Skip Navigation

please help!

Started by royally_screwed
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 14
Member since: Sep 2007
Discussion about
My first time buying a co-op, and I entered the jungle without my own broker. The seller's broker under quoted the maintenance (didn't mentioned a hike that has taken effect), assured me there was to be no maintenance hike planned. When I found out from talking to the neighbors, I've signed the contract. He said "oh, I meant there is no assessment". I was ready to swallow it. So I went into the... [more]
Response by kylewest
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007

When they told you at the Board interview that you couldn't sublease and about the assessment, did you tell them you didn't want to live there anymore since you'd been given false information and that financially the deal wouldn't work for you any more or that without subleasing you couldn't afford the apartment? What reaction did you have? What has your attorney said about turning these things up during the due diligence process for you? Have you complained to the broker's agency head? REBNY? Have you demanded out to the seller, agent, board, attorney? Have you retained new counsel? What options have you explored and what have you done so far?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by OriginalPoster
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 194
Member since: Jul 2006

It sounds like you signed the contract based on false statements given to you by the broker. They are bound by a code of ethics. I would call the broker's boss and tell them that you want the contract voided because the broker lied to you about 2 material aspects of the purchase. Ask them if they condone their employees lying to gain sales based on false pretenses. If the broker's boss give you a problem (which they shouldn't, because then they are complicit with the misrepresentation), get a new lawyer and pursue your legal options.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by royally_screwed_2
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 2
Member since: Jan 2008

Thanks for the input.This is royally_screwed.

Before I went into the interview, the broker coach me--"don't bring up the sublease question, otherwise they won't approve you." It's important for me so I did bring it up. I was feeling bad about it already so I hushed up. I thought about it afterwards, I really can't swing it with all these new info that I was not misrepresented before.

My problem is I have nothing in writing. How do I prove it? They had very little promotional material, nothing online, no email. Everything is verbal.

I'm not getting any help and he actually said--"what they gave you is the best to their knowledge." I couldn't believe it. Does he work for me or the seller?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kylewest
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007

The agent you speak of, based on what you write, is the seller's agent. He represents the seller. You had no contract with him, he couldn't enter into deals for you or speak on your behalf. The seller signed a contract with this agent. Of course he doesn't work for you. On the other hand, the agent must act fairly and honestly regardless of whom they represent.

I don't understand why you still wanted board approval if you didn't like what you learned about the unit. If the board didn't approve you, you would be out of the contract. Yet you apparently wanted to the board to approve you and so did not raise the sublet issue during the interview or your disatisfaction with the deal as a whole. This is confusing to me. Had you expressed regret at buying, the board most certainly would not have wanted you in the building. Particularly if you told them you didn't think you could afford the purchase.

You also have a number of other options, some of which I quickly mentioned in my post above but which you don't mention having explored in your second post. Rather than wring your hands over what is already done, now look to make good decisions that help you today and the future. You say your problem is that you have nothing in writing. How do you know that is "a problem?" Did a competent attorney tell you that? You see what trouble you get in trying to be the buyer/broker/attorney for yourself. Get competent help and there is a very good chance this will work out. Deal with the facts you know and get help.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by malraux
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 809
Member since: Dec 2007

royally_screwed_2:

I hate to say this, (and I feel badly doing so), but you screwed yourself.

The creepy broker aside, (and of course they'll say whatever they can as long as it's not totally illegal and in a grey area), your real estate attorney's PRIMARY JOB would have been to collect and assess this information. If your attorney had been competant and talked to the appropriate BoD member (or the BoD's legal rep) this entire situation simply would have not occured (your attorney must be truly awful). What's stunning to me is that in the case of the assessment/maintenace hikes, your broker can say there was an honest (oh sure) misunderstanding. But in the case of the subletting/subleasing, this arrangement HAS TO BE in the BoD house rules, amendments, and board minutes. It's a cut-and dried situation with NO room for confusion. This situation was entirely avoidable in the first place had the house rules been thoroughly reviewed, and was not either their broker's (or had you had one) your broker's job to know the building's rules and regulations or financials.

Having said this, the question now is what can you do to help yourself in a difficult situation.

The best thing you can do for yourself is to immediately get excellent legal representation specializing in Manhattan real estate, and fire your current attorney. After that point, ALL discussion should be directly between your attorney and all other parties. DO NOT TALK TO ANY OTHER PARTIES DIRECTLY, including the broker, BoD members, building tenants, or anybody else. The situation may be salvagable, but only by savvy and sharp legal representation at this point. Which, by the way, is going to cost you money, so be prepared. You will not get out of this deal cheaply. But I think you CAN get out of it, and go on to bigger and better things having learned a hard lesson.

GET AN EXCELLENT MANHATTAN RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE ATTORNEY IMMEDIATELY!!!!

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment

Most popular

  1. 10 Comments
  2. 10 Comments
  3. 8 Comments