Skip Navigation

manhattan apartment - time to back out?

Started by willie
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Feb 2008
Discussion about
Relatively new to this site, wanted to pick everyone's brain. I just had my offer accepted for a condo in midtown east - full service luxury building with pool / gym..etc Not a new construction but the building is in top-top shape. I am paying less than $850 / sqft for a one bedroom around 750 sqft. The contract is still being drfated at the attorney's so nothing is signed yet. With all the negative news going on at Wall Street I know this is probably not the best time to be buying a place but I think I am getting a good deal at this price. I am planning on living at the apartment for 3 to 5 years. Wondering if I should take the plunge now or hold on to my 20% downpayment for another 6 months to a year? Any thoughts will be apprciated.
Response by iMom
over 18 years ago
Posts: 279
Member since: Feb 2008

I'm not one of those "the sky is falling" people, but I DO think you will see a downward trend to prices between now and 2009. Some neighborhoods will hold better than others, but there will be increased pressure non-the-less. Financial markets are shrouded in uncertainty, access to mortgage capital has been severely reduced, Wall Street is bracing for thousands of layoffs and who know how long the recession will last? Besides, there has been a ton of construction that has yet to be filled, with more units coming on-line each month. You've already seen a bunch of price-chops (primarily in fringe neighborhoods so far) as developers start to get impatient.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by malraux
over 18 years ago
Posts: 809
Member since: Dec 2007

3-5 years before you sell is not a long enough time horizon in this market, particularly if it's more like 3 years, and you're concerned about losing money/making a profit.

I'd wait 6 months (at least) if I were you.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Buckster
over 18 years ago
Posts: 20
Member since: Feb 2008

I agree with iMom. Sounds like the price is fair for a luxury condo in the area, what worries me is the 3 - 5 years. Pulling out my crystal ball to guess that you'll probably be ok in terms of value in 5 years, but after your costs in and out are included you may have an issue.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by wyndcliff
over 18 years ago
Posts: 60
Member since: Sep 2007

Less than $850/sqft sounds pretty good for what you're describing. Is it a good deal relative to comps in the building?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by khd
over 18 years ago
Posts: 215
Member since: Feb 2008

i third the sentiment...3-5 years is not a good idea. Even if the place holds its value, you will lose bi time on closing costs, etc.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by taxquestion
over 18 years ago
Posts: 13
Member since: Mar 2008

What about the same debate but with $970 sq foot, 1100 square feet, 2 bed 2 bath, non luxury, no doorman, $.9/sq ft maint, 5-7 year horizon condo in the mid-50s on the west side?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by willie
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Feb 2008

Thanks for everybody's posts.

Actually our plan is to live in the apartment for 3 to 5 years, and turn that into a rental property while we move to a bigger place in the suburbs..etc. My main concern is should if now is the time to be jumping into what seems to be a good deal, or be conservative and see how the latest round of financial market events / layoffs affects property prices in the city.

wyndcliff - yes, the apartment is cheaper on a per sqft basis compared with other units for sale in the building. I suspect the reason is it has been on the market longer, also other units are on higher floors.

any thoughts / opinions are much appreciated,

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by uptowngal
over 18 years ago
Posts: 631
Member since: Sep 2006

willie,

On the one hand, the condo is in a key location and it sounds like a great price for a full service building. And you can rent it out at any time.

On the other, condos should experience more price volatility than coops because they are easier to sell. And with a lot of Wall St'ers having purchased condos in recent years, will look to sell them once a large wave of layoffs comes. The saving grace - foreign investors if the USD remains weak.

That said, I think 3-5 years for ANY RE purchase is too narrow a window; I think 5 years+ is more appropriate. You don't know what's going to happen and the more time you allow the lower your risk.

At the end of the day you have to consider a renting vs buying scenario to determine what's best for you. And check w your lawyer on writing something into the contract that would put you in favor of the deal in the event that the price drops (i.e. buyer concessions, finance contingencies).

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by cliff702
over 18 years ago
Posts: 182
Member since: Apr 2007

You found it, you like it, you studied it and you analyzed it. Will you keep renting for 6 months? Keep looking meanwhile? I think the tax benefits (mortgage interest and taxes deduction) are important. And, since you plan on renting after 3-5 years, that gives you additional leeway if sale prices haven't recovered.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by kylewest
over 18 years ago
Posts: 4455
Member since: Aug 2007

Depends on your risk tolerance. If you can financially cope with the RE market being depressed and/or not appreciating in the next 3-5, this could be fine. If you are cutting things close and of necessity your plans won't pan out unless the unit appreciates by x% in 3-5 years or unless you can definitely rent it for $x in 3 years, then this may be too risky a course. No one here or anywhere has a crystal ball. I WOULD NOT make this decision without a trusted financial advisor familiar with your entire financial situation weighing in.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Twins
over 18 years ago
Posts: 7
Member since: Mar 2008

If you think your job is immune to recession and depression, then you may consider continuing your journey with this purchase. However, don't forget today's rental earning's doesn't pay off your mortgages in the NYC area. You have to put down at least 30-40% down to see some level of positive cash flow or even out. Otherwise, with 20% down, you will be in a negative cash flow for at least next 7-10 years with the cap rates we have in NYC. The way the economy is moving, this very low cap rate in NYC will have to correct it self and increase otherwise, average people will have a hard time to effort anything more then $500K in the next 3-5 years. This will definitely hurt you if you want to unload your property that time. Imagine this, you bought this property with low Cap rate which is not enough to pay your mortgage, and also you lost your job in the next 3 years which is not there to subsidize the difference, if the housing market in NYC doesn't appreciate or hold it's value, you are officially in the Bankruptcy situation. Or you still have your job, but want to rent this place in the next 3-5 years, you will be still in the low cap rate situation, and your rental gain will not pay off your mortgage. So you will be destined to either continue to live there or unload the property. However, if the market price is not there for you, you will still be stuck to live there unless you want to subsidize the difference in between the mortgage payments or rental earnings.

If you still think this price is worth the risk, then go for it.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by LP1
over 18 years ago
Posts: 242
Member since: Feb 2008

Willie -- I think you should decide based on your own personal cash flow. Are you employed on Wall St? Do you have significant equity in stock? If not and you feel secure financially go ahead b/c you need a place to live.

My spouse and I have been looking to buy, but we both work on Wall Street and have decided not to execute on anything until we see a turn around in our businesses. The main issue here is we are concerned about the security of our jobs, future bonuses and our equity exposure. If we worked in health care or law I'm sure we would behave differently.

HTH

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
over 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

I agree with everybody - wait and see if your horizon is so short. If property prices do collapse - and they may - you might wind up having to rent the apartment out for less than it costs you to carry it, meaning that instead of making money you'd be losing it on two fronts: falling equity and carrying costs greater than rental income. It could become the worst investment in your life.

On the other hand, if you were going to live in it for 20 years and can afford it now, I'd say go ahead and buy, it won't cost you a thing and may make you very happy.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Tony
over 18 years ago
Posts: 140
Member since: Feb 2008

That's surprisingly sensible coming from you, Stevie. I'd generally agree, but I think we'll be out of the Bush depression in a period shorter than 20 years. Probably 20 months.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
over 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

Tone, I don't think we're in a recession. I've been making $1.5k a day every day since the end of December. That doesn't indicate a recession to me.

The only thing I think is wrong is property prices are too high. Finance is fine, Wall Street is fine (except the crisis of confidence). Real estate is my only problem in the world, though I do wish China would perk up a bit.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bjw2103
over 18 years ago
Posts: 6236
Member since: Jul 2007

1.5k a day? stevejhx, can I send you my resume?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by stevejhx
over 18 years ago
Posts: 12656
Member since: Feb 2008

bjw2103, sure. And if you speak English, Spanish, Portuguese, Italian, & know something about accounting, finance, & law, you 2 can have a job.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by Looking2Buy
over 18 years ago
Posts: 23
Member since: Aug 2007

Tony -- not an avid Bush fan by any means. But a Bush depression? Have you ever heard of a business cycle? C'mon now.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by baabamaal
over 18 years ago
Posts: 37
Member since: Mar 2008

Willie:

I am in a similar situation with a shorter time horizon (2-3 years max.), though I have not made a formal offer yet on the midtown east luxury skyrise 1Bdrm. It seemed very tempting after I saw it yesterday, but after sleeping on it and waking up to find that the 5th largest Investment Bank had vanished this morning, I am really having second thoughts. As a renter, I can walk out of a place and move if the market goes up or look for a better deal if the market is down. While it is very difficult to time the market, I do think that most Manhattan real estate prices have NOT factored in the looming recession and lack of mortgage fund liquidity. I would wait if I were you - as a renter your worst case scenario is capped, but as an owner - there is no cap, you could really hurt yourself.

Cheers, Baaba

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bjw2103
over 18 years ago
Posts: 6236
Member since: Jul 2007

stevejhx, was just having a little fun. 5 out of 7 ain't bad though.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bugelrex
over 18 years ago
Posts: 499
Member since: Apr 2007

willie:

What kind of loan were you intending to use? IO Neg ARM? If you can comfortably afford it with a 30 year fixed rate then you should just go ahead. Do you think the rent will cover the mortgage/maintaince in 5 years? You'll be bleeding badly if you need to rent it out..

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by will
over 18 years ago
Posts: 480
Member since: Dec 2007

I think if you are planning for owning more than five years and have a strong stomach, go with the deal. You may have to witness a roller coaster of a ride in both the economy and some ups and downs in median Manhattan RE prices for a year, maybe more, and that sense of "oh, I could have gotten a better deal if I had just waited," but if things go down, they will invariably come back up, and then go back up farther. And no one knows what will happen with interest rates.

There are a lot of reasons that we cite all the time on why Manhattan is different (center of the universe, low for now inventory, foreign investment, etc etc) but two other factors exist (1) the city was unusually hit by the Sept 11 attack and I think that was an ongoing drag on prices for at least a few years -- meaning that prices would be even higher here now if it wasn't for that, and (2) costs are much less than other major international cities.

So could be things may go down a little bit the next 12-18 months, but then up, and then up more.

A great American once said, "today is better than yesterday, and tomorrow will be better than today!" Well, maybe this week's stock market will bear that out... no pun intended.

So if you are buying a place you really like to live for a while, rent for a while, I say go with it!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by royally_screwed
over 18 years ago
Posts: 14
Member since: Sep 2007

Willie, just want to ask a very relevant question--is your common charges plus tax on the high end? What is it if you don't mind sharing?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by theresa
over 18 years ago
Posts: 4
Member since: Mar 2008

Hi

I am a reporter at Crain's New York Business and I'm writing a story about residential real estate in Manhattan. I'm interested in hearing from potential buyers to get your feeling on the market. Are sellers more flexible? Are you taking long time to make a decision? Are you seeing a lot of options in your price range? Are you delaying buying because you think the market will fall.

Thanks

My email is tagovino@crain.com

Theresa

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by poorishlady
over 18 years ago
Posts: 417
Member since: Nov 2007

What great American said that crapola, Will? P. T. Barnum?
But I think Willie should go for it ----- as long as the common charges/taxes are reasonable, as royally screwed asks.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by willie
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Feb 2008

Wow, lots of insights from everybody!!

For my specific situation - the real estate tax + condo charges combined are about $1.55 / sqft, half of which is tax deductible (taxes). With the new GSE conforming loan limit the 6.25% rate for 30 year fixed isn't so bad.

I think my situation is similar to many buyers sitting on the fence right now - financially ready to take the plunge but not sure about the risk. The bigges worry on people's minds right now is the potential falling equity on the property from massive layoffs that trigger huge inventory & big drop in price.

How much can Manhattan property values drop in an event of a price correction? Back to 2004 / 2005 levels?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by bugelrex
over 18 years ago
Posts: 499
Member since: Apr 2007

If you notice the streeteasy "Downtown Condo Listings Snapshot", the $ per sqft has been declining the past 2 weeks (first I've ever noticed it going down)... Not sure if its a trend, but worth noting.. numbers don't lie unlike broker babble

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by taxquestion
over 18 years ago
Posts: 13
Member since: Mar 2008

I am in the same boat (although not a luxury building), offer in, contract not signed, but really scared that I am about to sink several hundred thousand dollars into an asset that at best, will not appreciate, and at worst will decline in value. I have to believe that mortgage rates are not going to significantly increase in the coming months, and neither will apartment prices, I am really thinking of backing out. The thing is two months ago, I would have thought this was a good deal. $972/sq foot, $1/sq foot in maint, no amenities.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by BillyRes
over 18 years ago
Posts: 166
Member since: Feb 2008

Remember this is a place to live, not a stock market investment. Think long haul. It will probably take 6-7 years of living in your property before you can sell and come out ahead. If you have a stable job and plan to hold onto the property for a few years, the short term risks (1-3 years) become less relevant.

It's a buyers' market - you have choices and time to make decisions. The alternative is to wait until the market picks up, shifts to a seller's market, and be in a position to settle for a unit that is less than ideal. I recommend not adopting a day trader mentality for your home and think longer term.

I'm buying a place in Williamnsburg, a place that some would consider even more risky than most NYC neighborhoods. Depsite the abundance of new developments in the area and news of layoffs, I believe in the potential and love the neighborhood. There will be dips but I strongly believe I will come out ahead and say to myself in a few years "I'm glad I made the decision to buy." Besides, I don't want to wait another 2 years before I buy a place. I've been waiting for the "perfect time to buy" and have lost out on too many opportunities. Just my opinion.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by masterd
over 18 years ago
Posts: 55
Member since: Dec 2007

bugelrex - I didn't notice the downtown condo price/sqft on streeteasy going down. I saw it going up for the 2bedrooms - up to $1396/sqft. Perhaps the 1 bedroom index has gone down a bit, but I wouldn't rely on it. I've seen the numbers fluctuating up to $100 either way over the past year. What I did notice going up consistently are the median size and price of the 1bed and 2bed apartments.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by cranky
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Mar 2008

We currently have a contract executed for a new development downtown. 4BR/3.5BA, about 2500 sq ft. Excellent location, excellent light and layout. Doorman, garage, gym, playroom, etc. We signed contract in October 07 and are currently awaiting closing date (which should be in the next few months). Paid about 1550/sq ft.

Given the situation in the NYC markets, we are getting concerned about whether we should have waited 6 months to see what panned out in 2008. Not terribly concerned about what happens when we eventually resell the place (5+ year horizon) but rather whether we could have gotten the same thing for 10% less just by waiting a little while longer.

Question is this: anyone have experiencing getting out of a new development contract? Our lawyer said that the only real out is to ask nicely and hope the developer feels they could get a higher price, but I have a feeling he is saying this because he is working for a flat fee and just wants to get the deal done with minimal work. Any RE lawyers out there willing to provide free advice or buyers that have gone through this process? Mainly curious, haven't necessarily determined that we want to aggressively pursue.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by willie
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Feb 2008

Okay. Called the realtor and the real estate lawyer today and told them I am not moving ahead with the purchase. Going to hold on to my 20% downpayment and wait this out for another 6 months.

Thanks everybody for their input. Lets see how things turn out from here. Should be a fun summer ahead of us!!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by iMom
over 18 years ago
Posts: 279
Member since: Feb 2008

I think that was a smart move. It's not like these apartments are flying off the shelves. Best of luck to you.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by 415Buyer
over 18 years ago
Posts: 10
Member since: Apr 2006

Would you be willing to say what building, cranky?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by malraux
over 18 years ago
Posts: 809
Member since: Dec 2007

cranky - your lawyer is (basically) right. If the developer thinks they can get more, they'll gladly let you out of the contract. If they think they can't, then it's yours.

I had a call from a sponsor/developer the other day asking about a new development Village condo I had purchased from them and closed on last august for $3MM. He asked if I would sell the place for a $1MM profit. So if your developer thinks they sold your unit way too cheap (which mine did, and I knew it, but he wasn't not they brightest bulb in the bunch - no vision), they'll come back to you, even AFTER the fact.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by cranky
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Mar 2008

malraux, thanks. Do did you take the deal? Sounds like a tidy profit. When did you sign your contract?

415Buyer, the building is in BPC would prefer not to get too specific on this forum.

I wonder if there is any precedent or grounds for renegotiating a signed contract based on changes in market conditions. For example, if the sponsor were to lower the price of a comparable unit that has not sold yet such that it would be less per sqft than mine all other things being equal (floor, etc), would that give us any basis to work with?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by malraux
over 18 years ago
Posts: 809
Member since: Dec 2007

cranky:

I didn't take the deal. It's the place I bought to permanently live in, so it's not a $ /- situation. We signed the contract initially in July 2006.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by willie
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: Feb 2008

Hmm. Realtor called back after few days and asked me to "name a price you feel comfortable with"..

asking for a 10% cut from the originally agreed upon price would mean getting into a full service condo at $760 psqft. Very tempting!!

Thoughts on how much condo prices could drop in manhattan over the course of next couple years?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by malraux
over 18 years ago
Posts: 809
Member since: Dec 2007

Willie:

If you're only really living there for 3-5 years and then want to turn it into an income producing property, you could get hurt. I say 'just say no.'

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by JuiceMan
over 18 years ago
Posts: 3578
Member since: Aug 2007

willie, what are 750 sqft 1 beds renting for in that building?

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment

Most popular

  1. 10 Comments
  2. 10 Comments
  3. 8 Comments