Coops with a lot of rent-stabilized tenants
Started by JohnDoe
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 449
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
How would you think about buying an apartment in a coop where a substantial portion of the apartments (~1/3) are still occupied by rent-stabilized tenants? Suppose the common areas are a bit dingy, but the apartment itself is in good shape. how does it impact future appreciation and resale? do you worry about the building falling apart because it's harder to make repairs, spend money on upkeep, etc?
I would avoid something where the sponsor still has lots of units, trapped with RS tenants.
Also, if you have one person owning a large number of units (regardless of whether or not they're RS) it places the building at a greater risk in the event that that one owner goes into bankruptcy.
But this means it's 2/3 owner occupied, which is very good. It's not harder to make repairs and perform upkeep because the owner/sponsor is responsible for the maintanance on those apartements, which is probably at similar prices as other coops. You need to look at the financials for the building overall - is the building 'smaller' and have a doorman. If yes, I'm sure a substantial amount of operating income is going to salaries vs. nice hallways.
My building is kinda like that. Things to note:
1) If the r/c tenants mean its less than 50% owner occupied, it's harder to get a mortgage. (Some of the other owners may be subletting.)
2) The trend is to get rid of the rent controlled tenants, so hopefully the situation will improve over time. As the proportion of them drops, your apartment resale appreciates.
I agree with the advice to either avoid the building or at least going in with the mindset that you will encounter obstacles to investing in the upkeep of the building. If you can confirm whether you have an independent managing agent or if the sponsor is acting in that capacity and whether the sponsor has control of the board, these will be good indicators to how involved your non-sponsor neighbors are in the management of the building. In addition to the building financials, see if you can get a copy of the rent roll for the sponsor units (could have been a part of the underlying mortgage package). This will help you understand whether the sponsor is cash flow positive or not. In the event that he/she is barely breaking even, has control of the board, and/or acts as managing agent, don't expect much investment to improve the aesthetics of the building or much above the bare minimum in terms of upkeep.
We also own in a building like this. The lawyer we used when we bought the apartment said that actually made it a better investment in some ways because the value of such places tends to go up as the rent-controlled/rent-stabilized tenants leave. The ones in our building have been there a LONG time. I assume that is their status because their residence predates formation of the co-op. The financials of the building are quite healthy.
Just curious (maybe a subject for another thread), how could the aesthetics of one of these plain-jane pre-war walk-ups be improved? Is it even possible?
Truthmaker - very good advice.
I live in one too uesowner. I guess we just keep an eye out for inspiration. Most pre-war walk ups just tend to have pretty run down common areas (even if some of the apartments are renovated like faberge eggs on the inside)
Newer owners like me tend to see the value in getting an interior designer in, but I doubt that the sponsor who is saddled with rent control tenants or the long term people who bought for half nothing 30 years ago agree.
Management painted all the common areas a few years ago, and I wish they had consulted a decorator or designer when they picked the colors. (Or perhaps they did, asking for "institutional style" -- cream walls and dark green trim, high gloss, to NOT coordinate with the vintage brown tile in the foyer and on the stairs.) They also make sure the peel 'n' stick street number over the front door is correct.
I don't know how common this is, but I've seen units for sale in two buildings where the sponsor was selling all unsold shares, and though the buildings were pre-war walkups (East Village and LES), the common areas in both had been renovated to attract new buyers and looked great, much better than most of the similar buildings I've seen. Not sure what happened to people's maintenance charges (they were reasonable in both units), but I bet the folks already living there were very happy with the changes.