other market manipulation - wash sales
Started by dtown
over 18 years ago
Posts: 9
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
another one, and arguably the simplest, is a wash sale. Say I'm the developer for beaver house. I create some internation shell companies that buy a few of the larger units at $4000/sq ft. I don't make or lose money in the deal, I'm just moving my own money around. Those recorded sales find their way into the comps and now I've pushed up the value of the whole building. Who would police for that?
Nobody, but you still have to get people willing to pay $4,000 sq. ft., or it's all been a waste of energy. For that matter, you could make it $10,000 sq. ft., and say your building has just set a per s.f. record for Manhattan residential real estate. It wouldn't matter.
I've always wondered if something odd like this happened with the Flowerbox building at 259 East 7th St between Aves C & D. A mysterious "early investor" was said to have paid "just under $10MM” for the 6500sf penthouse in news stories and interviews the developers gave. This was supposedly the money they used for construction. That may not seem like a lot on a ppsf basis for a large penthouse, but anything going for $10MM a few doors down from the projects of Ave D gets a lot of attention. StreetEasy has a listing for a $9.2MM penthouse, but no sales record. The building has been reported as being sold out, with other units going for around $1k psf.
Transfer taxes pose something of a deterrent, I think.
to malraux, good point, and it's not that you would get people to pay 4000, but someone might be more willing to do 1400/sqft if they see a comp at 4000/sqft, when fair value is more like 1200/sqft. The numbers are perhaps extreme, so a little more subtlety would obviously make that kind of manipulation more effective.
To tenemental, anecdotes like those are what make me suspicious. That, and it's in my nature =).
To west81st, that is a good point, all in ~3% or so?
Very good points. I definitely wonder now too...
dtown: Yes, a little under 3%, assuming the mansion tax applies.