Skip Navigation

Assessments

Started by coopownr98
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 52
Member since: Dec 2007
Discussion about
Is it normal or have you ever heard of a building imposing close to 20% as an assessment over several years???? I just found out that this may happen due to some building facade work. I would have thought that our buildin'g cash reserve, which had always been deemed substantial, would cover these types of expenses. Apparently, that's not the case. I'd love to hear any thoughts on your experiences on assessments. Thanks!
Response by johnnyjai
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 65
Member since: Feb 2007

Technically, a sound cash reserve would cover such things as brick pointing (building facade work), but if it goes beyond that - like changing all bricks from white to red, etc - then you could spend it all very quickly. I would think that the assessment is to ensure that the cash reserve does not dip.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by coopownr98
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 52
Member since: Dec 2007

Many thanks for your reply.

I just found out that the assessment will be over 3-4 years and closer to 25%. The facade work is a result of having hired a contractor a couple of years. Now, there are leaks as a result but, guess what, we're hiring the SAME contractor! Is there truly a shortage of contractors in Manhattan that would also allow financing over the duration of the project and, supposedly, at the lowest cost available - or is this a clear sign of a mismanaged or corrupt board?

Also, is it a sign that the board has been mismanaging given that maintenance has been below market at $1.30-$1.50 per square foot over the last several years for a full-service building (FSB)? In 2008, maintenance will be increased by 4%.

I just want to know if the maintenance and assessment charges individually or together are nightmarish or plain normal? Is it time to sell? I'd only like to sell if the building's mismanaged. Otherwise, the building is, admittedly, great. Great staff (even with the pending strike), above average lobby, and one of the best roof decks in Manhattan from what I've seen - although no gym.

Your thoughts would be once again appreciated!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kylewest
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007

Increase of 4% maintenance sounds modest in an era of rising fuel and labor costs. I'm not sure what you mean by a 20 or 25% assessment. That is a percentage of what? In any event, the latest Local Law cycle (we're up to #11) is a costly one requiring that facades not simply be repointed and patched, but rather that structural issues such as rusted beams inside the facade be repaired if water has damaged them over time. Various things are required in different Local Law cycles--some cost little, some are more involved. The current one is major. You may be in a building that got away with some patching in the past, but that doesn't mean it was ever intended to last forever or address more fundamental problems. It simply may be time to pay the piper versus a situation involved such nefarious elements as a negligent contractor or "corrupt" board. You need much more information. Attend the annual town hall meetings if you have them in your coop, review recent board minutes on file with your managing agent, speak to board members and ask them your questions, and as a final resort, have a lawyer do some due diligence on the building's finances and overall situation. At this point, though, you have too little information to draw conclusions and general responses you get on this forum are unlikely to be very meaningful since they lack the context of your particular coop's situation.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by coopownr98
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 52
Member since: Dec 2007

Thanks again for the intelligent replies!

The 20-25% assessment will be based on the increased maintenance. This will roughly amount to an additional $100 - $600 per unit per month depending upon the number of shares.

Overall, it sounds as if the numbers I've mentioned aren't alarming to others. Hopefully, this bodes well for my coop's situation.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by ba294
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 636
Member since: Nov 2007

you are complaining because of 20-25% increase based on your maintenance? I had first thought it was based on your property value. Be extremely happy with that, many others are paying upto 100% of maintenance for years on assesments.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by mccvd
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 1
Member since: Aug 2007

People must be pretty cash-rich on this board with such blase comments. I'd say that 20 - 25% is hefty. Is it REALLY so common to have buildings impose this magnitude of an assessment?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by ba294
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 636
Member since: Nov 2007

Yes it is REALLy common to have such ridiculous assesments when you have bricks and fascade work. This is not a simple alarm or video monitor installation.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment

Most popular

  1. 10 Comments
  2. 10 Comments
  3. 8 Comments