171 Sheldon Avenue

$1,374,999

for sale

Price Drop$50,001

- ft²

7 rooms

5 beds

3.5 baths

Two-family home
Annadale
Resale

This home has been saved by 3 users.

Listing by Platinum Property Management LLC, Real Estate Principal Office, 244 Detroit Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10312

Report listing

Common charges

Not applicable

Estimated payment

$7,411/mo

Taxes

No info

Tax abatement

No info

About

Seller’s agent

Jennifer Rella

Licensed Real Estate Broker

Platinum Property Management LLC

Description

Live in the spacious main residence and rent out the separate two-bedroom apartment, or explore renting both. Built in 2017, this custom detached two-family Colonial at 171 Sheldon Avenue sits on a 5,500 sq. ft. lot on Staten Island’s South Shore.

The three-bedroom main residence opens to bright living and dining areas with soaring ceilings, custom millwork, and recessed lighting.

Policies

Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.

Home features

Central air
Fireplace
Private outdoor space
Balcony
Washer/dryer

Building amenities

Services and facilities

Parking
Garage

Wellness and recreation

No info on wellness and recreation

Shared outdoor space

No info on shared outdoor space

About the building

171 Sheldon Avenue

171 Sheldon Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10312

Two-family house in Annadale

2 units

2 stories

2017 built

For sale

1 available units for sale

For rent

0 available units for rent

Learn more about 171 Sheldon Avenue

Property history

Price change: ↓ $50,001 (-3.5%) on 11/5/26
Days on market: 61 days

Date	Price	Event
11/5/2026	$1,374,999	Price decreased by 4%
9/15/2026	$1,425,000	Price increased by 2%
9/11/2026	$1,397,000	Listed by Platinum Property Management LLC

Explore Annadale

Schools

District 31

Schools zoned for this address:

I.S. 075 Frank D. Paulo

06, 07, 08, SE

P.S. 036 J. C. Drumgoole

PK, 0K, 01, 02, 03, 04, 05, SE

Tottenville High School

09, 10, 11, 12, SE

School attendance zone boundaries are not guaranteed to be accurate — they are provided by a third party and subject to change. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.

View on Google Maps