Skip Navigation
Printed from StreetEasy.com at 11:05 AM, Mar 10 2026

409 East 58th St. #TH1

Located at 409 East 58th Street 409 East 58th Street, #Th1, Manhattan, NY Sutton Place, Midtown East
This unit is not currently listed on StreetEasy
5 beds, 6 baths, 3,200 ft²

Step into a gorgeous bright and airy private townhouse with 12ft ceilings, beautiful hardwood floors, a private 50’ garden, finished rooftop deck,and basement. Tucked away on a quiet tree-lined street in the exclusive Sutton Place, 409 East 58th Street is a 3200sq ft semi-detached, four story,...

Step into a gorgeous bright and airy private townhouse with 12ft ceilings, beautiful hardwood floors, a private 50’ garden, finished rooftop deck,and basement. Tucked away on a quiet tree-lined street in the exclusive Sutton Place, 409 East 58th Street is a 3200sq ft semi-detached, four story, single family townhouse in excellent condition with five bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, an enormous amount of storage, original marble mantle fire places and a lovely deck leading out onto the garden.

When you step into this pre-war townhouse, you will notice immediately that the original doors to the home have been carefully restored and preserved, as were the handrails and staircase. An excellent facade and traditional townhouse feel with a parlor and garden level entrances. The garden level boasts a chefs open kitchen with stainless steel appliances, opening up to the lovely garden, perfect for entertaining. The parlor level has a vast living room and formal dining area. The private rooftop is an oasis with its calming atmosphere. The unfinished basement gives you the opportunity to create additional livable square footage in the home.
The beauty of this special home is the endless possibilities. For developers, to turn this home into an income producing property or a gut renovated single family home is ideal. As an end user, move right into this turnkey townhouse as is, or renovate it to your liking and make this a very special home for your family. As an investor, return this townhouse to its original use as a three family, income producing home in the heart of Sutton Place, enticing with its close proximity to Midtown, the United Nations, a plethora of top NYC restaurants, upscale shopping and all methods of transportation.
A versatile home in a highly desired NYC neighborhood!
A zoning analysis will be provided upon request.


See a problem with this listing? Report it here.

About the Building

409 East 58th Street  New York, NY 10022

Three-Family Home in Sutton Place

  • 1 Unit
  • 4 Stories
  • 1899 Built

Sales listings: 7 previous
Rentals listings: 5 previous
Documents and Permits: 15 documents

Unit History

Nearby

Transportation

  • N R 4 5 6 W at Lexington Av-59 St

    0.31 miles

  • F Q at 63rd Street

    0.38 miles

  • E M 6 at Lexington Av-53 St

    0.4 miles

  • F Q at Lexington Av

    0.48 miles

  • E M 6 at 51st St

    0.53 miles

View subway lines on Google Maps

Schools

District 02 - Schools zoned for this address:
East Side Elementary School, PS 267

(0K,01,02,03,04,05,SE)

Disclaimer: School attendance zone boundaries are not guaranteed to be accurate – they are provided by a third party and subject to change. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.