image of million-dollar neighborhoods nyc

… But not all of them. One of the newest million-dollar neighborhoods in NYC is the Lower East Side.

Though the New York City sales market is cooling at the moment, there have been some major new arrivals to the city’s club of million-dollar neighborhoods over the last five years.

In 2010, only four neighborhoods in New York had a median recorded sales price of $1 million or more. Five years ago, that number jumped to 17 which is where it remains today — and two neighborhoods broke the threshold for the very first time this year. Let’s take a look at New York’s newest million-dollar neighborhoods.

image of million dollar neighborhoods nyc

Three New Brooklyn Neighborhoods Join The Million-Dollar Club

Over the past five years, three Brooklyn neighborhoods have crossed the $1 million median recorded sales price threshold.

Brooklyn Heights, Prospect Heights and Williamsburg are the newest additions to New York City’s million-dollar club, with Williamsburg gaining entry for the first time in 2019. (For this list of million dollar neighborhoods, we excluded areas with a median price per square foot below $1,000, to control for neighborhoods with very large homes.)

Prospect Heights has a significant number of single-family homes and townhouses, which of course tend to be more expensive. Williamsburg and Brooklyn Heights also broke the threshold, likely because of their lively atmosphere and desirable location along the East River.

Neighborhood Borough Median Recorded Sales Price in 2019
Brooklyn Heights Brooklyn $1,010,000
East Village Manhattan $1,071,000
Gramercy Park Manhattan $1,405,185
Lower East Side Manhattan $1,371,587
Prospect Heights Brooklyn $1,160,000
Williamsburg Brooklyn $1,038,863

Manhattan Is Still Home to Most of NYC’s Million-dollar Neighborhoods

During the second quarter of 2019, price growth in the outer boroughs was stronger than in Manhattan, as prospective buyers sought relative affordability. Prices in Manhattan fell 3.7%, but remained stagnant in Brooklyn, and rose in Queens by 1.5%.

That said, Manhattan is still home to the majority of NYC’s million-dollar neighborhoods, and half of the six that joined the ranks since 2015 were in the borough. Gramercy Park, the East Village and the Lower East Side all crossed the $1 million threshold in the past five years.

In the Lower East Side, recorded sales prices have doubled in the past five years, and a number of sales in high-end new developments this year have pushed the neighborhood’s median home price over the $1 million threshold for the first time.

See below for a list of all million dollar neighborhoods.

Neighborhood Median Recorded Sales Price
Tribeca $4,100,000
SoHo $2,725,000
Flatiron $2,163,781
Midtown $2,000,000
Greenpoint $1,578,287
Greenwich Village $1,575,000
Gramercy Park $1,405,185
Lower East Side $1,371,587
West Village $1,300,000
Chelsea $1,270,000
Upper East Side $1,250,000
Upper West Side $1,225,000
Park Slope $1,191,000
Prospect Heights $1,160,000
East Village $1,071,000
Williamsburg $1,038,863
Brooklyn Heights $1,010,000

Which Areas Will Be Next?

Even though the sales market is cooling, we expect the number of million-dollar neighborhoods to keep growing. We could even see the very first Queens neighborhood join these ranks sooner rather than later. Our eyes are on Long Island City, where the median recorded sales price is currently $903,419 — 10% higher than it was five years ago.

How We Did It

Our list of NYC’s million-dollar neighborhoods consists of neighborhoods in the city where there were at least 100 annual recorded sales between the years 2015 and 2019. Of those recorded sales, the median recorded sales price must have been greater than or equal to $1,000,000 for the area to be considered a million-dollar neighborhood. Neighborhoods with a price per square foot below $1,000 were excluded to control for overall dwelling size.

Inspired to find your next place in New York? Whether you’re looking to rent or to buy, search NYC apartments on StreetEasy.