How does a board approve major improvements on a building?
Started by Josephine
over 19 years ago
Posts: 4
Member since: Aug 2007
Discussion about
I am in the process of buying a co-op in Manhattan. I am in contract and found out about a future assesment on the building. The board is telling us no one knows about the work yet it's set to be done in a few months time. It's quite a bit of money. Does anyone have any information about what the process is for a board to get approval to do major work on a building?
I believe that the board has a lot of autonomy in making these decisions. What I find surprising is that they have approved the assessment for work that they cannot describe. Doesnt smell right to me. I think you should keep asking - ask the management company or the lawyer for the building they will probably be more forthright telling you what the problems are. good luck.
I have actually just found out that the assesment is for an emergency roof repair. My next question should anyone wish to play is we signed a contract without updated board minutes, we were not told we didn't have updated board minutes. Is taht the lawyer's responsibility?
We signed a contract and later found out our lawyer did not review/get a copy of the latest bldg. financials. If he had, he would have discovered that the bldg. was being sued by one of the condo owners for work done to their unit as a part of a building-wide plumbing upgrade. I beleive it is your/your lawyer's duty to look, but I beleive the seller had an obligation to tell you if they were aware of a pending assessment before you signed the K. We also were hit with an assessment 2 weeks after we signed - so we got whacked twice (although our seller did not know about the assessment). So, I say you go to the seller and find out when they knew of the assessment and go fromt here. Good luck.
starfish, thanks for your comments much appreciated. We are trying to find out who knew what. So far it looks like it was a last minute decision that may have been discussed but the tenants of the buidling were not told about the assesment. We are in a tricky place still trying to figure out what's what. I'm sorry to hear about your story.
OP you should not have signed a purchase agreement without updated board minutes. A savy buyer's lawyer should have flagged the missing board minutes to you, but in my opinion their failure to do so would not be viewed as malpractice.
You are not really in a tricky place as the purchase agreement should clearly dictate the responsibility for this new assesment. Odds are that the purchase agreement requires that the seller pay for the monthly special maintenance only until closing where you assume the responsibility thereafter.
Roof repairs happen all the time in Manhattan and while they suck to have to pay for, you as a new owner will enjoy the benefits.
What is the range of costs for major roof repairs? I looked at a building that needed a new roof. One reason I backed out of the deal is that there were no estimates for the costs. Anyone have any ballpark figures?
A co-op board is one of the most corrupt organizations on the planet. I know because I use to be on one. They do things in whatever whimsical way they are moved too at any particular moment. We laugh at the rest of you owners. You pay to be under our thumbs. Minutes? Ha, what minutes? Sometimes the biggest decisions are made in the elevator on the way out the door.