Skip Navigation
StreetEasy Logo
Printed from StreetEasy.com at 09:12 PM, Dec 22 2025
agent-profile-headshot

Penny Toepfer

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Compass

Experience

View this agent's total verified deal history.

About Penny Toepfer

Recognized as one of Manhattan's leading real estate experts, Penny Toepfer is highly respected by her customers, clients and colleagues for her...

Recognized as one of Manhattan's leading real estate experts, Penny Toepfer is highly respected by her customers, clients and colleagues for her dedication, discretion and extraordinary attention to detail.

Penny joined the firm after fourteen years with Trump Sales and Leasing, where she built her reputation as an honest broker with a direct style, with inspired negotiating and shrewd, comprehensive financial analysis. Determined and loyal, her business approach isn’t simply about achieving the best price in the shortest time with the fewest problems. It is about ensuring customers and clients feel completely satisfied with their process and the result. A selection of Penny’s accomplishments best illustrates her exceptional tenacity and the level of advocacy she provides clients:

Has closed approximately $200 million at the Trump Palace on the Upper East Side

Dedicated to assisting her clients in the appreciation of their homes, Penny sold the same full-floor apartment at 838 Fifth Avenue three times; the first sale was in

??????- 2005 for $13,600,000; then in
??????- 2007 for $16,500,000; then in
??????- 2009 for $22,500,000, amidst one of the worst recessions in history

Penny was a featured panelist at the Christie’s International Real Estate 2010 Conference.

An expert in all things real estate, Penny’s clients have requested and flown her to preview properties being considered for purchase in London, Seattle, Miami and several other metropolitan cities around the world.

Penny is incredibly grateful to work in this industry: “I believe in the strength and wonder of this city, and it is an absolute privilege to work with my clients on what may be one of the largest investments of their lives.” A graduate of New York University, Penny learned the art of competition and the success that lies in determination competing as a nationally-ranked varsity tennis player and expert skier. Her focus is unequaled.

As passionate in her personal life as she is in her profession, Penny works with several charity organizations in support of young women rising above adversity.

Penny’s listing at 310 East 53rd Street was featured on NBC’s Open House on March 10, 2013

Penny was interviewed in Avenue, March 2013

Penny was profiled in the October 2012 issue of Avenue

Penny was Broker of the Week for her deal at 721 Fifth Avenue

Penny’s transaction at 838 Fifth Avenue was highlighted in Robb Report – Exception Properties

Penny’s listing at 721 Fifth Avenue was profiled in the Wall Street Journal

Ask and You Shall Receive: 838 Fifth Avenue Condo Sells for $22.5 M.

Penny gives a tour of 838 Fifth Avenue to New York Magazine’s Jhoanna Robledo

445 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales, LLC

NY License Number

30GU0783480 (Expires 12/06/2026)

NY Licensed Name

TOEPFER PENNY E