2 available units in this building

Rental prices shown are base rent only and don't include any fees. Visit each listing to see a complete cost breakdown.

Skip to the end of the carousel

CO_OP in Sutton Place

436 East 58th Street, #1C

$399,000

Studio

1 bath

Listing by Compass

CO_OP in Sutton Place

436 East 58th Street, #1C

$3,000

base rent

Studio

1 bath

Listing by Compass

Skip to the beginning of the carousel

1 of 2

436 East 58th Street

436 East 58th Street, New York, NY 10022

24 units

5 stories

1890 built

Take the next step on a unit in this building.

See a problem with this building?Report it here

About

This intimate Sutton Place coop was built in 1890 and has lots of prewar charm like high ceilings and wide plank hardwood floors. Many units have fireplaces.. 436 and 434 East 58th are part of the same coop. Each building has its own elevator and they share a laundry room. The coop has superb financials. This is a reasonable coop that permits co-purchasing, pied-a-terres and subletting. The coop is located on a beautiful block off Sutton Place. Dogs are not permitted.

Facts

Development status: Completed
District: Community District 106City Council District 5Police Precinct 17
Building class: C6
Documents and permits: View documents and permits

Available units

#1C

$399,000

Resale

Studio

1 bath

- ft²

Listing by Compass

Unavailable sales

			Status				Floor plan
11/24/25	#4CD	$795,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	2 beds	2 baths	- ft²
01/26/24	#1D	$307,000	Sold (asking: $319,000; -3.76%)	Studio	1 bath	- ft²
09/05/23	#4B	$425,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
12/15/21	#2C	$385,000	Sold (asking: $399,000; -3.51%)	Studio	1 bath	- ft²
09/09/20	#5A	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	-	- baths	- ft²	-
11/07/19	#6B	$499,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	600 ft²
08/27/19	#3C	$376,000	Sold (asking: $379,000; -0.79%)	Studio	1 bath	428 ft²
07/11/14	#6D	$390,000	Sold (asking: $399,000; -2.26%)	Studio	1 bath	- ft²
02/25/14	#4C	$400,000	Sold (asking: $375,000; 6.67%)	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
02/24/14	#4D	$400,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
11/15/13	#5B	$420,000	Recorded closing	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/29/10	#4A	$315,000	Sold (asking: $335,000; -5.97%)	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
05/10/06	#3A	$389,000	Recorded closing	1 bed	1 bath	600 ft²	-
02/15/06	#2B	$340,000	Sold (asking: $350,000; -2.86%)	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/09/04	#6A	$335,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-

Unavailable rentals

						Floor plan
11/13/25	#4CD	$4,995	2 beds	2 baths	- ft²
09/27/24	#1B	$2,500	Studio	1 bath	- ft²
07/23/24	#1A	$2,300	Studio	1 bath	- ft²	-
06/07/24	#3A	$3,200	1 bed	1 bath	600 ft²
03/27/24	#5B	$2,995	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
07/13/23	#3B	$3,200	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
06/28/23	#6D	$2,950	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
07/28/22	#1D	$2,400	Studio	1 bath	- ft²
08/12/21	#2C	$2,200	Studio	1 bath	- ft²
06/23/21	#2B	$2,275	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
05/18/21	#B2	$2,300	1 bed	1 bath	600 ft²	-
07/24/19	#C2	$2,400	Studio	1 bath	- ft²	-
07/16/19	#A2	$2,400	Studio	1 bath	- ft²	-
10/11/18	#6C	$2,000	Studio	1 bath	- ft²	-
06/25/18	#4E	$4,700	2 beds	2 baths	- ft²	-
08/14/17	#6B	$2,700	1 bed	1 bath	600 ft²
04/27/16	#2D	$2,100	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/13/14	#6	$2,200	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
08/05/13	#3D	$2,500	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
09/29/11	#4C	$1,800	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
08/10/11	#3C	$2,100	Studio	1 bath	- ft²
06/12/10	#2A	$2,000	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
02/22/08		$2,000	1 bed	1 bath	550 ft²	-

Policies

Co-purchase allowed
Gifts allowed
Guarantors accepted
Pied-a-terre allowed

Amenities

Services and facilities

Elevator
Live-in super

Wellness and recreation

No info on wellness and recreation

Shared outdoor space

No info on shared outdoor space

Unit features

Not all features are available in every unit.

Dishwasher
Fireplace
Decorative
Furnished
Hardwood floors
Private outdoor space
Garden
View
City, Garden

Explore Sutton Place

Transit

Location	Distance
NRW456at Lexington Av/59th St	0.38 miles
EM6at Lexington Av–53rd St	0.42 miles
FQat Lexington Av/63rd St	0.54 miles
EM6at 51st St	0.56 miles
Qat 72nd St	0.61 miles