Skip Navigation

How to negotiate a closing

Started by tavistmorph
about 19 years ago
Posts: 52
Member since: May 2007
Discussion about
My lawyer sneaked some really great clauses in the contract that I'm pretty sure the seller didn't notice. For instance, the original contract said the sale would not include the furniture in the model unit. My lawyer changed "would not" to "would" and somehow the seller's lawyer didn't notice and signed the contract. I also have an escape clause in the contract that I can exercise at any time. So how does closing negotiation work? Can I actually press to get that free furniture, or will they just find some extra fees to stick with me if I do? Should I call the seller and bring up the furniture issue now, or wait till we get to the closing table? Exactly how does a closing negotiation work anyway? Do you actually sit and negotiate for hours, or is closing just a formality?
Response by inoeverything
about 19 years ago
Posts: 159
Member since: Jan 2007

Contract dictates the closing, what it says is what you get. Your seller is obligated to deliver a fully furnished unit. Perhaps you want to have your lawyer to inform the seller of your favorable of color/colors.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bguy
about 19 years ago
Posts: 2
Member since: Oct 2007

tavistmorph- would u care to share the name of your attorney? thanks

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anny23
about 19 years ago
Posts: 3
Member since: Nov 2007

really... your lawyer "sneaked" some favorable terms into the contract? and you are now on a public message board gloating about it. good luck at closing! I am sure you will get everything you deserve!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by rudy
about 19 years ago
Posts: 7
Member since: Sep 2007

did the seller not have an attorney review the amended contract?

honesty is the best policy.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by masterq
about 19 years ago
Posts: 110
Member since: Jan 2007

Seller will claim "fraud", be disgusted, and refuse to give you the furniture: and he or she will be right to do so. If both you and seller understand that the sale was INTENDED to not include furniture, AND if your attorney (quote) "sneaked" some changes in there, a judge will look outside the "four corners" of the contract (as lawyer's say) to see the real intent of the parties. He will likely do so on a theory of fraud.

It's like adding a clause in invisible ink. It's illigetimate. And the fact that you KNOW (as you're posting here) that the seller doesn't know about this little change, is the essential element for a judge looking beyond the intent of the parties as expressed in writing and at your actual intent. Which you've just publicly revealed (bravo).

If the seller's attorney is any good, he or she will kick and scream. I'd be amazed if you got that furniture. Imagine how you would feel if you were the seller. Do you want this property??? They may refuse to go through with the sale!!

And those who actually WANT to hire Tavistmorph's attorney: BAD IDEA. Attorneys who are dishonest or lack professional integrity are a pain for the other side, but also for you, the client. This kind of scheming is subhuman. I don't know what it is about the property market that makes reasonably honest normal people into suspicious traitorous "advantage at every opportunity" scumbags.

FYI tavistmorph - I'm not calling you a scumbag. I think you're genuinely wondering if this is right (or even legally enforceable), and you're attorney may have led you to believe that it is. But listen to yourself and what you're trying to pull off here!!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by spunky
about 19 years ago
Posts: 1627
Member since: Jan 2007

Gee for once I have to agree with masterq. To me what you and your attorney has done is unethical. How the hell do you actually look yourself in the mirror.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kylewest
about 19 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007

The conduct the poster describes by the lawyer is unprofessional and unethical and would probably not survive legal challenge. As I tell students often: the law is not an ass. Add to that, the tone of the poster's comment is offensive. Perhaps this is a ruse to just get a thread going, but if true, it's sad an attorney and client seem to be so gleeful about being sneaky and less than forthright. Real estate can be tough, but this is an example of just plain sleezy behavior.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uptowngal
about 19 years ago
Posts: 631
Member since: Sep 2006

tavistmorph, are you purchasing a model unit for a new development? Aside from your attorney's tactics, this may not be as big of an issue for the seller if they furnished specifically to sell the place vs. if you were to purchase the place furnished by someone who's already been living there.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by nyg
about 19 years ago
Posts: 150
Member since: Aug 2007

Couldn't agree with masterq, spunky and kylewest more on this one. NYC real estate can be an ugly environment, but it is not a legal or ethical free for all. There are certain rules by which we all abide. Your attorney's actions are appalling. I won't address the legalities because I am not an attorney. Had the seller or his attorney caught your idiot lawyer at his little game prior to countersigning, there would have been a good chance they would have told you to just piss off permanently. Noone wants to knowingly enter into an agreement with parties they know ahead of time to be so dishonorable,

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by billshiers
about 19 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Aug 2007

I think we need to get a better understanding of what the OP meant by "sneaked" before we can conclude that the lawyer acted unethically. If the seller distributed the contract to the OP and his attorney, his attorney made the mentioned revisions, distributed it back to the seller and the seller's attorney and the seller's attorney reviewed the contract with the revisions and the seller signed it anyway, I don't think there is really an ethical issue. That's not being sneaky - that's negotiating. If the Seller just didn't notice the revisions, it's their fault and their problem. Now, the fact that the OP is pretty sure the seller didn't notice the revisions is a bit of a problem, but I think it's an ethical gray area and not necessarily fatal to the OP's interpretation of the contract. If you're certain that the seller didn't notice a provision, then you do have a duty to call the seller's attention to the issues. If you are not certain however, I think it is legitimate to refrain from focusing the other party's attention on a concession you believe that they may have already made.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kylewest
about 19 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007

billshiers, I think you are wrong. A real estate contract is tiny print that goes on and on with many essentially useless clauses (e.g., the headings of each section are not to be considered terms of the contract). It is generally a pre-printed form. In most transactions, people use the Blumberg form. Dickered (altered) terms on the printed contract are fairly obvious and easily spotted. There is no hiding dickered terms on such a pre-printed contract. Riders must always be carefully scrutinized. If, however, the contract is created in such a way that it is possible for one party to change one word out of tens of thousands of words without it being obvious, it should be brought to the attention of the other party. You are begging for litigation otherwise. One practice is that each term dickered must be initialed by the other party to confirm they are aware of it. The law is not supposed to be a game of "gotchya." "Negotiating" tactics do not include deception which calls into question whether there was ever a meeting of the minds and whether the contract was entered into knowingly and intelligently. The test is not can you get away with it all in the name of the deal. You may for example cheat on your taxes and get away with it, but that doesn't make it right or legal. I don't respect people who cheat.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by JuiceMan
about 19 years ago
Posts: 3578
Member since: Aug 2007

What if the sellers are laughing their ass off because the OP paid a stupid price for the place and including some old furniture from a model apartment (that probably cost $500 at IKEA) is the least they could do to close the deal?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by verain
over 18 years ago
Posts: 133
Member since: Apr 2008

1. Agreement
Legal elements of a contract:
A. Offer
(1) Offeror's serious intent to be bound
(2) Reasonably certain and definite terms
(3) Communication to Offeree(s)
B. Acceptance
(1) Offeree's serious intent to be bound
(2) Communication to Offeror

2. Consideration

3. Legal Capacity (of Offeror and Offeree)

4. Legal Purpose

5. Genuiness of Assent (No fraud, duress, undue influence, etc.)

6. Form (kinds of contracts requiring writting to be enforceable)

#5 is where this guy will lose out.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by lajeep405
over 18 years ago
Posts: 124
Member since: Jul 2007

I think travistmorph is having fun with the discussion room

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment

Most popular

  1. 10 Comments
  2. 10 Comments
  3. 8 Comments