3 units for rent in this building

Rental prices shown are base rent only and don't include any fees. Visit each listing to see a complete cost breakdown.

Skip to the end of the carousel

RENTAL in Sutton Place

238 East 58th Street, #17

$3,950

base rent

2 beds

1 bath

Listing by REAL New York

RENTAL in Sutton Place

238 East 58th Street, #12

$3,950

base rent

2 beds

1 bath

Listing by Brighton Management

RENTAL in Sutton Place

238 East 58th Street, #15

$4,395

base rent

2 beds

1 bath

Listing by Brighton Management

Skip to the beginning of the carousel

1 of 2

238 East 58th Street

238 East 58th Street, New York, NY 10022

22 units

6 stories

1904 built

See a problem with this building?Report it here

About

Welcome to 238 East 58th Street, an inviting pre-war walk-up building nestled in the heart of Sutton Place. This six-story walk-up apartment building offers a collection of well-appointed one and two-bedroom apartments.

Our apartments feature custom kitchen millwork, Calacatta quartz countertops and backsplash, modern European stainless steel appliances, and convenient built-in closets to meet your storage needs. You’ll also appreciate the cove lighting throughout the apartments, dimmers in select locations, and the added security and convenience of a virtual doorman.

Facts

Development status: Completed
District: Community District 106City Council District 4Police Precinct 17
Building class: C7
Documents and permits: View documents and permits

Available units

Prices shown are base rent only and don't include any fees. Visit each listing to see a complete cost breakdown.

#17

$3,950

Available: Now

2 beds

1 bath

- ft²

Listing by REAL New York

#12

$3,950

Price Drop$380

Open house: Dec 5 (8 AM–8 PM ET), by appt only

Available: Now

2 beds

1 bath

- ft²

Listing by Brighton Management

#15

$4,395

Open house: Dec 5 (8 AM–8 PM ET), by appt only

Available: Now

2 beds

1 bath

- ft²

Listing by Brighton Management

Unavailable sales

			Status				Floor plan
11/08/21		$7,300,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
11/30/12		$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	-	- baths	15,532 ft²	-

Unavailable rentals

						Floor plan
11/22/25	#11	$4,395	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/18/25	#10	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/15/25	#13	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/13/25	#4	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/26/25	#3	$5,250	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/10/25	#16	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
08/14/25	#7	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
08/12/25	#14	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
07/12/25	#9	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
04/22/25	#5	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
04/14/25	#18	$10,000	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
03/31/25	#8	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
03/10/25	#6	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
02/13/25	#29	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
02/12/25	#25	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
01/28/25	#36	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
01/07/25	#38	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
01/03/25	#20	$10,000	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
01/02/25	#21	$10,000	1 bed	1 bath	800 ft²	-
12/21/24	#32	$10,000	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
12/13/24	#22	$3,250	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
12/06/24	#26	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/12/24	#6A	$4,050	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/05/24	#6R	$3,350	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/12/24	#6F	$4,500	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/26/24	#22B	$3,750	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/26/24	#25A	$4,495	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
07/09/24	#22A	$3,895	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
07/09/24	#14A	$3,995	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
07/02/24	#10A	$10,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
04/03/24	#19	$1,000	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/06/23	#18A	$1,000	Studio	0 baths	- ft²	-
02/15/23	#12B	$4,000	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/08/22	#12A	$4,250	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
08/15/22	#4A	$3,800	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
04/27/22	#28	$4,500	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
12/14/20	#27	$2,600	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/12/20	#17A	$2,500	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/26/20	#15B	$2,500	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/25/20	#15A	$1,895	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/06/20	#30	$2,200	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
01/10/20	#15D	$2,700	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/25/19	#13A	$2,445	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
08/12/19	#17C	$2,525	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
07/19/19	#17D	$2,350	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
07/10/19	#17AA	$2,350	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/01/18	#A12	$2,595	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/21/18	#A16	$3,300	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/07/18	#16A	$3,195	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/04/17	#23	$2,400	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/19/08	#SFW	$4,695	Studio	1 bath	500 ft²	-

Policies

No info on policies

Amenities

No info on amenities

Unit features

Not all features are available in every unit.

Central air
Dishwasher
Hardwood floors
View
City

Explore Sutton Place

Transit

Location	Distance
NRW456at Lexington Av/59th St	0.13 miles
EM6at Lexington Av–53rd St	0.25 miles
FQat Lexington Av/63rd St	0.32 miles
EM6at 51st St	0.37 miles
EMat 5th Av–53rd St	0.43 miles