Rent and Eviction Regulations, Section 2202.25
New York State Rent and Eviction Regulations, Section 2102.8
For more information or assistance, call the DHCR Rent InfoLine, or visit your Borough or County Rent Office.
Last updated on 02/28/11
jeeze--now we're going to hear about how rc and rs only benefit scammers like this woman and bianca jagger--or better yet, we can hear about people buying cigs and liquor with food stamps--blah blah
rc and rs are set up now so that, via attrition, they will be largely over soon enough--and, as a percentage of total apts rented, esp in manhattan, the rs anrcd staock is already pared down to near-irrelevance
or better yet, let's talk about how working people and unions caused the financial crisis
west34, you are cutting part of the info out off your picture
by nyc law, if the person (any unrelated person) takes care of the tenant for a year before the tenant pass away, this stranger can continue to have the unit, there were many many successful cases out there, go search for court records
Sorry Perry Mason, you're wrong and have no idea what you're talking about. There is no such law. The one year cohabitation rule refers to if the SUCCESSOR is disabled or at least age 62.
> Hearn — who also keeps a rent-controlled $747-a-month studio in Gramercy Park — says the landlord, 339-347 East 12th Street Investor LLC, filed to evict her in May 2012.
doesn't this mean that the lucky landlord at Gramercy should evict her as she's not using it as 1st residency?
perry mason, there is no such thing as "the SUCCESSOR is disabled or at least age 62" regarding this law
go search for court records, it's so easy