Carnegie Hill

Brimming with historic charm and contemporary cultural relevance, Carnegie Hill is a crown jewel on Manhattan’s Upper East Side. Beyond convenient park access, the neighborhood houses a long stretch of Museum Mile — a smorgasbord of diverse art institutions that stretch along Fifth Avenue for, you guessed it, a mile.

At a Glance

After industrialist Andrew Carnegie built an impressive mansion at 91st Street and Fifth Avenue in 1901, other wealthy city dwellers began to flock to this area and build their own grand digs. Thus began the development of Carnegie Hill, whose modern-day iteration boasts endless convenience in an opulent aesthetic. Over 100-year-old structures can be seen perfectly preserved in the Carnegie Hill Historic District. But this neighborhood is decidedly not stuck in the past, as evidenced by its plethora of contemporary boutiques, bookstores, cafes and restaurants — not to mention the many, many museums along Fifth Avenue dedicated to showcasing modern art and culture. Carnegie Hill even earned a spot on StreetEasy’s list of NYC Neighborhoods to Watch in 2024.

The Mood

Gilded Age mansions, Romanesque Revival rowhouses, and prewar apartment buildings co-exist along lush, tree-lined streets.

Heart of the Neighborhood

Carnegie Hill encompasses much of the famed Museum Mile, with institutions like the Guggenheim bringing curated art, workshops, and events to the public.

Neighborhood Quirk

The eponymous Carnegie Mansion, located at 91st Street and Fifth Avenue, now houses the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum.

Best Perk

Central Park is basically your backyard, with landmarks like the Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoir and the iconic cast-iron Bridge No. 28 at your fingertips.

Biggest Downside

When it comes to housing stock, new developments are few and far between. Great news for history lovers, but you may be hard-pressed if you’re looking for amenity-rich modern builds.

Prices shown are base rent only and don't include any fees. Visit each listing to see a complete cost breakdown.

$1.3M

Median Sale

View All Sales

$4,250

Median Base Rent

View All Rentals

The Mood

Gilded Age mansions, Romanesque Revival rowhouses, and prewar apartment buildings co-exist along lush, tree-lined streets.

Heart of the Neighborhood

Carnegie Hill encompasses much of the famed Museum Mile, with institutions like the Guggenheim bringing curated art, workshops, and events to the public.

Neighborhood Quirk

The eponymous Carnegie Mansion, located at 91st Street and Fifth Avenue, now houses the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum.

Best Perk

Central Park is basically your backyard, with landmarks like the Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoir and the iconic cast-iron Bridge No. 28 at your fingertips.

Biggest Downside

When it comes to housing stock, new developments are few and far between. Great news for history lovers, but you may be hard-pressed if you’re looking for amenity-rich modern builds.

What’s close by

Rental prices shown are base rent only and don't include any fees.

1. Lenox Hill

Median Sale: $1.3M Median Base Rent: $4,250

2. Yorkville

Median Sale: N/A Median Base Rent: N/A

3. East Harlem

Median Sale: $607K Median Base Rent: $3,100

By the Numbers

Carnegie Hill’s greater neighborhood, the Upper East Side, had a median asking price of $1.495M in 2025 compared to Manhattan’s $1.35M. Buyers can expect decent inventory of co-ops from the relatively affordable to the luxurious, and a few condos. The Upper East Side’s median asking rent was $3,950 in 2025, below the borough median of $4,445, but rental inventory in Carnegie Hill tends to be quite limited.

Sales
Rentals

Median Price

Price History

Neighborhood Borough Median

Rental prices shown are base rent only and don't include any fees.

Median Base Rent

Price History

Neighborhood Borough Median

*Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2013 ACS

Located in Central Park stretching from 86th to 96th Streets, the Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoir includes a 1.58-mile path, gorgeous seasonal blooms, and a peaceful body of water home to over 20 distinct species of waterbirds.

Museum Mile is a mile-long stretch of important artistic and cultural institutions that border Central Park all along Fifth Avenue. Admire textiles, product design, and works on paper at the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum dedicated to design across the ages.

Two other notable museums along Museum Mile include the Guggenheim, showcasing both Impressionist and modern art and known for its iconic spiral shape; and the Jewish Museum, housing a diverse array of art reflecting the global Jewish experience.

Ajay Suresh from New York, NY, USA, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

View Gallery 11 photos

Food & Drink

Cozy eateries and cafes can be found nestled throughout the residential streets across Carnegie Hill, contributing to a sense of integrated community rather than a distinct restaurant row or nightlife section. The French Pascalou and Italian Sfoglia are local favorites, and be sure to grab a gourmet Italian sandwich from Milano Market.