$5,300
For Rent
Base rent only. For total monthly price and additional fees, see .
Rented 7/17/2025
- ft²
4 rooms
2 beds
1 bath
Rental unit
- Upper West Side
Under NYC law, you can't be charged a broker fee if you didn't hire a broker.
Listed By
This home has been saved by 38 users.
Listing by Coldwell Banker Warburg, 654 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10065
Unavailable
Rented on 7/17/2025
Days on market
8 days
Last price change
No changes
About
Fabulous 2 bedroom apartment in lovely historic Georgian Revival Townhouse. Have morning coffee on your private terrace, Working fireplace for those cold winter nights, The primary bedroom fits a queen sized bed, dresser and more. The second bedroom has a private terrace and lovely northern light and can accommodate a queen sized bed plus more. Soaring ceilings with skylights plus additional sleep/storage loft in living area.
Policies
Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.
Home features
Dishwasher
Fireplace
Hardwood floors
Private outdoor space
Balcony
Building amenities
Sorry, building amenities aren't available right now. Check back later.
About the building
257 West 91st Street
257 West 91st Street, New York, NY 10024
11 units
4 stories
1900 built
Property history
Prices shown are base rent only. For total monthly price and additional fees, see .
| Date | Base rent | Event |
|---|---|---|
7/17/2025 | $5,300 | Rented by Coldwell Banker Warburg |
7/9/2025 | $5,300 | Listed by Coldwell Banker Warburg |
7/29/2023 | $4,500 | |
7/26/2023 | $4,500 | Price decreased by 6% |
7/18/2023 | $4,795 | Price decreased by 4% |
Past listing photos
Sign in to take a closer look at how this home compares to similar homes.
Explore Upper West Side
Transit
| Location | Distance |
|---|---|
123at 96th St | 0.12 miles |
1at 86th St | 0.22 miles |
BCat 86th St | 0.49 miles |
BCat 96th St | 0.52 miles |
1at 103rd St | 0.6 miles |
About Upper West Side
Rental prices shown are base rent before any fees. Visit listings for cost and fees breakdown.
SalesMedian asking price
2 beds
$1.6M
RentalsMedian asking base rent
2 beds
$6,295
Sandwiched between two beautiful parks, the Upper West Side is one of the greenest spots in Manhattan. For that reason, it is a perennial favorite. The Upper West Side is relaxed, but never dull. There are plenty of low-key bars and restaurants to frequent along Amsterdam Avenue, and Broadway is an always-bustling commercial center. The wide, tree-lined streets still boast many mom-and-pop stores. Less posh than the Upper East Side, it is more easily accessible by public transportation, and real estate prices are just as, if not more, expensive.
Learn more about Upper West SideSimilar homes
Prices shown are base rent only and don't include any fees. Visit each listing to see a complete cost breakdown.
Rental unit in Upper West Side
150 West 92nd Street #3D- 2 beds
- 2 baths
- - ft²
Listing by OvCo Realty
previousnextRental unit in Upper West Side
784 Columbus Avenue #12J$4,641 net effective base rent
1 month free·16-month lease- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- 825 ft²
Listing by R New York
previousnextRental unit in Upper West Side
202 Riverside Drive #9B- 2 beds
- 2 baths
- - ft²
Listing by ONE Manhattan Real Estate
previousnext
previousnextRental unit in Upper West Side
792 Columbus Avenue #12K$5,367 net effective base rent
1 month free·15-month lease- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- 915 ft²
Listing by R New York
previousnextRental unit in Upper West Side
101 W. 90th Street #5K- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- 788 ft²
Listing by Realty Operations Group
previousnextCo-op in Upper West Side
102 West 80th Street #26- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by City Wide Apartments
previousnextRental unit in Upper West Side
146 West 83rd Street #9- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- 615 ft²
Listing by Kalos Realty NY LLC
previousnextRental unit in Upper West Side
792 Columbus Avenue #14C$5,288 net effective base rent
1 month free·14-month lease- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- - ft²
Listing by Stellar Management
previousnextSimilar Homes looks at ad spend and other factors like location, price, and number of beds and baths.