Renovating in NYC
This week, StreetEasy held The Insider’s Guide to Renovating in NYC, our first-ever renovation event, which brought more than 100 New Yorkers to TileBar in Chelsea.
Two panels of experts, including Instagram’s well-known Brownstone Boys and interior designer Natasha Habermann, spoke to a packed house about what to expect from a renovation timeline and budget, how to find and manage the necessary professionals, and how to design with resale value in mind.
If you attended the event, please let us know what you thought in this brief survey.
Renovation Event: Full Video Recap
Watch a full video of the event below.
Part 1: The Nuts and Bolts of Renovating in NYC
The first panel discussion focused on renovation costs and timelines, and included Barry Bordelon and Jordan Slocum of The Brownstone Boys, who are bloggers, project managers, and current renovators of a 120-year-old Brooklyn brownstone; Adam Dahill of Citizens Bank, a renovation-loan expert and restorer of historic brownstones; and moderator Amory Wooden, senior director of marketing at StreetEasy and four-time gut renovator.
Barry Bordelon kicked it off by saying that there are five essential parts of any renovation team: the architect, the general contractor, any specialists, a project manager, and a designer. Not all of these will be necessary for every project, depending on the scale and demands.
More on Renovating in NYC
But most renovations will need an architect, and Bordelon advised finding that team member first. That’s the person “who you tell all your hopes and dreams to,” he said.
As for how to find these pros, Bordelon suggested asking around a lot and interviewing candidates carefully before selecting any.
About the timeline: Bordelon suggested that a light, surface-level renovation could be done in a few months, while a full gut renovation will likely take more than a year.
A major factor in that timeline is pulling city permits. Everyone advised using an expediter to get plans approved by city hall and then get the necessary permits. “It just makes things go much more smoothly,” Amory Wooden said. Many architects or project managers will have expediters they recommend.
None of the panelists advised living in a home while it’s undergoing a substantial renovation. “Dust is going to get everywhere,” Adam Dahill said.
Renovation often requires considerable oversight from the homeowner, especially during construction, when you’ll want to keep an eye on work as it’s happening. If you have a full-time job or a demanding schedule, the panelists advised hiring a project manager to help with this.
As for financing a renovation, Dahill noted that Citizens Bank, where he works, is one of two banks in New York that does construction loans as well as purchase and renovation loans. In the former, the bank would loan money for the reno work alone. In the latter, the bank makes a loan for the total cost of the home purchase and the renovation, up to as much as 80% of the total final value after work is completed.
To get these loans, Dahill noted that borrowers will need a team and plans in place already. The bank will want to see specs, plans, a budget, and other details.
Brooklyn 3-5Brs Under $2M Article continues below
If a construction loan isn’t an option, Dahill advised either taking out a home equity line of credit or a cash-out refinancing of the home. The former could get a renovator 80% to 90% of their home equity in cash, he said.
Asked about their biggest mistakes in past renovations, Bordelon mentioned not ordering enough materials, which caused delays in the process, and Dahill said his biggest mistake was going with the lowest bidder on a project. A super-low bid “will usually come back to bite you in the backside,” he said.
Part 2: High-Value Projects and Designing for the Long-Term
The second panel focused on the end goal of a home renovation and finding ways to make it pay off when the home is sold. It featured Natasha Habermann of Natasha Habermann Studio, an interior designer and small-space expert, and Jason Saft, Founder of Staged to Sell Home and real estate agent at Compass, with moderator Amory Wooden.
Asked what kind of renovation work costs the most, Jason Saft said it’s always moving big stuff, like areas with plumbing (ie, kitchens and bathrooms) or mechanical elements. Both Saft and Natasha Habermann noted that there are many ways to save on kitchen and bathroom surfaces, largely by forgoing designer materials in favor of ones that looks similar but cost considerably less.
More on Renovating in NYC
Habermann advised checking out what high-end home stores are stocking, then looking for similar items at places like Home Depot. “Shop high, then buy low,” she said.
No matter what plans you go into a renovation with, and what budget expectations you have, “Be prepared to make mistakes, and embrace them,” Saft said.
When it comes to renovating a small living space, Habermann advised making a list of everything you’re storing, and planning for that from the start. As for the look and feel of a smaller space, “try to create almost rooms within a room,” she said — using accent walls and furniture to make a given space work for multiple purposes.
“No one ever has enough storage space, no matter how much money they have,” Saft said.
Manhattan 2-3BRs Under $1.3M Article continues below
Both Habermann and Saft advised that if a renovator isn’t into design, and doesn’t feel confident in their taste, they shouldn’t take risks with unusual colors or patterns in permanent places like kitchen or bathroom surfaces. So no, those pink cabinets may not be a good idea. Saft said this advice doesn’t apply to things you can pick up and move.
But “if there’s one thing you really want, go for it, and you can change it later,” he said.
Saft also advised not being in a hurry — acknowledging that this can be a challenge for over-scheduled New Yorkers. Both he and Habermann said some of their biggest mistakes in renovating came because they were in too much of a rush. “It’s your home — breathe a little bit and figure out ‘what do I need and what do I not need,’” he said.
More on Renovating in NYC
For more on renovating your home, check out our online guide to renovating in NYC.
—
Inspired to find your next place in New York? Whether you’re looking to rent or to buy, search NYC apartments on StreetEasy.