How much security is normal on rentals?
Started by overlook
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
What is the norm on rental security for an unfurnished apartment? One, Two, three or four months? One or two seems reasonable, any more makes me wonder of the landlord is planning on absconding with it rather than raising the rent. What protection do tenants have?
I very reluctantly paid 3, wondering the same thing as you, but I later realized my landlord is a stand up guy and simply wanted to protect himself. PLenty of law on the books about security deposits.
Thanks for answering. I appreciate it.
I am being asked for four months for an empty apartment, which worries me. I know nothing about the landlord other than he's lowered the rent several times with no takers - due to the four months security he wants, or so I've been told; but, who knows. It's a nice building.
Who is the landlord?
My guess is Mr. Johnston, Mrs Bleeker or possibly Mr. Kingman. Joking aside, his landlord is likely a single person.
Why would a single person ask for four months security for an empty apartment? Nervous about renting? I'd take good care of the place, I'm an excellent tenant, but ... would I get back my security? I don't see that I have any protection should he decide to claim I had "scratched" the floor or done some other damage. By the time I hired a lawyer to try to prove otherwise, I'd be out of pocket a bundle. I'm a landlord in the country and hold security equal to 10% of the rent which is reasonable and customary here. I wouldn't think of asking 30%, not even on a furnished rental.
When I first arrived in New York I paid 3 months security because I didn't have a job. The landlord explained it takes 3 months to evict a tenant if needed.
I usually take 1st month's rent 1 month security, unless credit is sub-par, I will also take a month or two of additional security (which can be applied to the last month(s) rent. If someone needs more than 2 additional months security (3 total), they would not be accepted anyway, unless the apartment was just not renting, which never really happens...
Please tell us what your credit score is, so we have a frame of reference.
The security is not only for damages, its also to cover the time it would take to evict you.
I work in property management and I've been a renter myself. Quite frankly, 4 months is ridiculous and I wouldn't even bother with this Landlord. The security deposit in New York is usually one month's rent. I have to agree with MAV. A security deposit of 2 months maybe 3 months is ok but normally Landlords ask for this much if your credit is pretty bad and your income pretty low or average.
If you really want this apartment, you should speak to the Landlord about it and see if you can bring the security deposit down to 2 or 3 months. But only if you make good income and have very good credit. If not, there are plenty of nice buildings out there. Good luck!
I am a property manager too. When we are looking at applicants the first rule that is followed is the standard income calculation of 40 x the rent. So if you are looking at a rental of $2,500 a month, plan on having an annual income of $100,000. Then after that we check to see your credit score.
If the applicant doesn't look strong we usually ask for 2 - 4 months security; sometimes masking the 4th month as a last month's rental payment. Or we might take a tri-state Garantor too. This sometimes lessens the security needed.
Note that also researched is landlord / tenant court to see if the applicant has had any cases with previous Landlords. If the name comes up that usually means the applicant is a no-go. It really doesn't matter what the case was about.
Good Luck!
IMO, the 40X the rent rule is crazy and outdated. When an apartment was $800 a month in 1985, $32,000 was reasonable. Today though, asking someone to make $100,000 to live in a $2500 apartment is just crazy. So many people make more than their taxes say anyway, and just about everyone under 30 (75% of my applicants) gets help from parents or have some sort of 6 figure brokerage account or trust anyway.
I care much more about someone's credit score than their income, as I much rather have someone who pays their bills on time than someone who makes a lot and doesn't know how to spend it....
MAV, if your salary is $100K, you take home about $60K, or $5K a month, at the end of the day. Spending half of that on rent is a lot. Doesn't seem unreasonable to me for landlords to want you to be spending no more than 50% of your net on rent. Not a landlord or renter, so I don't really care at the end of the day.
overlook, if the landlord is willing to take less money per month as a result of his deposit demands, he/she was probably seriously burned by a tenant: months of no rent, court, excessive damage, etc. I think it's pretty doubtful you'll get this person to change his/her mind.
MAV - My credit score is 798 and income above $400,000. The apartment is under $3000 a month. Four months security seems exorbitant. I'm a non smoker, clean, sober, quiet and hard working. Can't do much better than to have a tenant like me.
It is indeed exorbitant, and if I was you I'd find another place. I do not know why any reasonable landlord would want more than 1st + security based on those numbers, maybe 'last' also...
This can be a sign of other things to come...
overlook, by those numbers i'd walk hard. btw, i'm vacating my place in the EV eom, rent is like 2600, decent building--they only wanted 1 month security, but the management co. runs like 12 large buildings inthe city. professional place. good value play.
Walking might be good advice. However, it seems that the problem may have been with the showing broker, not the landlord, who it turned out would be happy with two months security. Interesting. I have learned a lot here. Thanks everyone.
I've had a landlord ask for one month security, first & last month's rent- total of 3 months up front. In the end, I realized the landlord would not be returning my security so I did not pay the last two months of rent (series of problems with the landlord including them BREAKING IN to my apartment when I was a tenant). They tried to get it from me, but I moved out without a forwarding address.
Nice job liv8,
I am 100% sure they have your SS#, legal first and last name.
I suggest watching your credit report daily for any collection notices. Watch your credit score plunge at least 100-150 points.
I don't know what had happened to your apt but Landlord has every right to break in (if no key was given), in case of an emergency.
They did it illegally- there was no emergency- the Landlord wanted to have the apt. re-zoned and had an inspector come without warning. She pushed in the a/c unit and climbed through the window. We changed the locks on the doors prior because she threatened to "be waiting for us" in our apartment a couple of weeks earlier. This was years ago- no action was taken by the landlord. But she is still renting the apartment- and even charging a realty commission from new tenants.
There are more rights that favor the renter than the owner/landlord; once they have your money, it is very hard for you to get it back.