New Conforming Limits and NYC Co-ops
Started by Tony
over 18 years ago
Posts: 140
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
Did anyone ever get to the bottom of the issue of whether the new conforming loan increases would cover NYC co-ops? I recall there was something in one of the circulars from Fannie Mae that said "cooperative properties" or some such would not be covered.
coops are not covered according to their website
Any reason to think there's a Freddie/Fannie distinction here?
doubt it, sounds like just another case of NYers getting screwed. Lot of limitations, no cashout refinances, no second mortgages(must be subordinated on refinances of first loans), only 5 year ARMS and 30 year fixed, etc. Not sure all condos will qualify either.
Condos will clearly be covered. Also there still are 7 yr ARMS, interest only etc. Maybe no zero down but you won't find that anywhere.
Just the odd thing in the circular from Fannie Mae that seems to exclude coops. I can't help but think it intended something else.
I agree Tony, it seems strange that co-ops wouldn't be covered. My only guess is that it was intended for co-ops in other states that are not considered as "stable" as the co-ops in NYC. Maybe someone needs to ask a lender to get to the bottom of this...
As I understand it right now, co-ops are not covered by the increase in the loan limits. Only single family and condos. I have also been told that you will need to purchase 2 points in order to get the conforming limit rate for a loan above the original limit of 417K.
Briguynyc: Two points to get the two-point conforming rate, or two points to get the zero-point conforming rate? The first possibility would just be an annoying restriction. The second would be a total deal-killer.
When do you think these changes will be reflected in the rates? By traditional market rules, they should have been priced into the rates already, right?
I think co-ops aren't covered because people don't own 'real estate,' but rather shares in a corporation.
Highly unlikely that they aren't covered, since the IRS considers co-op share loans and mortgage loans to be essentially the same thing. For federal tax purposes (not state or local tax purposes) co-ops are considered just another way to hold real estate. This is because of a historical quirk dating back to medieval England, where it was not possible to own "property" that was not connected to the ground. Therefore, the concept of freeholder - the person who held the part of the property connected to the ground - and leaseholder - the tenant, or a person holding "title" to a property on any floor but the ground floor - developed. This was not fixed in England until the last Conservative government, which converted almost all leaseholds - except Crown Property - into freeholds, and caused the Duke of Buckingham - the largest landowner in London, whose family had owned Buckingham Palace until Queen Victoria bought it from them - to leave the Conservative Party. The same problem was fixed in New York State law in 1964, when condominium ownership was allowed. No buildings built before 1964 in New York are condominiums, unless they converted from co-op status.
According to the brokers I talk to, some banks may start offering the new conforming jumbo loans on Monday, but the rates may not be any better than the current non-conforming jumbo rates. It doesn't look like co-ops will be covered. We should know more on Monday.
I believe it will be 2 points to get the zero-point conforming rate. So far co-ops are out. I can't speak to why. Things are still moving though. Remember that it also excludes multi-family. We will know more soon enough, but all in all I don't think it is much to be excited about yet.
Where are you getting this information? Multi-family are not out.
State Metropolitan, Micropolitan, or County Name Limit
1 unit 2 unit 3 unit 4uni
NY New York-Northern New Jersey-Long Island, NY-NJ-PA (Metropolitan Area)
Component Counties (NY): Bronx, Kings, Nassua, New York, Putnam, Queens, Richmond, Rockland, Suffolk,
Westchester
$ 729,750 $ 934,200 $ 1,129,250 $ 1,403,400
csn: From my days packaging Fannies, I think the relevant distinction is multi-family vs. 1-4 unit properties.
briguynyc: If it's two points to get the zero-point conforming rate, there's no net gain at all, based on the current spread between confirming and jumbo loans (about 50 bps) and the prevailing buy-down value of an up-front point (roughly twenty-five bps).
Sorry, the prior post should read "conforming", not "confirming".
...and I mis-used "bps". It's been a while since I was on a trading desk. Anyway, you get the point.
csn: I know the info you are quoting. I got an email from the chase mortgage area and that is what they said. They are still working on all the details but claimed that the change to limits did not apply to multi-family properties. I don't know how to reconcile that with the info you quoted, that I saw too.
On the points part. I think the important thing to understand is that raising the conforming limit does not mean the sudden availability of easy credit. The crunch is still on and FNMA and FHLMC are struggling with the losses they have been sustaining. Thus the points as a price adjuster. I agree that this is suddenly not such a great deal. Although without all the info it is difficult to judge if you are better or worse off. I'm sure some of the specifics may change.
In agency terms, "MF" means more than four units. To you and me, "multi" might mean more than one, but the market has its own language.