Skip Navigation

East Village/LES Rezoning

Started by petrfitz
over 18 years ago
Posts: 2533
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
The new zoning laws are about to be voted on and may pass in the Fall. There are a few blocks in the zone that are going to receive significantly increased FAR. Has anyone looked into these properties and have an opinion on potential purchase and return on flip to developers? It seems there is significant opportunity on Chrystie and parts of Pitt Street where FAR will actually double.
Response by tenemental
over 18 years ago
Posts: 1282
Member since: Sep 2007

petrfitz, I'm not an investor so I don't have anything to offer regarding the figures, but I will say that Pitt Street is still the 'hood. The luxury condo on Attorney Street has not inspired any change that I can see in the immediate vicinity, and just looks like it was dropped in the middle of a slum. The projects abound. Club Sine next door recently closed. Maybe its replacement will be something upscale? A little girl was shot in the leg by a stray bullet on Pitt last year. River Ridge Condos is the most recent new development, if that's any indicator. There's another building going up near Pitt on Houston; it's assisted living for people who were orphans and are now entering the adult world, as well as others, but I forget their specifics.

I would think you'd be much safer on Chrystie Street, and I'd like to see Sara D. Roosevelt park turn around. It's been fixed up a bit, but it's still the kind of place where homeless cretins cat-call your girlfriend.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by petrfitz
over 18 years ago
Posts: 2533
Member since: Mar 2008

Tenemental - kind of like how peole used to say "the Bowery is total crap who would ever want to build amongst flop houses, homeless and retaurant supply houses" Now the Bowery is on its way to be NY's grandest street.

Due to the rezoning, Pitt St and Chrystie streets will be rezoned to have the greatest building capacity and developer incentives in the entire EV/LES. Expect these streets to be bought up, demolished and redeveloped with 12-15 story buildings in the next2-3 years. They will see the greatest change than any other block in the entire neighborhood.

People will be scratching their heads saying who would have thought that would have happened on Pitt and Chrystie streets just like they are saying now about the Bowery.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bjw2103
over 18 years ago
Posts: 6236
Member since: Jul 2007

petrfitz, if you're so convinced, go for it! I do think proclaiming the Bowery as "on its way to be NY's grandest street" is a bit of a stretch, no? I live on Elizabeth, so I'm there a lot, and there's a LOT of work left to be done before it will be a destination the likes of 5th Ave, Broadway, etc. I'm also a bit wary of Pitt (less so with Chrystie, but still) due to the distance from subways. That's why Aves C and D will probably never take off like their counterparts to the west did/are. As tenemental said, there's also a lot of public housing that can't just be swept under the rug. But you're right in that there is a great amount of potential, mostly because it is still quite a risky investment.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by tenemental
over 18 years ago
Posts: 1282
Member since: Sep 2007

petrfitz, bjw2103 just covered a lot of what I was going to say. Please note that my thoughts on Chrystie were very different from my thoughts on Pitt. My only negative on Chrystie was the park. As someone living near Tompkins Square, I know it can certainly come around. I'm looking forward to it.

Pitt, on the other hand, is very different from the old Bowery. Whereas Bowery has good access to transportation and other neighborhoods surrounding it that greatly improved, Pitt has a long walk to a single train line and some lousy buses. Going east from Pitt, there's almost nothing but projects, which won't be changing.

bjw2103, congrats on your purchase. Not that you need to hear it from me, but I know you've done your research, and I'm guessing that a 2BR gives you room to grow and a timeline you're comfortable with. Enjoy.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bjw2103
over 18 years ago
Posts: 6236
Member since: Jul 2007

Thanks, tenemental. Should probably devote another thread to this, but I'm having my attorney ask for a financing contingency before I sign anything. I'm hoping the sponsor agrees to that, because even though I'm pretty confident I'll get someone to lend, I will walk if they insist on putting all the risk on me. But otherwise, yes, excited to have a 2BR to grow into, and I plan on staying there fairly long-term, so I think everything will be ok. Hope your search turns out to be fruitful as well!

petrfitz, come to think of it, I've only been on Pitt a handful of times. What exactly is over there now? At least the old Bowery had CBGB to attract people.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by petrfitz
over 18 years ago
Posts: 2533
Member since: Mar 2008

City Planning has issued its statement of final intent for rezoning the East Village and Lower East Side ("Final Scope of Work").

The good news is: it's not final. They will continue to consider alternatives as they study the area for their final rezoning proposal. So it is possible to influence the final plan, though time is short.

Also good news:
1. the study will cover a quarter mile around the rezoning area, so all of the Bowery to Pell Street and a large part of Chinatown will be studied
2. the rezoning will end most hotel development south of Houston between Essex and Allen
3. EV sidestreets will remain, in effect, unchanged
4. the end of the Community Facility bonus will protect larger sites like Mary Help of Christians and P.S. 64 from being developed into towering dormitories. Both sites will be limited to eight stories, though Mary's, on the avenue, will be allowed greater bulk
5. underbuilt tenements on 4th-7th Streets between A&B will be protected.

There's bad news too.

A.
Developers will be allowed to build larger buildings on 1st and 2nd Avenues and Avenue A if they develop or recycle affordable housing anywhere in the district or within a half mile of the district.

So the three, four and five story townhouses and tenements from the 1840's through the Civil War which line 1st Avenue and Avenue A, filled with long-term tenants paying truly affordable rents, will be vulnerable to demolition and redevelopment into seven- or eight-story buildings. To get the bonus size, the developer has merely to promise to rent some apartments somewhere at stabilized rates forever.

There appears to be no meaningful oversight for this permanent off-site stabilization, so, in effect, anything goes. And affordable housing bonuses are bought and sold -- according to HPD it's quite a market -- so developers will be getting their height bonus for free and without contributing any affordable housing to our community.

This sad excuse for an affordable housing program is called "Inclusionary Zoning," widely known as "yet another scam."

Since many stabilized rents have already risen to market rate, developers will feel no pain. However, this plan will add to the pressure to evict tenants and warehouse empty apartments. Currently, large buildings can be developed only on multiple lots. This seems to have protected the avenues from development in recent years. Under the rezoning, larger buildings could be built as-of-right on single lots, facilitating the spread of development at every level, even among smaller owners.

B.
The rezoning plan will protect the Lower East Side from Allen to Essex from new hotel development, but it will allow large developments on Houston, Chrystie, Delancey, Pitt (forming a wall surrounding the LES south of Houston) and on Avenue D. This wall of market-rate luxury development will exacerbate the up-scaling of the LES as a nightlife and tourist destination and the decline of its day-time, residential and arts community.

C.
Upzoning D will threaten the projects, bringing up-scale development and gentrification, adding to the pressure to move the projects out of subsidy and into the market.

D.
The rezoning itself does not include the Bowery or Chinatown, so we can expect that hotel developers, prevented by the rezoning from developing in the LES, will turn all their attention to the Bowery and Chinatown.

E.
In addition, City Planning is changing the zoning text so that residential storefronts in all the planned residential zones can be reverted to commercial use, no matter how long they have been out of commercial use. In plain English: more bars encouraged.

For the intrepid, here are the technical details:

The sidestreets of the EV: FAR 4 (about the size of a six story tenement) -- R7A

The large avenues of the EV (2nd,1st,A): IZ bonus to FAR 4.6 (seven stories) -- R8B

The LES south of Houston: FAR 4 (six stories) -- C4-4A&R7A

EXCEPT
Houston, Delancey, Chrystie, D and parts of Pitt: IZ bonus to FAR 7.2 (with required setbacks this maxes out at 12 stories) -- C6-2A

AND
City Planning is considering an alternative which would allow IZ up to FAR 8.5 (maxing out at 15 stories). So far this alternative is only being considered for Chrystie Street, but their language is vague and evasively non specific.

The plan downzones 7th - 4th Streets between A&B from FAR 3.44 to 3.

Finally, the city will add R8B zones to those zones in which commercial storefronts are deemed perpetually available for commercial use, no matter how long they have been used as residences.

the proposed zoning requires a street wall to 60' with setbacks above. It is a contextual zoning, so it provides an envelope within which all the bulk (FAR) must fit. Specifically, on the sidestreets of the EV, for example, the 4 FAR would have to fit within 80' in height and 70' in depth and whatever the width of the lot -- one standard lot would be 25' wide.

For Pitt Street, the same 60' street wall would be required, with setbacks above to 120', if the IZ bonus is taken. I haven't worked out the arithmetic for the setbacks, but I imagine that multiple setbacks would be required to attain full bulk.

It's the current zoning that requires multiple lots for greater bulk, not the proposed rezoning.

In some areas of the EV, the rezoning is a wash for developers. You are losing your community facility bonus which was limited by the sliver law: the bonus allowed you 6.5 FAR, but on a single lot, you can't build taller than the street is wide. That's one reason why development on single EV lots doesn't go higher than 70 or 80'. There's also a requirement for narrower footprint under the current zoning, which also limits height.

So under current zoning, it's not easy to build really high, and we don't see really high towers in the EV.

We see them in the LES commercial zone and on 3rd Ave and 4th Ave which are all C6-1 zones. So if you bought a property on Orchard, you could, like Misrahi, build a huge out-of-context hotel, make millions, and transform the neighborhood beyond recognition, while not offering any housing or alleviating the housing shortage.

But if you bought on Pitt, you've bought in a residential zone like the EV, and the new zoning allows you a more bulk, but a little less than you would have gotten if you took the community facility bonus, despite the sliver law. (Pitt St will have 12-15 story builind limit with developer incentives to build and will have the greatest building heights in the entire EV/LES. Pitt street will also be 2 blocks from the East River Parck which will be completely rebuilt by Summer 2008. Also planned on Pitt St south of Houston at the Henry Street Settlement complex is a 12 story Lux condo unit.)

Pitt Street will look dramatically different in 2-3 years. It will be higher with 12 story buildings mixing luxury, and affordable housing.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by fatrabbit
over 18 years ago
Posts: 83
Member since: Jan 2008

Petrfitz, do you mean that Henry Street Settlement will share its site with a twelve-story condo?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by petrfitz
over 18 years ago
Posts: 2533
Member since: Mar 2008

The proposal includes knocking down all buildings on the Henry Street complex except the Historic structures which I believe is the Theatre Building. Checked out Curbed.com and search for Henry Street - it will give you the deal. I think Loho10002.com also did a blurb on it.

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment

Most popular

  1. 10 Comments
  2. 10 Comments
  3. 8 Comments