mortgages
Started by nycborn
over 18 years ago
Posts: 23
Member since: May 2007
Discussion about
what is the maximum mortgage allowed before you need a jumbo? I heard that the maximum was going to be raised. Has it been? If so, to what? And is it worth refinancing a 15 year jumbo that I took out less than one year ago if now I could get a conforming rate which I assume would be much lower.
Rates are jumping all over the place so make sure you can get a rate lock. Congress did raise the conforming limit, though I do not believe that the exact amounts per geographic area have been determined. This should help things in general, but I think Manhattan will be lumped in with the rest of the New York metro area so the increase may not be as great as a lot of us thought it might be.
Will is right. The prior conforming limit had been $417,000. The current plan will increase it up to $729,000 in the nations's most expensive housing markets like San Jose and some other pricy West Coast towns. However, Manhattan (where the median price is $850k and the average price is $1.4 mil) is lumped into the five boroughs and the surrounding MSAs (the suburbs), so the proposed ceiling is $450,000 or less (about the price of a studio or junior 1 bedroom in prime Manhattan). This is just yet another example of the federal and state tax and regulatory framework penalizing Manhattanites (e.g., the 4% New York city income tax, the federal alternative minimum tax, the NY state "mansion tax" for apartments over $1 million, federal tax deductions phasing out over $129,000 in income). A middle class Manhattanite makes $400,000, but has a standard of living of a person making $60,000 in middle America. Manhattan is good for multimillionaires and the impoverished who enjoy the cradle-to-grave social services. Anyone who makes between $50,000 and $600,000 gets screwed and should move somewhere more affordable like Atlanta, etc.
Try ING Direct for jumbo condo mortgages (they do not make co-op loans). ING Direct only increases the interest rate for loan amounts above $500,000, and the premium is 0.50% (50 basis points). They are a more straight forward lender than dealing with a mortgage broker. If you do use a mortgage broker, you should cross check what your broker can do with ING Direct. They are quick and fair. They will approve you if your credit score is above 700 at the quoted terms on their web site.
"Manhattan is good for multimillionaires and the impoverished who enjoy the cradle-to-grave social services. Anyone who makes between $50,000 and $600,000 gets screwed and should move somewhere more affordable like Atlanta, etc."
You are right, and its pretty sad.
Agree also, wish the candidates would start talking seriously about AMT reform.
columbus - where did you get the 450k number?
Columbus, I totally agree with you that people in the "meaty part of the curve" economically in Manhattan get royally screwed with taxes. It makes me boil with anger to hand over 44% of my gross pay, on top of having no ability to take deductions that most other Americans enjoy. But the standard of living still ain't bad. It's just that so many people here make excellent money but are still considered "have nots"...anywhere else in the country they would be walking tall.
will, I think McCain is talking seriously about AMT reform...not sure he or anyone else has the silver bullet, though.
I'm going to have to change my name to extremelypoorlady
But being poorish in New York is better methinks than being in Atlanta and affluent . . . . .
By the way, regarding the ING mortgage.
They do offer attractive rates but I think that they only offer 7 year adjustables.
try etrade, they do 30 and 15 year fixed (around 5.8 - 6%).
Same deal as ING with straightforward closing costs.
also, they give a free 90 day lock (as most do)
Has anyone had any experience with Preferred Empire Mortgage Company (Elliman website) or Manhattan Mortgage (NYTimes.com)? Right now I'm considering Wells Fargo and my own bank Bank of America. I've been keeping an eye on their rates which are a bit high for jumbo loans. I'd like to consider other options, but I'm a little weary about using a boutique company that I don't know. Thoughts on these two mortgage companies?
we used manhattan mortgage and they were able to get us a better rate from citi than we could get through citi directly through their private bank service. I also found New York Mortgage Co. to be very good. We closed on a new construction condo last week with a jumbo ($1M) 7 year ARM I/O at 5 3/8%. We locked in late Jan.
I used manhattan mortgage on 3 different mortgages/refinances for the past 6 years. They are quite good and offer competitive rates especially for coops. I currently in the market for a condo mortgage. Wells offers the most attractive option: free 6 month lock on 10/1 ARM with a flow down option to a 30 year fixed 60 days prior to closing. Manhattan Mortgage does not seem to offer this program.
I've worked with Mike McGivney at Wells twice, and he's excellent (came referred by a friend, who also raved). He just moved to Stanley Capital and does a lot of work with jumbos.
so what's the answer to "columbus - where did you get the 450k number?"
My understanding of the new conforming loan limit is the lesser of $729,750 or 125% of the average home value within a given MSA. The average price for NY-NJ-LI MSA is $435K or maybe higher. That puts the new limit at $543K. Not as high as I had hoped, but still significant.
FYI-Mortgage Backed Securities markets falling apart. Interest rates are skyrocketing today. A lot of hedge funds are selling Mortgage Backed Securities to meet margin calls causing investors to require higher yields on MBS. Hopefully this is a short term blip otherwise the higher conforming limits won't mean much based off of todays rates.
Bravo Columbus!
mortgage rates will likely remain high. due to balance sheet constraints, lack of securitization market to offload risk, lenders are cutting back use of balance sheet for all mortgages, not just subprime. today citi announced it wants to reduce its mortgage book by 45 billion. that means fewer new deals done. if other lenders follow suit, only one way for mortgage rates to go...just plain old supply and demand...
looks like Manhattan as well as the rest of NY is getting a much higher cap for conforming loans according to a CNBC article. the article included this pdf file that lists all 220 cities that will be affected by the change in conforming loan limits....http://www.ofheo.gov/media/hpi/AREA_LIST.pdf
Thanks doglover. This is a really great development that should keep Manhattan RE stable, particularly the studio and 1-BR market.
Suz, mortgage rates are still historically low, even though they are up from a couple of weeks back.
The economy in general is going through a rough patch. Passage of the mortgage relief packages (Dodd and Frank bills) would be a great development, a sort of "trickle up" that would have a stablizing influence.
I used Jeff Appel, I think he used to be with MM but now I think he's elsewhere. He was great (a few purchases). Will, I think you're right about the studio and 1br market, they're at or below $1000 per sf now pretty consistently. Where I think new construction really over produced is the family sized apartment, which was very low in supply but also has EXTREMELY low school spots. Most (although not all, I realize) overseas buyers are not looking for the true 2 bed (and way up). We shall see.
quoted 30 year fixed 6.625%, 10/1 ARM 6.375%, no points, 20% down on $1M, credit score over 720. Rates have dropped since I got the quote the other day.
Lock in those rates if you can still get them csn.
note, the conforming cap relief ends at the end of this year. because of the meltdown in mbs (think carlyle capital and thornburg who mulliganed on margin calls and in the case of carlyle, levered over 20x) spreads between agencies (freddies/fannies) and treasuries (what drives mortgage rates, not fed funds), moved up ~60 bps in 3 days. finally economists concede the US is in a recession. guess we'll see how "stable" the NYC real estate market will be in this climate...
Maybe I'm being a pessimist, but I can't see nyc bucking the overall recession. I keep reading how things are different in Manhattan, and certainly we are unique, but how insulated can Manhattan be? It smells to me like the new, new economy theory people used to favor. There are some seriously bad indicators coming out daily and the consensus is that the numbers we get are too old to tell the whole story. The US is in a recession, and Europe is on it's way. Granted, the USD is cheap, which makes for great tourism, but I would imagine foreigners are starting to think twice before investing here in RE, unless it's for their own personal use.
And being a finacial center isn't a help this time around. Greenwich is big in finance, anyone take a look at the amount of foreclosures up there?
If only I had a good crystal ball...
CSN--you said that
uoted 30 year fixed 6.625%, 10/1 ARM 6.375%, no points, 20% down on $1M, credit score over 720. Rates have dropped since I got the quote the other day.
Can you advise who quoted you the fixed jumbo rate? Thanks
The quote came from Wells Fargo. Try John at 212-805-1159. He is great to work with.
By the way the new conforming rate in Manhattan is $729,750 for any single family residence until the end of the year.
Under the heading of "unintended consequences", the higher conforming caps may be combining with rising foreclosures and other problems at FNNMA and FHLMC to push agency rates higher. In other words, while the higher caps will provide some modest help to borrowers who would otherwise need jumbo loans, the changes may also hurt borrowers who would have qualified under the old agency limits.
An interesting ratio to watch is the one between the treasury-agency spread and the agency-jumbo spread. If the first spread grows and the second one shrinks, it's a sign that the higher caps may be a double-edged sword from a macroeconomic standpoint, though it's hard to isolate them from the other problems pushing agency rates higher.
Of course, the higher caps are an unmitigated blessing for high-priced markets like Manhattan, where the old conforming limits wouldn't cover the downpayment on a parking space. And if Congress steps in with an explicit guarantee of Fannie and Freddie, everyone in real estate wins - at the expense of ordinary taxpayers, especially those who aren't in a position to benefit from the Government propping up the real estate market.
On second thought, not everyone in real estate wins when Congress (or the Fed) intervenes to ease credit. The one notable exception: buyers with substantial liquid assets. In a credit crunch, cash is king. The worse the borrowing environment, the more a buyer who can make a big downpayment can dictate the other terms of a deal. So if your money is in three-month paper and you've been eying that dream co-op, you really want Fannie and Freddie to go bankrupt and Congress to do nothing.
csn: Can you give us a source for the $729K conforming loan in Manhattan? There had been a lot of discussion previously that Manh was lumped in with other boroughs and the lower values in the outer boroughs would depress the conforming loan amount in Manh when it all got figured out to about $400K-$500K. Do you have more recent data?
Kylewest, yes it is going to be 729. It was in an earlier post, I think from the FHA website. I'll see if I can find it.
That's awesome. Thank you.
http://www.ofheo.gov/media/hpi/AREA_LIST.pdf
OFHEO is part of HUD. Doglover posted the link above. It looks legit.
Here's the line of most interest to this audience:
MSA Name State One-Family Two-Family Three-Family Four-Family
NEW YORK-WHITE PLAINS-WAYNE, NY-NJ METRO NY $729,750 $934,200 $1,129,250 $1,403,400
West81st -- just curious, though, what you think would happen to the value of the dream co-op if Fannie and Freddi went bankrupt? I really think the thing that could tank the economy even more than it's already tanked would be a further nosedive in consumer confidence. I think it would send ripples through the economy and then yes, Manhattan RE would crash.
Will: That's the $4 trillion dollar question. Government at all levels has distorted the real estate market so grotesquely with tax breaks and cheap money that the real economic value of any property (the value if all those artificial props were removed) is very difficult to predict. I'm pretty sure nobody really wants to find out.
Ironically, the $7MM market price of that elusive pre-war classic nine co-op may be relatively close to its economic value, for several reasons: supply is scarce, the potential pool of buyers isn't very price-sensitive, a buyer probably has to put 50% down to satisfy the Board, the mortgage is still a jumbo loan, and the mortgage interest deduction is limited to the first million of principal; so neither cheap money nor tax benefits are that big a factor.
The distortion is much more profound at the commodity end of the real estate market. Shut down the phony liquidity machine (quasi guarantees and favorable tax treatment) and watch what happens to cookie-cutter subdivisions in the outer suburbs.
The long-term problem for the high end in New York is that so many of the buyers get their money via trickle-up from the lower strata. Wipe out several trillion dollars of national wealth, and the I-bankers - as well as their lawyers and cosmetic surgeons - may get a lot more price-sensitive, because the amount they can skim off the top could shrink pretty quickly.
Also, Will, I agree with you about consumer confidence, and I think it's already sliding. So we'll find out about that one pretty quickly.
Anyway, the $7 million classic nine is sort of like Angelina Jolie: Fun to ogle or gossip about, but impossibly out of reach for mere mortals. The REAL Manhattan market consists mostly of two segments: small apartments for young professionals/empty nesters/investors, and larger apartments for families who are trying to resist the pull of the 'burbs and hang on in the City. I'm in the second market, and I think it's already cracking as potential buyers worry about their jobs/bonuses, or give in to the lure of falling house prices outside the city.
Since I'm on the buy side, maybe that's just wishful thinking. If I just had a $2MM CD coming due in April, it would be fun to see how far that money would go.
Thanks west81st. I'm inclined to agree with that, though I feel very strongly that the government needs to take actions such as the Dodd/Frank mortgage relief efforts to ensure that the lower-strata are safe in their homes and jobs so that the trickle-up continues.
Can anyone confirm that the new conforming limits will NOT be available for co-ops? I read this somewhere and cannot find the source again
I think they'll be available for co-ops. I suspect the different form of ownership could raise the issue, but I never heard that they won't be. I think it still is about obtaining mortgages. The change won't impact whatever individual co-op requirements are.
Reading StreetEasy, CNBC and WSJ, it is no wonder that health care is one of the still-growing sectors of the economy. Must be the doctors that deal with ulcers, hypertension and heart conditions.
i found the source of non-co-op availability
https://www.efanniemae.com/sf/guides/ssg/annltrs/pdf/2008/0805.pdf
can anyone re-confirm I'm reading this correctly? and this is thr 'official document'
Ineligible Products, Features, or Transaction Types
The following are not permitted on jumbo-conforming mortgage loans:
• Balloons
• Bi-weekly payment schedules
• Cash-out refinances
• Cooperative properties
.
.
.
Bugelrex: Thanks for catching that. If accurate, it's a huge exception for the NY market.
Will: We part company on mortgage relief. I think the government should limit its intervention to helping the victims of genuine abuse - in other words, the people whom government regulators failed to prtect from predatory lenders when it was their job to do so. IMO, helping people who simply placed bad bets on real estate would just add another level to the house of cards. The market needs a shakeout, not artificial price support from a government that's already mired in debt and up to its neck in real estate exposure.
That's interesting Bugelrex. Not sure what to make of it. It was not my impression that there was any intention of Congress to exclude co-ops.
will: I'm sure the democrats snuck that co-op clause in since co-ops are essentially a business corporation .. we all know how much liberals HATE corporations right?
Anyway.. this whole thing is stupid, the government should step aside and let the market work.. prices will come back down to where the market can support it.. Japan made the same mistake at the start of their lost decade
Actually, Bugelrex, it's much more likely that Republicans would have snuck in a co-op exception as a way to screw New York.
The topic of the government's proper role as a bubble deflates has a lot of interesting aspects: microeconomic, macroeconomic, moral, political, etc. Maybe that discussion doesn't belong on this thread, but I hope we can pick it up elsewhere.
I think bugelrex has it right, but for a different reason: The majority of Republican campaign contributions come from the same Upper East Side zip code... definitely from co-ops.
It is interesting how NY gets screwed via AMT/state taxes and in other ways. Maybe we should contact our two Senators.
Bugelrex and West81st -- with all due respect, but it's the market that got us into this mess. We need some intervention so the "lower strata," as west81st calls them, can keep going and the economy doesn't get into the second Great Depression. You guys may be independently wealthy but us income stiffs, even us upper income working stiffs, depend on a stable economy to make our mortgage payments. If the tanking economy wipes out our very well paying but economically elastic jobs, we're going to start seeing more bankruptices and foreclosures around here. So, maybe you don't care and you're so well off that you can swoop in and get a good price for our abandoned abodes, and then make a terrific profit in 2025, but I'd prefer a different outcome.
Regarding the conforming rate, I doubt if it was a Democrat or Republican thing, probably just some stupid bureaucrat trying to be as unhelpful and restrictive as possible. Got a say though, they do thrive during Republican administrations.
Tony: I'm not a free-market extremist by any means. Besides, if the bottom falls out I'll probably be part of the same wave of financial industry layoffs as a lot of people on this board. So I'm speaking less from self-interest than from what I think is ultimately best for the economy and the country.
You may be right that now isn't the time for laissez-faire to prevail in real estate. I do think the long-term goal should be a less heavy-handed government presence, and I fear that any federal intervention in the current crisis will do more lasting harm than good.
Understood, west81st. In the long run, though, we're all dead. I know I've gotta be dead at some point but would prefer not to be broke.