Schedule of Closing - Inept Lawyer
Started by will
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 480
Member since: Dec 2007
Discussion about
A friend of mine has a lawyer who is telling him that closings just about never take place on the date listed in the contract. He's freaking out because he has contractors ready to start work a day or two after the closing. My observation is that closings might be delayed from time to time when there's a snag or snafu, but parties do try to stick to the date listed in the contract. I'm a litte concerned because this lawyer has given him bum advice before -- the lawyer told him he'd be sued if he tried to get out of the deal during the condo doc review period, absent fraud or misrepresentation on the seller's part. What do you think re closing date? (Also re condo doc review -- ever have any issues for a customer getting out?) And should my friend get a new lawyer?
Specified closing dates in contracts are just starting point. Either party, without explanation, under the terms of virtually every contract, is permitted to delay the closing up to 30 days from the "set" date. Actually none of the recent closings of which I'm aware closed on the set date. That would be the exception, no the rule. This is 30-day provision is spelled out in pretty plain language in the contract. It doesn't take a law degree to read this provision. If time is of the essense in closing, then the contract must state that. You friend is a little naive to have scheduled contractors so tightly. Unless he explained all this in detail to his lawyer, lay off the attorney. The attorney probably crafted a standard boiler-plate contract because his client didn't tell him to do otherwise.
Thanks Kylewest. I don't know if there's a 30-day provision though I am certain, that because of certain circumstances, the buyer made clear the time sensitivity element. Unfortunately, I do not believe the the attorney put in a "time is of the essence" clause.
I have had three closings in the last 4 years (bought, sold, bought) and two were delayed at least a couple weeks. One actually went through a day earlier than the contract stated in large part because we pushed very hard to do so and had every thing done on our end very quickly.
the date in the contract is the ON OR ABOUT DATE and is an estimated closing date. Either party can delay closing for 3-4 weeks or so, but once you reach the 4 wk mark, you can have your atty issue a TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE notice to expedite the closing. Ive had closings delayed by a few weeks and legally there is very little that can be done. Victim is usually the buyer if they have a rate lock expiration.
Thanks Urbandigs. There's a rate lock issue here, and also the buyer is leaving the country on business for a week right afterwards. The lawyer is an Admiralty lawyer who just moved here from Arizona looking to expand his practice, with apparently little previous real estate experience, and that makes me a little nervous. Not someone I would have recommended!
Of course closings never take place on the date set forth in the Contract. Are you also going to try to blame your doofiness on the attorney too?
Sorry, I forgot that this is the "it always hurts to ask" website.
xirafi, my last three closings occured on the date in the contract. So that makes you the doofus right?
No slight intended toward will or his friend, but
a. residential real estate closings in Arizona are generally done without lawyers involved
b. what kind of admiralty law did that guy practice in the desert? Water-skiing right-of-way cases on man-made lakes?
Alanhart,
Have no idea re Arizona admiralty or real estate. I am not a real estate professional or expert. I am fascinated with Manhattan RE and the national economic situation which is why I read this board. I am in international trade area and have a background in law and economics. I have had two closings in my life -- one here and one in another place far away and long ago. Both were on time. Generally, I know things can get screwed up and delayed, though I always thought the norm was "on time." If I knew the answer, I wouldn't have asked the question. But like everything else on this board, seems like this is a matter of controversy and an opportunity for some on the board to engage in vitriole and ad hominum attacks (not you, but in general). I imagine if someone posted "the sky is blue" ther would be disagreement. Could be a New York thing... not a hot bed of amicability.
Well, I learned through experience that the closing date can be delayed 30 days by either party without explanation, sucked, but what can you do? My Manhattan real estate attorney said that is par for the course.
"On or about" closing dates are fictional in NY. The parties come to an understanding as to projected timeframe for closing (i.e 60 days) and the sellers attorney picks a specific date. Although most parties target the date listed in the contact, either side is entitled to a "reasonable adjournment" which is understood to mean up to 30 days. As noted above, unless the words "time is of the essence" are inserted in the contract, the closing date is not firm. As for condo doc review, in NY that review must take place prior to contract execution unless otherwise agreed. Therefore, if your friend tried to back out, he'd have a problem.
NYCREAtty- to clarify, the condo doc review was before contract execution - that is, before the contract was signed. Atty instructed that even at that pt you could only get out on basis of fraud or misrepresentation during the negotiation, etc. That's what I found questionable. I'm not an expert on NY RE law, though. Things can get kind of strange here.