2586 Broadway #2J

$5,400

for rent

Base rent only. Price may not include required fees and charges.

- ft²

4 rooms

2 beds

1 bath

Rental unit
Upper West Side

Under NYC law, you can't be charged a broker fee if you didn't hire a broker.

Learn more

Listed by

Zoey Brucker

220 West 98 Realty LLC

Listing by 220 West 98 Realty LLC

Report listing

Available

10/1/2026

Days on market

Listed today

Last price change

No changes

About

Welcome to this charming pre-war 2-bedroom on the Upper West Side, offering classic New York character and a comfortable, well-proportioned layout. The home features gracious living spaces, beautiful period details, and the warmth and scale that make pre-war apartments so special.

The two bedrooms provide excellent flexibility, while the spacious living area is ideal for both everyday living and entertaining.

Policies

Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.

Home features

Hardwood floors

Building amenities

Services and facilities

Doorman
Elevator
Laundry in building
Live-in super

Wellness and recreation

No info on wellness and recreation

Shared outdoor space

No info on shared outdoor space

About the building

2586 Broadway

2586 Broadway, New York, NY 10025

Rental building inUpper West Side

133 units

12 stories

1911 built

For rent

2 available units for rent

Documents and permits

View documents and permits

Learn more about 2586 Broadway

Property history

Prices shown are base rent only. For total monthly price and additional fees, see .

Date	Base rent	Event
9/23/2026	$5,400	Listed by 220 West 98 Realty LLC
6/18/2012	$3,600	No longer available
5/10/2012	$3,600	Price increased by 7%
5/10/2012	$3,375	Listed by Platinum Brokerage Group, LLC
5/24/2011	$3,375	Rented by Platinum Brokerage Group, LLC

Past listing photos

5/24/2011

Explore Upper West Side

Transit

Location	Distance
123at 96th St	0.12 miles
1at 103rd St	0.27 miles
BCat 96th St	0.38 miles
BCat 103rd St	0.47 miles
1at 86th St	0.55 miles

View transit on Google Maps

View on Google Maps

About Upper West Side

Sales

Median asking price

2 beds

$1.59M

Rentals

Median asking base rent

2 beds

$6,822

Sandwiched between two beautiful parks, the Upper West Side is one of the greenest spots in Manhattan. For that reason, it is a perennial favorite. The Upper West Side is relaxed, but never dull. There are plenty of low-key bars and restaurants to frequent along Amsterdam Avenue, and Broadway is an always-bustling commercial center. The wide, tree-lined streets still boast many mom-and-pop stores. Less posh than the Upper East Side, it is more easily accessible by public transportation, and real estate prices are just as, if not more, expensive.

Learn more about Upper West Side