Skip Navigation
StreetEasy Logo

$5,000

For Rent

Base rent only. For total monthly price and additional fees, see .

- ft²

2 rooms

2 beds

1 bath

Under NYC law, you can't be charged a broker fee if you didn't hire a broker.

Learn more

Listed By

Owner

WANT TO STAY UPDATED?Save this home for email and push notifications on price and more.

This home has been saved by 3 users.

Listing by Owner

Available

2/1/2026

Days on market

2 days

Last price change

No changes

About

Elegant 2-Bedroom Brownstone Apartment in Yorkville

Located just off East End Avenue on a quiet, tree-lined block, this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment is nestled in a classic Upper East Side brownstone near the East River. With Carl Schurz Park and Gracie Mansion just a few blocks away, you're surrounded by greenery, history, and peaceful riverfront paths.

Policies

Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.

Home features

No info on home features

Building amenities

Services and facilities

  • Laundry in building

Wellness and recreation

No info on wellness and recreation

Shared outdoor space

No info on shared outdoor space

About the building

538 East 89th Street

538 East 89th Street, New York, NY 10128

Rental building inYorkville

11 units

5 stories

1910 built

Property history

Prices shown are base rent only. For total monthly price and additional fees, see .

DateBase rentEvent

12/2/2025

$5,000

Listed by Owner

5/14/2018

$3,500

No longer available

5/2/2018

$3,500

Listed by Sotheby's International Realty

11/30/2016

$3,500

No longer available

10/28/2016

$3,500

Listed by Sotheby's International Realty

Past listing photos

Sign in to take a closer look at how this home compares to similar homes.

Explore Yorkville

Transit

LocationDistance

Qat 86th St

0.37 miles

Qat 96th St

0.46 miles

456at 86th St

0.61 miles

6at 96th St

0.69 miles

6at 77th St

0.84 miles

About Yorkville

Rental prices shown are base rent before any fees. Visit listings for cost and fees breakdown.

SalesMedian asking price

2 beds

$1.3M

RentalsMedian asking base rent

2 beds

$4,600

When George Washington commandeered the building site that would eventually become Gracie Mansion, he probably didn't imagine that this peaceful, riverside enclave would become the lively residential neighborhood it is today. Between then and now, Yorkville has seen a lot of change. Tony mansions and elevated trains went up at the turn of the century and then came down in the postwar years as a middle-class population moved in.

Now, the neighborhood is a haven of high-rise co-ops and condos interspersed with quiet rows of townhouses. The mixed housing stock makes Yorkville a practical choice for anyone seeking a slowed-down Manhattan vibe. Several avenues over from the throngs of Lexington and Third Avenues, Yorkville maintains a low-key, no-frills feel — it's a place where you'll find more diners and donut shops than upscale lounges and boutiques. This homey attitude is writ in its storefronts, where the food is kept simple and the owners are often from around the block.

Learn more about Yorkville

Similar Homes looks at ad spend and other factors like location, price, and number of beds and baths.