co-ops vs. condos
Started by sara328
about 19 years ago
Posts: 2
Member since: Oct 2007
Discussion about
I'm just now starting the proccess of looking for a place and am wondering what the pros and cons are of buying a co-op versus a condo. Can anyone help? Thanks!
Condos are easier to buy for several reasons. Condos usually require only 10% down compared to co-ops, which almost always require at least 20% down. Co-op boards are often very picky and have the right to turn down a potential buyer regardless of their financial stats. Condo boards usually only get to review the buyer's info, but not actually get to decide if they can buy the unit. Co-ops often have much stricter rules, like no-subleasing provisions. As to the conceptual difference, if you buy an apartment in a co-op, you are actually buying shares in a corporation that entitle you to live in a particular unit. When you buy the condo, you are actually buying the unit. That said, condos are usually more expensive per square foot, because lots of people who would not pass a co-ops financial test (like me) move to condos and there are far fewer condo bidgs in Manhattan than co-ops. Less supply and more demand drives up the price. Lots more to say, but I only know some of it.
The board approval process works both ways, though. On the downside, when you want to buy into a co-op they go over your finances with a fine-tooth comb and can still reject you for any number of other reasons which they most often choose not to share with you. Then, when you want to sell, the board can turn down a prospective buyer making the process more difficult for you. But there's another side. All those restrictions may be something you like once you are in the coop. For instance, Burmese mountian dogs are wonderful loving animals; they are also huge, shed a lot and drool profusely. That may not be something you appreciate in the small elevator as you go to work in your suit in the morning and the dog is sniffing your crotch. Other large breeds are not so gentle. Your coop board may keep such pets out. Another example: if someone is subletting, what can you do if the tenant becomes a real problem--having drug dealers deliver their wares to the apartment, loud late-night parties, we even had a hustler sublet once and the human traffic up and down the hall was awful--and shady. What are you going to do in a condo? The owner is God-knows-where, the tenant has a sublease...your building is now in a legal mess footing lawyers' fees. Also, some banks require 70%+ owner occupancy in a building before they'll issue mortgages. Too many subleases = hard for buyers to get mortgages = hard to sell you apartment eventually. Not so in a coop that disallows subleases. And in a coop if an owner goes nuts and becomes a nightmare for the building (100 cats in his apartment; a nail salon business run out of his livingroom), the building board has legal recourse and can actually oust them.
Neither a coop or condo is better. They are different. They appeal to different mentalities and one may be better suited to someone's particular financial/life situation.
Why do condos require 10% down? It is real property. I thought in most condo board provisions, if they reject the buyer they have to buy the property for the agreed upon price (right of first refusal). But it usually doesn't happen b/c they need to come up with the money.
Our condo board has the ROFR. That is the only way they can really stop a sale, and the board has no interest in owning a unit (nor the money to buy it). Our board still required a pretty intrusive application, but really lacked the power to reject us. Both have positives and negatives
It may be hard to avoid looking at coops because most buildings in this city are coops, compared with condos. that said, each coop is governed differently. Many allow sublets, though the sublessee has to go through the same board review process, and there are often restrictions on # of years, etc. This is for the reasons kylewest states above.
if you're looking at coops and it's your first time it might be wise to enlist the help of a broker who can steer you towards buildings that would have a good chance of accepting you. A good broker shoud know which ones are 'tough' and which ones are easy.
I just bought a coop and submitted the board package a month ago and am biting my nails wondering if they are going to accept me or not. I wish I had bought a condo to avoid this hassle, but couldn't afford it.
the killer on a coop is the flip tax. Generally, mature NYC coops will charge anywhere from 2% of the gross sales price on up to 5%. This is a lot of money. This is on top of the massive maintenance fees usually charge by Manhattan coops (normally at least $1 psf on up to $2 in some cases). However the "maintenance" in a coop is partially deductible as it covers interest on the underlying coop mortgage, if any, and portion of real estate taxes ties to the shares. the rest is non deductible maintenance. Some coops will include all utilities in the maintenance. Some leave you on your own to pay utilities but basics, heat and gas are generally included. All this plus the transfer taxes and your transaction costs can top, along with broker fees, 10-12% of your sales price. If you're gonna stay long term, coops are solid, if you're time horizon is short, the transaction costs are large. They're large in new condos as well unless you can have the developer cover the transfer taxes going in.
Thanks for all your comments. It's a huge help.
"Generally, mature NYC coops will charge anywhere from 2% of the gross sales price on up to 5%." Are these numbers right? I had no idea flip taxes were so high -- I thought they were generally in the 1-2% range.