Scared about economy & NY RE?
Started by interested1
over 18 years ago
Posts: 2
Member since: Apr 2008
Discussion about
and the fact that europeans are started to feel credit crunch. Despite a weak dollar is there hope they can continue to prop up the market? Also what if Bernankes rate cuts dont work? My friend at Citi just got a 3 months notice that they wouldnt be promoting him so he's looking at new options. Finally, would it seem reasonable to wait out the storm so real estate prices for 1BR fall back to around 300-450K? Robert Schiller, an economist at Yale predicts NY will be hard hit over next 2 years, especially next fall-winter.
1 BR for 300-450k...I can only dream!!!
You will be shocked to what's about to happen. You can be optimistic all you want but it's all gonna collapse. good luck
It depends on your situation. It makes a big difference if you are long term holder, financially secure, job secure, etc., compared to short term, financially streached. I think urbandigs has a post on this somewhere - try and check it out.
There are a lot of ways to analyze it, but at the end of the day you can not time the market so I agree that personal factors are the more important.
Had a random thought today related to interest rates and prices. Since price appreciation is tied to cheap money, if mortgage rates continue to rise, how much could prices fall in the next 3-5 years to have no impact on my monthy cost assuming mortgage rates revert to their historical mean? I know this is a big assumption but just thinking out loud.
so assume the following:
mortgage $1MM
current 30 fixed rate 6.75% (20% down)
historical mean mortgage rate approx. 8.5%
The payment on a $1.2MM place would be $6,486. So if mortgages revert to 8.5% how much of a mortgage can I carry for that same payment? about $845K, so a $1.045MM place.
Meaning that prices could drop by about 13% (from $1.2 to $1.045) and I'm still in exactly the same spot.
so who cares if prices go down if rates are going up?
at the same time I disagree with myself because I think the Fed is going to be very accomodating, but thought it was fodder for discussion.
my assumptions:
Today's 30 year rate on $1MM of 6.75%. called mortgage broker today to get quote. buyer tip if you are in the market - you can get much better rates going to banks that sell from their own portfolio and not to wall street
Historical mortgage rate of 8.5% - pulled the mothly data from freddiemac for 1987 to 2000. why these dates? after Volckers war on inflation and before free money
mschlee: If you buy at the lower price, with the higher rate, you can refi when rates fall again. If you pay the higher price and get the lower rate, you don't get the same kind of mulligan on the purchase price if the value of your property falls.
Buy low. Sell high. A low purchase price, and correspondingly small debt, are wonderful things. You can always refinance a crappy mortgage, as long as your financial circumstances don't erode.
mschlee - Astute comment. One other factor is that you can also get more apartment if the amount of payment you can afford is not the limiting factor but rather the down payment. Also, although the 12-24 months payments in reserve will still be the same closing costs and commissions, in addition to down payment will be lower. And in your example for people who are cash rich they can get that much closer to conforming or to a 50% down co-op.
agreed, much easier to get out of a "crappy" mortgage than a crappy price. even if you think rates are going to go up, refi option is valuable insurance.
guess the point i was making was that it is not all doom and gloom. will the market continue up? dont think many people would take that bet. how much, who knows. it's more a personal choice. tring to time the market is a futile effort.
mschlee , which banks sell from their own portfolio ? thanks
Agreed, West 81st. And anyone thinking long-term gets to pay their principal down that much faster.
Regarding the idea of timing the market, I don't think most bears expect to do that. The point is that with things trending down and the likelihood of saving a significant amount of money being much greater than a price increase, patience makes good sense.
Also if the interest rate is higher you have a potentially greater tax deduction and more of your mortgage expense may fall under the 1M limit excluding Heloc.
better you should have a higher interest rate IF the purchase price is lower, but in any case, always best to not be so stretched on the mortgage interest that you can't pay down the principal.
Something else I found in my years of being underwater that most people won't have the dubious pleasure of learning -- sometimes paying off extra principal at any mortgage rate is getting that money a higher rate of compounded interest than any safe savings vehicle. If mortgage rates were to be at 7.5%, for instance, each $200 you pay in additional principal you could look at as "saving" at 7.5% compounded over X years. Anyone getting CDs for 7.5% lately? In 2002 CDs were paying around 1%.
While everyone on this board is arguing that prices are going to go down and waiting it out, it's happening now. There are price reductions all over the market. A short time ago, apartments were going 5 - 10% over listing, routinely. Now you have price reductions and apartments often going for 5 - 10% below asking. You can already get a 10 - 15% savings over a couple of years ago if you shop carefully. Will it go down more? Maybe. Who knows. The economy is not going to be in the tank forever. If you want to continue to wait - I'm no prognasticator - wait. Wait until there are signs of an economic recovery and everyone jumps back into the market and bidding wars on apartments return. It just seems that there are nice discounts to be had out there now. Just my .02.
US lost 80,000 jobs last month- biggest monthly decline in 5 years.
The RATE of job losses is accelerating... this is really really discouraging data for those who were still are trying to believe there is a chance of avoiding a recession (aka those in denial).
sfo, work with a mortgage broker. i can't say true for all, but my broker has contacts with these banks so i'm guessing other do as well.
tenemental - deciding to wait, or get in for that matter, because expectation of future price movements is in fact market timing (please don't take that as an attempt to isnult you, just pointing it out) i'm not disagreeing that fundementals seem to point to decreases, but they have for over 5 years, in which time someone could have made a lot of money.
my point was to interested1 (original poster) that nobody knows where the market is going and they dont know where interest rates are going. using fundamental analysis would have had you sitting on the sidelines through the entire real estate run up. it would have also had you sitting on the sidelines for the dot com run up. the list goes on. my suggestion was to make the decision based on his/her personal situation and forget trying to time the market.
mschlee, I don't take that as an insult. It may be market timing in the very broadest sense, but I don't think it's what most bulls have in mind when they say "you can't time the market." I think there's a huge difference between following a trend in a general sense and thinking you can pick the bottom. I may buy at a discount to 2007 and then find that prices have gone even lower. Or prices may bottom and then come back halfway before I buy. Either way is better than buying now, if you believe as I do that the likelihood of a price decrease is much greater than the likelihood of a price increase.
No insult meant from me either, but I don't think the indicators during the runup were anywhere near as negative as they were in 2007 and are now playing out.
good point mschlee, so much analysis has been made, numbers thrown out there left and right. It is a personal matter -- from job security and eventual wifey/kid(s) to location, your credit, and your timeframe. I've honestly had to adjust my gameplan, weathering the current storm: while there is a discount at the moment, this most certainly won't last. I predict the sun will rise and prices will start to tick upwards by Q2 09. This gives lots of calculated players that want to enter the market a chance to get off the renting sidelines..but like what has been said, don't think you'll time it impeccably -- a sure candidate for paralysis by analysis. Until the stock market settles, it's a great time to aggressively pay back principal.