8 available units in this building

Skip to the end of the carousel

condo in Turtle Bay

959 First Avenue, #6F

$1,300,000

1 bed

1 bath

Listing by Compass

condo in Turtle Bay

959 First Avenue, #17B

$1,900,000

1 bed

1 bath

Listing by Corcoran

condo in Turtle Bay

959 First Avenue, #6P

$2,200,000

2 beds

2.5 baths

Listing by Compass

condo in Turtle Bay

959 1st Avenue, #7K

$2,425,000

2 beds

2 baths

Listing by Douglas Elliman

condo in Turtle Bay

959 1st Avenue, #17C

$2,425,000

2 beds

2 baths

Listing by SERHANT.

condo in Turtle Bay

959 First Avenue, #23H

$3,500,000

3 beds

2.5 baths

Listing by FIND Real Estate

condo in Turtle Bay

959 1st Avenue, #12A

$3,575,000

3 beds

2.5 baths

Listing by CORE

condo in Turtle Bay

959 1st Avenue, #7X

$6,000

base rent

1 bed

1 bath

Listing by Undivided Inc

Skip to the beginning of the carousel

1 of 15

The Sutton

959 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10022

113 units

29 stories

2016 built

Thinking of selling your home?

Get in touch with an agent who has experience selling in this building.

Daniella Schlisser

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Brown Harris Stevens

44

NYC Condo sales in the last 10 years

7

years selling in Turtle Bay

View full profile

Take the next step on a unit in this building.

See a problem with this building?Report it here

About

The Sutton at 959 First Avenue is a distinguished full-service condominium that has become one of Sutton Place’s premier residential addresses. Developed by Toll Brothers City Living and designed by Goldstein Hill & West, the building combines timeless craftsmanship with modern luxury, featuring its signature Roman brick façade, elegant proportions, and thoughtfully curated interiors inspired by classic New York architecture.

Facts

Development status: Completed
Owner: UNAVAILABLE OWNER
Developer: Toll Brothers City Living
Architect: Goldstein Hill & West
Interior design: Incorporated NY
District: Community District 106City Council District 4Police Precinct 17
Building class: K4
Documents and permits: View documents and permits

Available units

#6F

$1,300,000

Resale

1 bed

1 bath

827 ft²

Listing by Compass

#17B

$1,900,000

Resale

1 bed

1 bath

895 ft²

Listing by Corcoran

#7K

$2,425,000

Resale

2 beds

2 baths

1,384 ft²

Listing by Douglas Elliman

#17C

$2,425,000

Resale

2 beds

2 baths

1,349 ft²

Listing by SERHANT.

#23H

$3,500,000

Resale

3 beds

2.5 baths

1,798 ft²

Listing by FIND Real Estate

#12A

$3,575,000

Resale

3 beds

2.5 baths

1,947 ft²

Listing by CORE

#6P

$2,200,000

Resale

In contract

2 beds

2.5 baths

1,428 ft²

Listing by Compass

#7X

$6,000

In contract

1 bed

1 bath

736 ft²

Listing by Undivided Inc

Unavailable sales

			Status				Floor plan
10/28/26	#19D	$2,350,000	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,370 ft²
12/23/25	#20D	$1,400,000	Recorded closing	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,370 ft²	-
11/05/25	#25H	$3,500,000	Sold (asking: $3,999,000; -12.48%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,798 ft²
11/03/25	#8X	$1,395,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	742 ft²	-
10/31/25	#6G	$4,300,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	2.5 baths	2,472 ft²
10/30/25	#25E	$1,895,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
08/04/25	#19AB	$6,095,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	4 beds	3.5 baths	2,904 ft²
07/01/25	#12B	$1,412,500	Sold (asking: $1,425,000; -0.88%)	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
06/18/25	#15D	$2,450,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,367 ft²
03/28/25	#10D	$1,999,900	Recorded closing	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,600 ft²	-
03/20/24	#24B	$1,995,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
02/28/24	#25A	$3,550,000	Sold (asking: $3,695,000; -3.92%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
01/02/24	#10C	$2,200,000	Sold (asking: $2,325,000; -5.38%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²
08/29/23	#21H	$3,565,000	Sold (asking: $3,650,000; -2.33%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,798 ft²
07/08/23	#20B	$1,895,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
05/31/23	#11A	$3,415,000	Sold (asking: $3,500,000; -2.43%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,950 ft²
12/06/22	#23A	$1,972,500	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
08/03/22	#14B	$1,700,000	Recorded closing	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²	-
06/17/22	#8P	$2,625,000	Sold (asking: $2,650,000; -0.94%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,428 ft²
04/27/22	#12D	$2,600,000	Sold (asking: $2,650,000; -1.89%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,367 ft²
04/05/22	#20A	$4,250,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
11/23/21	#8J	$3,945,000	Sold (asking: $4,495,000; -12.24%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	- ft²
08/19/21	#11D	$2,350,000	Sold (asking: $2,489,000; -5.58%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,367 ft²
06/30/21	#PH1	$6,500,000	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	3.5 baths	3,356 ft²
06/04/21	#9F	$1,550,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	799 ft²
09/15/20	#PHI	$5,800,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
09/30/19	#23E	$1,810,000	Sold (asking: $1,830,000; -1.09%)	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
09/10/19	#PHR	$8,950,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3.5 baths	3,356 ft²
08/26/19	#9P	$1,995,000	Sold (asking: $1,995,000; 0%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,428 ft²
08/05/19	#26L	$2,850,000	Sold (asking: $2,850,000; 0%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,442 ft²
08/01/19	#11B	$1,527,364	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²
08/01/19	#7R	$1,299,990	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	841 ft²
08/01/19	#7F	$1,282,984	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	799 ft²	-
08/01/19	#15B	$1,619,007	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²	-
08/01/19	#9L	$2,459,063	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2 baths	1,376 ft²	-
08/01/19	#15C	$2,514,990	No longer available on StreetEasy	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²	-
08/01/19	#20C	$2,815,451	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2 baths	1,349 ft²
08/01/19	#18D	$2,907,093	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,370 ft²
08/01/19	#16D	$2,650,000	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,370 ft²	-
08/01/19	#PH2	$9,999,990	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3.5 baths	3,281 ft²	-
08/01/19	#15A	$3,808,244	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,947 ft²	-
08/01/19	#21A	$3,535,270	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
08/01/19	#22H	$3,800,000	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,798 ft²
08/01/19	#17A	$3,800,000	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
04/24/19	#26M	$4,499,000	Sold (asking: $4,499,990; -0.02%)	4 beds	3.5 baths	2,158 ft²
02/27/19	#TC3	$4,799,000	Sold (asking: $4,999,990; -4.02%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,926 ft²
02/04/19	#TC1	$4,700,000	Sold (asking: $4,999,990; -6.00%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,947 ft²
02/01/19	#7RR	$1,475,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	1 bed	1 bath	841 ft²
10/03/18	#26A	$4,307,187	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²	-
10/02/18	#TC2	$5,675,000	Sold (asking: $5,675,000; 0%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	2,272 ft²
05/16/18	#PH	$9,999,990	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3.5 baths	3,356 ft²
04/03/18	#6T	$3,715,000	Sold (asking: $3,819,990; -2.75%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	2,472 ft²
03/24/18	#16A	$3,487,506	Sold (asking: $3,574,990; -2.45%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
03/21/18	#18A	$3,500,000	Sold (asking: $3,634,990; -3.71%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
03/01/18	#7P	$2,153,598	Sold (asking: $2,174,990; -0.98%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,425 ft²
02/20/18	#17D	$2,545,614	Sold (asking: $2,499,990; 1.82%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,370 ft²
11/21/17	#16B	$1,800,000	Sold (asking: $1,885,000; -4.51%)	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
09/28/17	#25B	$1,869,990	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²	-
09/28/17	#11C	$2,394,990	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²
09/28/17	#19A	$5,300,000	Sold (can't find government record)	4 beds	3.5 baths	2,854 ft²	-
04/19/17	#PH3	$7,359,990	No longer available on StreetEasy	3 beds	3.5 baths	2,592 ft²
03/24/17	#17E	$2,749,990	No longer available on StreetEasy	2 beds	2.5 baths	- ft²
03/17/17	#8S	$949,990	Sold (can't find government record)	Studio	1 bath	572 ft²
03/17/17	#10B	$1,506,999	Sold (asking: $1,479,990; 1.82%)	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²
03/17/17	#6X	$1,160,794	Sold (asking: $1,099,990; 5.53%)	1 bed	1 bath	739 ft²
03/17/17	#18B	$1,654,810	Sold (asking: $1,705,990; -3.00%)	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
03/17/17	#21B	$1,789,990	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
03/17/17	#9X	$1,209,990	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	742 ft²
03/17/17	#13B	$1,603,733	Sold (asking: $1,574,990; 1.82%)	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²
03/17/17	#22E	$1,749,990	Sold (asking: $1,749,990; 0%)	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
03/17/17	#22B	$1,809,990	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
03/17/17	#7X	$1,140,429	Sold (asking: $1,119,990; 1.82%)	1 bed	1 bath	739 ft²
03/17/17	#8F	$1,239,990	Sold (can't find government record)	1 bed	1 bath	799 ft²
03/17/17	#21E	$1,731,014	Sold (asking: $1,699,990; 1.82%)	1 bed	0 baths	907 ft²
03/17/17	#24E	$1,822,657	Sold (asking: $1,789,990; 1.82%)	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
03/17/17	#13C	$2,359,794	Sold (asking: $2,454,990; -3.88%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²
03/17/17	#14C	$2,459,990	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²	-
03/17/17	#12C	$2,424,990	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²
03/17/17	#9K	$2,000,000	Sold (asking: $2,139,990; -6.54%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,155 ft²
03/16/17	#18C	$2,655,000	Sold (asking: $2,659,990; -0.19%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,349 ft²
03/16/17	#19C	$2,659,990	Sold (can't find government record)	2 beds	2 baths	1,349 ft²
03/16/17	#14D	$2,657,622	Sold (asking: $2,609,990; 1.82%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,367 ft²
03/16/17	#13D	$2,550,952	Sold (asking: $2,604,990; -2.07%)	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,367 ft²
03/16/17	#16C	$2,539,990	Sold (asking: $2,599,990; -2.31%)	2 beds	2 baths	1,349 ft²
03/16/17	#24H	$4,210,453	Sold (asking: $4,134,990; 1.82%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,798 ft²	-
03/16/17	#10A	$3,299,990	Sold (asking: $3,299,990; 0%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,947 ft²
03/16/17	#13A	$3,580,000	Sold (asking: $3,659,990; -2.19%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,947 ft²
03/16/17	#22A	$4,069,990	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²	-
03/16/17	#14A	$3,699,990	Sold (can't find government record)	3 beds	2.5 baths	- ft²	-

Unavailable rentals

						Floor plan
09/22/26	#3L	$4,240	1 bed	1 bath	647 ft²	-
08/28/26	#25B	$8,000	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
08/28/26	#9X	$6,150	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
08/24/26	#22A	$17,500	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
08/11/26	#17B	$7,550	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
08/05/26	#23E	$7,550	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
07/16/26	#TC1	$25,000	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,947 ft²
07/02/26	#11C	$10,250	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²
06/05/26	#6X	$6,000	1 bed	1 bath	739 ft²
04/16/26	#7K	$9,850	2 beds	2 baths	1,386 ft²
03/11/26	#13D	$10,200	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,367 ft²
02/24/26	#24E	$7,500	1 bed	1 bath	905 ft²
01/06/26	#24A	$19,000	3 beds	3 baths	1,959 ft²	-
11/17/25	#8X	$5,750	1 bed	1 bath	742 ft²	-
10/17/25	#25E	$7,000	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
09/05/25	#23H	$15,000	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,798 ft²
08/14/25	#6P	$8,800	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,428 ft²	-
08/06/25	#13B	$7,300	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²
08/02/25	#8K	$7,995	2 beds	2 baths	- ft²	-
07/02/25	#4B	$4,350	1 bed	1 bath	650 ft²	-
05/13/25	#9F	$5,800	1 bed	1 bath	800 ft²
05/11/25	#9P	$9,000	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,428 ft²
05/06/25	#16C	$9,500	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²	-
02/21/25	#14A	$13,000	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
02/20/25	#22E	$6,800	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
11/18/24	#8F	$5,400	1 bed	1 bath	799 ft²
09/11/24	#6F	$5,800	1 bed	1 bath	827 ft²
06/13/24	#20B	$6,500	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
06/05/24	#16B	$6,300	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²	-
04/25/24	#8S	$3,550	Studio	1 bath	572 ft²
08/28/23	#24B	$6,600	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
08/08/23	#13A	$15,000	3 beds	2.5 baths	1,959 ft²
06/26/23	#9K	$8,650	2 beds	2 baths	1,155 ft²
05/18/23	#25H	$10,500	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,798 ft²
04/24/23	#13C	$8,350	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²
12/07/21	#21E	$5,700	1 bed	1 bath	907 ft²
03/07/21	#21B	$5,400	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
02/10/21	#22H	$9,500	3 beds	2.5 baths	- ft²
01/21/21	#11B	$5,490	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²
12/31/20	#22B	$5,200	1 bed	1 bath	895 ft²
08/18/20	#8P	$11,950	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,428 ft²
01/29/20	#7P	$7,700	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,425 ft²
01/01/19	#20D	$8,500	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,370 ft²
07/23/18	#7R	$4,995	1 bed	1 bath	841 ft²
09/29/17	#12C	$8,400	2 beds	2 baths	1,340 ft²
09/19/17	#10B	$5,750	1 bed	1 bath	- ft²
03/21/17	#15D	$7,500	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,367 ft²
03/13/17	#12B	$5,250	1 bed	1 bath	893 ft²
03/06/17	#16D	$8,000	2 beds	2.5 baths	1,370 ft²

Policies

No info on policies

Amenities

Services and facilities

Bike room
Doorman
Elevator
Storage space

Wellness and recreation

Children's playroom
Gym

Shared outdoor space

Garden

Unit features

Not all features are available in every unit.

Central air
Dishwasher
Furnished
Hardwood floors
Private outdoor space
Terrace
View
City, Garden, Park, Skyline, Water
Washer/dryer

Explore Turtle Bay

Transit

Location	Distance
EM6at Lexington Av–53rd St	0.24 miles
EM6at 51st St	0.34 miles
NRW456at Lexington Av/59th St	0.44 miles
EMat 5th Av–53rd St	0.53 miles
LIRRat Grand Central	0.53 miles