Condo Financing
Started by Colgin
almost 19 years ago
Posts: 79
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
I just wanted to throw the following anecdote out there. I was on the phone with my lender (at a major bank) to make sure we would not have a qualification issue on a loan amount that is higher than what we had requested in the past in connection with an apartment we are bidding on. She asked me whether it was a condo or coop and I told her condo. She then said "I hope you're not looking to put... [more]
I just wanted to throw the following anecdote out there. I was on the phone with my lender (at a major bank) to make sure we would not have a qualification issue on a loan amount that is higher than what we had requested in the past in connection with an apartment we are bidding on. She asked me whether it was a condo or coop and I told her condo. She then said "I hope you're not looking to put only 10% down". I told her that we wanted to put down between 20-25% depending upon the final purchase price. I asked if there was a problem with 10% down though. She said that the days of 10% down on condos are coming to an end. I said that the Manhattan condo market had remained strong so why the change. She said her bank had national standards for this type of underwriitng so NYC per se did not matter. She said she thought the first move would be towards minimum of 15% down but eventually it would be 20% down minimum. Since it didn't really effect me I did not push her on when this was coming to pass although I wish I had out of curiousity. I also asked her what type of effect this would have on condos in NYC, particularly new developments. She said that condo sales had clearly remained strong but that looking back over the past few years, particularly with respect to studios and 1 bedrooms, she has seen a lot of maximum 90% financing which, in her opinion, was helping to drive up that market. I wonder if anyone else has heard similar stories. Finally, before all the haters attack me, I pass this along FWIW and am not trying to "talk down the market" (impossible to do that anyway). I have a bid in on a loft at full ask and will be raising my bid when we go to best and final so at this point I don't want condo prices to collapse or even fall. Colgin [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
10 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
9 Comments
-
10 Comments
-
8 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Colgin - do you want to reveal the name of the bank ?
Colgin: Here's an article from Florida that reinforces your anecdote. And, before the haters attack us, I know it's Florida and I know it's just a piddly little conservative bank and that "it can't happen here", but I have noticed that trends in the other parts of the country and the world have started to affect NYC.
Wednesday, February 13, 2008 - 3:59 PM EST
BankUnited blacklists 191 condo projects South Florida Business Journal - by Brian Bandell and Oscar Pedro Musibay
Meltdown hits deep impact stage [South Florida]
Interested buyers looking for mortgages to buy units in Miami's Opera Tower, Everglades on the Bay or Four Ambassadors shouldn't bother approaching BankUnited. The Miami-based bank has included them on a list of 191 condo projects it won't write loans for.
The Business Journal obtained a list of "non-permissible" projects used internally at BankUnited (NASDAQ: BKUNA) and updated as of Jan. 14. Most of the forbidden properties were in Miami and were added at the last update. It wasn't clear who at the bank wrote the list, but the author stated a reason for almost every project declared off-limits.
Declining market value was the biggest culprit, followed by high investor concentration -- as much as 70 percent in one case. BankUnited also cited numerous foreclosures, delinquent homeowners association dues, structural-based litigation and the bank's existing exposure in the buildings.
BankUnited spokeswoman Melissa Gracey said the list is based a similar guidelines used by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
Here's a link to the rest of the article. You need to copy and paste it into a browser.
http://southflorida.bizjournals.com/southflorida/stories/2008/02/11/daily22.
html?b=1202878800^1590385&surround=etf
Closed on a property in Manhattan the other day. The closing before mine for the same building was canceled because the bank pulled the funding at the last moment. Do not know the circumstances or the bank but everything had been approved.
No doubt banks are tightening up but keep in mind co-op financing has generally always required 20% down. I am sure that there are some banks that are tightening up on condo financing, and these things are always a function of the property, as well as the buyers credit score,income etc. Miami is one of the worst markets in the US right now, so it's not really a fair measure. Also, as many contributors made the point to me a few weeks back (with a sledgehammer, as ususal), closings are often put off. One delayed closing (whether because of financing or otherwise) does not make a trend.
Good point will. I hope the new requirement will be at least 20% from now on. This 0 or 10% down payment gets rid of the weaker buyers who don't have the means to ride it out when market conditions change.
this is an example of what is occuring OUTSIDE Manhattan affecting buyers IN Manhattan. Its going to get tighter before it gets looser. Welcome to a credit crunch. Jumbo market will be shaky for a while. Its reality. Dont worry about the haters who are blinded in denial. Its really occuring and there is nothing wrong with discussing it.
I just got an email from a UrbanDigs reader who said this to me: "The major, national bank changed its policy last week and now requires 35% down on all mortgages over $1m. It has nothing to do with my credit, and I quickly got pre-qualified for the desired mortgage at another bank."
It starts small, then spreads. Expect banks to require more down payment, be very tight on appraisals, expect the borrower to back up everything they state, and credit being weighted much more heavily. Banks are strained for capital and if bond insurers get downgraded, which looks likely, expect a new wave of losses to be written down across the board. If this occurs, lending will tighten further. Again, reality, more so OUTSIDE here but it is now trickling in and has been for months.
Time to look for another Job urbandigs. Certainly anyone potential buyer you have on your short list doesn't have the means and won't qualify. Time to go back to day trading.
how shocking of you spunky to write an attack like this. Ups your credibility. In your world, as always, there is no tightening of lending standards. Its all just a dream.
I think the information is helpful, so thank you. You can debate whether the NYC market will "adjust" all day long- I think what will be telling is when deals that have gone to contract actually close...or don't... New developments in particular seem to keep buzzing along in terms of units being "in contract", but we haven't seen a lot of those close yet, so only time will tell... I agree with urbandigs that as banks become more balance sheet constrained and as lenders pare down their mortgage orgination business altogether, underwriting standards will likely continue to tighten.
Seems like it would only be sensible to demand mortgage contingencies in all contracts if there is even a grain of truth in half of what appears here.
Prior to the real estate boom, financing outs were standard. With the housing boom, that got turned on its head and financing contingencies were non-starters if a buyer wanted a shot at a winning bid. With the recent tightening of credit, practical shutdown of the offloading of risk via the securitization market (eg, residential mortgage backed securities) and general "pain" lenders are feeling from mortgage defaults (including prime loans), better to have the financing out and get the seller comfortable with a pre-approval letter from a reputable lender. I think going into contract on a new development with no financing contingency is particularly risky. If you go into contract with no financing out, you'd better get a price adjustment downward to compensate for the fact you are taking the market risk. You can be sure that until your deal closes and the lender funds, if the lender is really nervous, it has plenty of ways to get out of funding. The NYC market is slowly begin to accept this, although quite frankly, it's up to buyers to start this trend again. Everyone's situation is different, so you need to really assess whether this is a risk you are comfortable taking.
Thanks Suz. I think that makes a lot of sense. I'm in the school that Manhattan RE prices will not be dramatically impacted the next year or so by the national economy but it will become a buyers market in other ways - financing contingencies and a lot of negotiation about closing costs will be two areas where we see things swing wildly in the buyers direction. Also renovation and amenity concessions for new developments.
Also storage space where available, possible.
Hey Digs...if you turn back to day trading, i'll capitalize you.
Will- agree, but also think that buyers interested in new developments will have the most leverage to negotiate when developers have units actually ready to close and just want to move inventory ASAP. In addition, there will be an overlap period during which people who bought into the new developments early as investors (at lower prices) look to flip (and in the resale, seller will pay transfer taxes). So, it'll come down to basic supply and demand to determine price/what developers are willing to do to move any remaining units which will also in part be driven by how long investors who bought in early are willing to carry the investment costs before they decide to flip it for a more modest profit than in the past. What's fascinating about the NYC market is that a lot of these investors/flippers in new developments are brokers who have the inside scoop. So, it'll be really interesting to see what happens as projects get completed and investors start incurring carrying costs. The best example of what "could" happen is probably the Charleston where there have been some resales while there are still unsold developer units. The prices there have been reduced fairly drastically to move them. At some point, that developer (a good one by the way) will just tell the on site brokers to sell the rest of the units at whatever price it takes so they can wrap it up and move on to their next project!
ha! i cant unleash that devil again