2 units for sale in this building

Skip to the end of the carousel

CONDO in Carnegie Hill

65 East 96th Street, #4B

$1,999,000

3 beds

2 baths

Listing by Argent Advisors LLC

CONDO in Carnegie Hill

65 East 96th Street, #10B

$2,799,999

3 beds

2.5 baths

Listing by Argent Advisors LLC

Skip to the beginning of the carousel

1 of 3

65 East 96th Street

65 East 96th Street, New York, NY 10128

60 units

16 stories

1924 built

Take the next step on a unit in this building.

See a problem with this building?Report it here

About

One of the few condominiums in Carnegie Hill, The Gatsby is a charming, prewar, full-service building with only four apartments per floor. It underwent a large-scale renovation that took several years, restoring it without compromise to its fine prewar detail and classic style. Built in 1924, the Gatsby is a fabulous full service condominium with a live-in Super, laundry room, basement storage and is steps from Central Park and all major transportation.

Description provided by Jamie Joseph

Facts

Development status: Completed
Developer: ELAD Properties
District: Community District 111City Council District 4Police Precinct 23
Building class: RR
Documents and permits: View documents and permits

Available units

#4B

$1,999,000

Sponsor unit

3 beds

2 baths

1,800 ft²

Listing by Argent Advisors LLC

#10B

$2,799,999

Sponsor unit

3 beds

2.5 baths

1,800 ft²

Listing by Argent Advisors LLC

Unavailable sales

			Status				Floor plan
12/08/25	#15D	$2,799,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3 baths	1,600 ft²
10/31/25	#8D	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	-	- baths	1,557 ft²	-
10/16/25	#3B	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	-	- baths	1,800 ft²	-
08/25/25	#14B	$3,100,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,800 ft²
07/10/25	#16B	$2,084,866	Sold (asking: $2,389,000; -12.73%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,800 ft²	-
05/21/25	#9B	$2,495,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	2 baths	1,800 ft²
10/18/24	#4C	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	2 beds	2 baths	1,309 ft²	-
10/02/24	#16A	$2,625,000	Sold (asking: $2,650,000; -0.94%)	3 beds	2 baths	1,600 ft²
09/09/24	#4A	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	3 beds	2 baths	1,566 ft²	-
07/17/24	#11A	$2,493,000	Sold (asking: $2,599,000; -4.08%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,600 ft²
10/18/23	#7C	$1,555,000	Sold (asking: $1,575,000; -1.27%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,300 ft²
06/23/23	#1D	$1,225,000	Sold (asking: $1,295,000; -5.41%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,265 ft²
09/29/22	#14A	$2,200,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,566 ft²	-
06/22/22	#5CD	$4,350,000	Sold (asking: $4,000,000; 8.75%)	4 beds	3.5 baths	- ft²
05/05/22	#11B	$2,600,000	Recorded closing	3 beds	2 baths	1,800 ft²	-
05/03/22	#9D	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	3 beds	3 baths	1,600 ft²	-
01/24/22	#8B	$2,650,000	Sold (asking: $2,750,000; -3.64%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,800 ft²
08/07/21	#6A	$2,200,000	Sold (asking: $2,250,000; -2.22%)	3 beds	2 baths	1,600 ft²
06/25/21	#10A	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	3 beds	3 baths	1,600 ft²	-
08/11/20	#7D	$2,649,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3 baths	1,600 ft²
10/21/19	#2B	$2,595,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	2.5 baths	- ft²
02/05/19	#6C	$1,585,000	Sold (asking: $1,649,000; -3.88%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,300 ft²
06/09/18	#10C	$1,950,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	2 beds	2 baths	1,309 ft²
07/27/17	#14D	$2,050,000	Recorded closing	3 beds	2 baths	1,566 ft²	-
01/06/17	#PRO1C	$1,965,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,332 ft²	-
12/04/15	#15A	$2,750,000	Sold (asking: $2,795,000; -1.61%)	3 beds	2 baths	1,625 ft²
09/16/15	#1C	$1,859,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	2 beds	2 baths	1,332 ft²
07/14/15	#17R	$3,100,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	2 beds	1.5 baths	- ft²
03/11/15	#5B	$3,195,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3 baths	1,800 ft²	-
06/17/14	#10D	$2,400,000	Sold (asking: $2,450,000; -2.04%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,600 ft²
04/09/14	#11C	$4,350,000	Sold (asking: $4,500,000; -3.33%)	4 beds	5 baths	2,900 ft²
02/04/14	#17F	$3,805,000	Sold (asking: $4,000,000; -4.88%)	3 beds	3.5 baths	1,715 ft²
07/13/13	#PHS	$4,000,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3.5 baths	1,715 ft²	-
05/24/13	#12A	$0	Recorded closing (non-market sale)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,566 ft²	-
04/13/12	#PHF	$3,500,000	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	3.5 baths	- ft²
01/11/11	#PHN	$2,250,000	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	1.5 baths	1,200 ft²
07/01/10	#16C	$1,400,000	Sold (asking: $1,450,000; -3.45%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,309 ft²
06/30/10	#PRO1A	$980,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,231 ft²	-
02/10/10	#16D	$2,099,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	2 baths	1,600 ft²
12/06/09	#3C	$980,000	Sold (asking: $1,075,000; -8.84%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,300 ft²
05/27/06	#5C	$1,527,375	Sold (asking: $1,595,000; -4.24%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,300 ft²	-
09/20/05	#2A	$1,600,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,566 ft²	-
01/06/04	#7A	$1,225,000	Recorded closing	3 beds	2 baths	1,600 ft²	-
04/17/02	#2C	$725,000	Recorded closing	2 beds	1.5 baths	1,300 ft²	-
03/05/02	#5A	$1,171,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,566 ft²	-
09/21/01	#1B	$840,500	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,557 ft²	-
08/22/01	#3A	$1,120,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,566 ft²	-
07/16/01	#12C	$662,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,309 ft²	-
05/25/01	#PRO1	$499,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,231 ft²	-
12/19/00	#14C	$866,000	Recorded closing	2 beds	2 baths	1,300 ft²	-
12/12/00	#19B	$1,013,500	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,566 ft²	-
12/08/00	#5D	$967,500	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,557 ft²	-
11/27/00	#6D	$876,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,557 ft²	-
11/22/00	#SA	$152,500	Recorded closing	-	- baths	1,396 ft²	-

Unavailable rentals

						Floor plan
09/04/24	#10C	$7,500	2 beds	2 baths	1,309 ft²
08/08/24	#4A	$9,000	3 beds	2 baths	1,566 ft²
07/22/24	#14C	$8,500	2 beds	2 baths	1,300 ft²	-
06/21/24	#2C	$7,000	2 beds	1.5 baths	1,300 ft²
02/19/24	#5B	$8,995	4 beds	3 baths	1,800 ft²
12/30/23	#FROF-1C	$2,800	Studio	1 bath	454 ft²	-
10/23/23	#PHR	$10,500	2 beds	1.5 baths	1,251 ft²
05/03/23	#12A	$9,500	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,566 ft²
03/14/23	#14D	$12,500	3 beds	2 baths	1,566 ft²
03/05/23	#1D	$6,200	2 beds	2 baths	- ft²
04/23/21	#17R	$9,000	2 beds	1.5 baths	1,251 ft²
01/29/21	#9B	$9,000	3 beds	2 baths	1,800 ft²
01/25/21	#4D	$1,900	2 beds	1 bath	- ft²	-
11/01/20	#FROF1C	$2,000	Studio	0 baths	1,325 ft²
08/28/19	#11B	$12,000	3 beds	2 baths	1,800 ft²
11/01/18	#9D	$9,750	3 beds	3 baths	1,700 ft²
08/06/18	#5B1	$9,250	4 beds	3 baths	1,900 ft²
04/16/15	#16C	$7,500	2 beds	2 baths	1,309 ft²
12/07/13	#PHS	$15,000	3 beds	3.5 baths	1,715 ft²
04/25/13	#PHF	$14,500	3 beds	3.5 baths	1,450 ft²	-
06/30/11	#PHFU	$15,000	3 beds	3.5 baths	- ft²
05/07/09	#15D	$7,500	3 beds	3 baths	1,600 ft²
11/06/08	#2B	$8,950	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,800 ft²
11/16/06	#7A	$13,000	3 beds	2 baths	1,600 ft²