Exclusive right to sell?
Started by andwin
over 18 years ago
Posts: 80
Member since: Jan 2008
Discussion about
Exclusive right to sell seems to be what most brokers want you to sign. It seems like 6 months is a long time to give someone an exclusive right to sell. What happens if your not happy with their efforts? In the internet age it seems like advertising overhead is almost zero now. So it's not like there are huge up front expenses for the broker. Has anyone been able to negotiate open or agency listings without a 6 month commitment? Thanks
I have sold a few houses with brokers and I have signed 3 month contracts. I explain to the broker that I want the right to fire them quickly if I feel they're not doing the job. I've always stated that if I believe they're acting in my best interests I would expect to re-sign for another 3 months if the property didn't sell. Never has anyone said no to that and if they did I would worry about their reasoning. As it always turned out, my properties have sold within the 3 month period so it never became an issue. In this environment sales might be tougher because of optimistic seller assumptions of where the market currently is, so I can see reluctance only if the broker believes the asking price is too high.
I am a real estate agent and I would not take a listing with only a 3-month exclusive -- for one thing Manhattan properties are averaging over 4 months on market!
You will get the service you pay for. If you don't want to use a broker, don't use a broker, but if you do want to use a broker, let them do their job.
Also, anyone who takes your listing should be able to defend the price they ask and where the money goes. On my latest exclusive, I have spent money creating a website to showcase the apartment; paying a handyman to fix small things that the owner had let slide, that were necessary to get the apartment in tip-top condition; and on print advertising as well as internet advertising.
In addition, maintaining our networks -- because it's most likely that the apartment gets sold to someone with a listing broker -- costs money in terms of professional dues and database fees.
Finally, the two largest costs for any agent are probably office rent and time. Again, your agent should be able to tell you what their time costs, and to justify that expenditure on your part.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Ali: Why do you need an office? More to the point, what is the benefit to a seller of you having dedicated office space? Your profession seems ideally suited to the mobile office/home office mode of operation. Andwin points out the ways that the Internet has changed advertising. If anything, it has changed the need for a physical office even more.
You already think brokers do not do enough, and you are telling them to work from home?
Most agents will start with 6 months, but will settle for 3 if you ask them. As with a lot of things in the business world, people often try to get more from people who do not know better.
MAV: It doesn't really matter to me whether an agent works in an office at home, or on the Moon. I'm just asking why an office is necessary, and how sellers benefit from the added overhead (which ultimately comes out of the proceeds of a sale).
I think the Internet has changed the profession, although I'm not all that reflective about "the good old days" because I've only been doing this for a couple of years.
But there are two answers to "why do I need an office" in an Internet world.
1) My time is valuable to my customers, and I need to be relatively close to the properties that I am helping them buy and sell. When I don't go to my office on 16th Street, I do indeed work out of my home in Midtown, but to the extent that my laptop and my files take up space in my home, a $500K condo, those are business costs, and they're going to get passed on in the cost to my customers. (We haven't even talked about the fact that I went to my actual office in Chelsea today to create a pdf so that the buyers 3,000 miles away could get a presentation that they could print out and discuss with each other.)
Along that theme, the inventory of properties isn't all so much the same -- it's not shares of IBM -- that real estate pros can eliminate records of what it is. New York State requires I keep paper files for years, and frankly, it helps me sometimes to look up what one seller said 18 months ago. What I do is pretty electronic, but I can't work on the subway.
2) I need a watercooler. If what I am doing is true brokerage -- connecting buyers with different psychologies to available properties with different profiles -- I need to add something the buyers can't have themselves, and to some extent that's knowledge of inventory. The best way to get that -- especially in a fast-moving market -- is to go to a physical office and hang out with other agents from my firm. For example, I've got a corporate buyer looking for a "hotel-y" 2-BR -- the Orion is a logical choice, but my boss pointed out to me that there's something with a bigger footprint available on Seventh Avenue -- and one of my colleagues told me that there's something in a building he lives in in West Chelsea that would be perfect.
I'm not selling Range Rovers; one apartment REALLY is different from another. For my corporate buyers, they are getting a level of service that involves us not just picking inventory based on computer photos, but on us picking out physical spaces (which ultimately, is what we're selling) that we try to have actually been in. It's the difference between saying "oh, the floorplan for #2B looks nice" and saying "you should show them Mike's apartment, because he did something great when he flipped the kitchen."
This may be a level of service that West81st may not want or need to pay for -- which is just fine by me. But some people do want this level of service, and will pay for it, and in fact consider the costs somewhat negligible given that I am helping them make the best possible multi-million dollar financial decision.
Those people are my clients.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
Ali: Thanks very much for your thoughtful response. The one time I sold a Manhattan apartment, I worked with an agent from a major firm, and was very pleased with the results. That was eight years ago, at the height of the original 'Net boom. The agent - who was very young - wasn't sold on technology as a replacement for human contact. Although he took panoramic images of the apartment and posted them on his firm's site, he always insisted that technology was just a useful adjunct to the real work of selling apartments.
I didn't intend the question as an attack, and I'm glad you didn't take it as one. I just wanted a professional's view on the bricks-vs.-clicks question as it affects the industry in 2008. Sometimes I wonder if the fancy offices are just nice places for senior management to sit on their laurels.