Condo-crippling crunch
Started by tenemental
about 19 years ago
Posts: 1282
Member since: Sep 2007
Discussion about
http://www.newyorkbusiness.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070902/FREE/70902019/1010/toc Interesting article on the substantial effect the credit crunch is having on Manhattan condo developers and it's expected effect on the market.
Link is busted due to the "=" in the URL, but here's an interesting snippet:
"LOWER DEMAND, LOWER PRICES
So far, condo prices in New York have held their ground while those in other markets around the country have declined. That could be changing soon.
Consumers will be facing stricter lending standards, meaning that fewer buyers will qualify for mortgages. As a result, demand will be lower over the next 18 months, just as 25,000 new condo units come on line in the city.
Even worse, if the credit crunch deepens over the next few months, it could threaten year-end bonuses on Wall Street.
"If Wall Street reacts to this crisis as it did after the '87 crash, the condo market has a big problem," says Stuart Saft, a partner in the real estate practice at LeBoeuf Lamb Greene & MacRae. "A lot of projects going up now depend on selling to big-salary people. If they stop buying, it will have a tremendous ripple effect."
Developers are already sweetening their deals to attract buyers. AFC Realty Capital is marketing luxury condos, ranging in price from $700,000 to $1.5 million, at West 127th Street and Fifth Avenue in Harlem. It's now offering prospective buyers subsidies on their mortgages in the form of interest-rate buy downs of as much as 1.5 percentage points.
David Tillman of Mission Capital Advisors, which helps lenders sell off nonperforming assets, notes that high-end projects like 200 Chambers St. and 445 Lafayette St. still have units for sale. "Anyone who says New York's residential market is impervious to problems elsewhere is smoking crack," he says."
So, who's SMOKING CRACK HERE?
There are a TON of new developments out there that have not released most of their units - so even though Streeteasy shows that say 20 are for sale in 10 West End Avenue or any such development, there are really probably 400 more unoccupied units that the devleoper actually needs to sell. This doesn't even take into account all the unfinished projects out there and a lot of the demand for new high end multi-million dollar apartments has already been absorbed - you can't sell 25,000 more 8 million dollar apartments, not even in NYC.
Yep it's official the article confirms that Manhattan RE Market has finally cracked.
"There are a TON of new developments out there that have not released most of their units - so even though Streeteasy shows that say 20 are for sale in 10 West End Avenue or any such development, there are really probably 400 more unoccupied units that the devleoper actually needs to sell."
As you probably know, this is normal practice for new developments. They sell the units in batches, sometimes altering brokers. Usually, units sold earlier in this 'parceling' process are cheaper.
25,000 condo units coming on the market at a time when it's getting harder and more expensive to get a jumbo mortgage. Not exactly a combination that makes you want to jump up in joy about the market is it? Well of course, unless you're smoking CRACK.
Yep there are a TON of new developments the market is collapsing. Wah Wah Wah and a Blah Blah Blah. If you don't believe this than you are on ACID
Manhattan Market collapsing as we speak. And a blah blah, collapsing, blah blah, dropping, blah blah blah, decreasing, blah blah bad. Not a great time to buy unless of course your smoking the weed.
Simple question:
Ever stop to wonder why there's so many negative biased articles on the Manhattan commercial and residential markets now?
Riiiiight- they've ALL gotten it wrong, are all totally off the charts, have no idea what they're talking about, and are scared chicken littles.
Sounds eerily familiar doesn't it? you all know what happened to the rest of the nation. after denial, came the fear and the panic. the time is fast approaching for Manhattan.
But, hey, smoke some more of that CrACk and bask in oblivious bliss while you still can.
They may be right in some respects, but 200 Chambers is a bad example, and shows that although it makes for a funny 1995-era sound bite, many experts have no idea what they are talking about. All the units for sale in 200 Chambers are "flips" -- the sales office has been closed for months. The original offering plan is sold out. And out of 250 units there are 15 for sale -- 6% of the inventory. Not a whopping number by any stretch.
I agree 200 Chambers street was sold out long ago. Most for sale are flippers and investors who by the way are doing very well in resales.I have been following this building for the past several months and watching the units available for sale shrink at a nice pace. The one on west 127th street I have no idea about.
But then again MMAfia I hope you sent your rent check in because it was due on the 1st.
Stop trying to change the subject. I repeat:
Simple question:
Ever stop to wonder why there's so many negative biased articles on the Manhattan commercial and residential markets now?
However 101 Warren street a new development is almost all sold out as well. I guess you have to judge each development via location. Those in the West Village, Greenwich Village, Soho and Tribeca are doing rather nicely.
MMAfia --
Whay are there so many negative articles? Because media stories flow in trends, and to be honest, most reporters are sheep, driven by editors on tight deadlines.
I work in media, and the way content is created is based on what our competitors are talking about -- not any great insight. The latest hot topic gets written about to death so that no one misses the boat, and the topic eventually burns out. Very little real investigative journalism is done anymore and story packages are created like this:
1. Find an interesting factoid or piece of data that is released in the market
2. Find a talking head that will support the data (usually both sides are NOT presented anymore)
3. Find an anecdotal case of a "man on the street" who will comment on the data providing credibility for the common man
I am not saying that this or any other story has more or less credibility -- just stating why we are seeing more stories from a single angle on a single subject. It is relatively easy to do, makes media outlets feel competitive and fills up airtime/space.
Reporting on the dangers of "social networking" was another hot topic that filled the media incessantly for a few months and then died out. Stories on the nation's crumbling infrastructure (like it was a new story) were hot last month.
It goes in cycles. This story / angle will be dead long before any problem or non-problem which it is documenting ever goes away.
"...AFC Realty Capital is marketing luxury condos, ranging in price from $700,000 to $1.5 million, at West 127th Street and Fifth Avenue in Harlem...."
Ummm, well, that's not exactly my idea of a 'luxury condo,' either in terms of price or location. So it comes as no surprise to me that in this specific case they're offering givebacks. But I don't see that ever happening at 100 Eleventh Avenue, 200 Eleventh Avenue, One Jackson Place, 166 Perry, SoHo Mews, etc. Completely different markets altogther. It's like saying casually drinking beer leads directly to severe heroin abuse.
MMAfia, I have to say that in reading a number of recent posts, I do have to concur that on balance, you're seeming to take a much bleaker pov on the effect this entire situation will have on the prime Manhattan real estate market than I. Making such a big deal about the negative bias in the mainstream media is a puerile argument, on its merits alone. On the other hand, I also have to admit that I do agree with you that it appears the broad majority of people don't have a deeper understanding of the implications of this recent market shakeup. But that just means that there will be tremendous opportunities to capitalize large positions. Some people are going to be making LOTS of money....
"I also have to admit that I do agree with you that it appears the broad majority of people don't have a deeper understanding of the implications of this recent market shakeup But that just means that there will be tremendous opportunities to capitalize large positions. Some people are going to be making LOTS of money.."
Now Now Now let's be a careful here cause there have been some recent hedge fund blow ups run by those who thought they knew more than than most do, particulary when it comes to capitalizing with large positions. Some of these smartypants who knew exactly where the market was going have filed for bankruptcy or ended up on some secret remote island that don't have any phones.
Go 'Now Now Now' yourself, spunky.
Our fund was up 20%+ net last month alone, and is up over 60%+ year to date. I feel eminently comfortable speaking from a vantage point of personal experience and direct involvement in the matters that I choose to address. My comment that you requoted in your post above is precisely on point to what I do for a living, and not based on armchair quarterbacking, as are many of the rather egregiously uniformed opinions bandied about on this site at times.
Are you directly involved in the hedge fund markets on a day to day basis? If not, it certainly doesn't mean that you're not entitled to your opinion - of course you are! But do you actually know first hand any of the people directly involved in these '...recent hedge fund blowups...' that you opine about, as do I? Or are you just regurgitating factoids that you've read or heard about elsewhere?
There's a big difference between opinion and wisdom. You certainly appear opinionated, from reading your multiple posts on this and other threads - but I'm not yet completely convinced how wise you truly are from direct experience about the things you offer your opinions on.
I know several very bright Harvard Grad etc who do very well in the Hedge fund industry. Some of which are friends of mine. With that said I know very little on the statistics of which ones constantly make the gains that you have quoted. I am happy for you that your fund is up 60% year to date. That's great. All I was saying is there are very smart people who have lost fortunes in Hedge Funds industry. Is that not true? I think if you spoke to some of BSC's clients out there in the Cayman Islands they might say yes to my question. I am sure the Hedge Fund manager felt he understood the market better than most and took a large position that he was trying to as you put it "capitalize on".
BTW -I don't or never did claim to be smart as you particularly in the area of opinions. Your opinions are much smarter than mine. Not going to argue with on that one. after all your up 20% last month. While my portfolio was down for last month so you got me there too.
"But that just means that there will be tremendous opportunities to capitalize large positions. Some people are going to be making LOTS of money...."
:]
spunky:
I think my point is that some hedge funds do well, and some blow up. It's just the normal arc of the business. The fact that some blew up due to this specific situation is neither surprising nor unexpected - but by the same token some did extremely well. That's just life - not a sign of the coming apocalypse. It's like that old Gordon Gekko quote from the movie Wall Street "...money isn't made or lost, it's just transferred from one perception to another..."
Using the funds that blew up as some kind of signpost for the larger economic paradigm you're discussing is not effective. Funds blow up even in the best of times. I just hope it ain't ours!
Okay - it's 7:30 a.m. already. I gots to strap in for the day. Ciao.
What strategy are you investing with? Those are really outstanding returns!
nova77: the strategies are propriatary, so sorry, cannot comment in any other than a general way. But I can tell you that volatility is my little friend, and the more extreme (either way), the better.
ok - i was just thinking broadly - long/short, merger arb, energy or something like that?
Spunky, you and Julia need to meet - based on your posts - the two of you would make a great couple.
nova77:
Both long and short positions, short term hold (in general) lots of S&P action, no merger/arb, very little leverage (and what there is, is tightly controlled).
Not as as close of a match as you and MMafia Let's double date though
So your short the S and P interesting how's your returns for the past 10 years.
hmmm..., interesting terminology. "lots of S&P action" "merger/arb" "tightly controlled" leverage.
Do you really work for a hedge fund?
No offense. You're not really a day trader?
spunky - returns are (in my opinion) quite stellar. Over 20% net on an annual compounded basis over the past eight years. As far as S&P's go, we're in/out of large positions quite quickly compared with others on a comparable basis, whether short or long.
yournamehere - sorry if my nomenclature is problematic for you. No offense taken.
Yes, I really do work with a hedge fund. Over 10 years now.
No, I'm not a day trader (though it is people like that who are responsible to a large degree for the volatility we so covet).
And why would anybody fib on this board about working in a hedge fund if they were just a day trader? What exactly would the point be?
Let's not split hairs but don't many hedge fund trade on a daily bases so technically they are day trading. So what no big deal as long as they produce. I'll take 20% even if it's done by day trader working at hedge fund.
traiding daily isn't the same as day trading - closing all active positions by EOD. Small number of hedge funds do that, mostly within their stat arb strategies, whereas majority of vol shops that trade NASDAQ employ day traders who generate volume and comissions, scalping was one of the methods a few years ago