When Will You Buy?
Started by october
over 18 years ago
Posts: 145
Member since: Mar 2008
Discussion about
For the buyers out there - I was wondering, based on your own outlook (bull/bear), when do you think that you will actually buy New York real estate. My own thoughts - I am looking right now - but I think that I am going to hold off at least one year. This is based on my own assumption that prices between now and next April will be flat and that even if somehow the market does go up it will not go up more than 5%. (In the mean time I have very positive cash flow from a - knock on wood - fairly secure job. I'm hoping to use that positive cash flow to either put down a larger downpayment or get a larger apt. next year) Thoughts?
I sold (Manhattan) and just bought (Queens, Forest Hills). I got twice the space for half the price, and am pocketing the difference. I also got a 20 minute express train to Manhattan, I acknowledge. But I don't think it was a bad trade off (for me.).
I backed out of a deal a few weeks ago for a one bedroom in kips bay, and is still looking. If the right property comes up at the right price and it is a property I can stay in for 10 years, I will probably jump in. Otherwise I am holding on to my cash continue to rent / save.
October, same boat as you in. But I gotta say this past year was very frustrating as all signs point to a decline in prices and yet sellers refuse to give in.
Wouldn't touch any property for at least a year. NYC housing has begun it's slide. Give it sometime for people to realize they can no longer afford their condos and let the effects of tighter credit eliminate the competition.
Sometime this year, most likely 3rd/4th quarter. Waiting for Downtown Brooklyn to come down a bit (Fort Greene, Boerum Hill area). Also waiting for some buildings to start selling like the one in Brooklyn Heights.
Slee - I agree this past year just seemed crazy to me. The signs were all starting to show about a downward economic trend - and everyone kept saying - "not in New York."
Will put off for a year as market will prob be flat. But will buy sooner if something nice comes up on the market.
don't think you can time the market. there won't be an alert in your inbox that says, "BUY NOW." That being said, i bought one year ago in carroll gardens and the latest report of property value in 1Q 08 in BK came in at + 3%. Pretty resilient during a time like this. I'm a non-Wall Streeter and intend to assume a worse case scenario horizon by paying down principal aggressively enough to prepare to rent when I want to upgrade from my condo. Although they say for every Wall Street job lost, it will affect 3 NY workers, Wall Street makes up 35% of NY economy, etc, overall salaries here are sustainable enough to withstand mortgage, inflation, recession. Clearly it's not a flipping climate, but if you have a 5 year horizon...there are deals to be had in my eyes until next year at this time.
I agree with curious007. Also, if you are looking to build massive equity in 5 years and then sell, then I would say it might be safe to temper down your expectation. Prices will go up although probably not enough (as in the past 5 years). If you do a 5 year analysis you will more than likely come out on top. You can then treat any appreciation as a potential upside but don't make decisions solely based on it, that way any potential drop in house value will not impact you too much.
I am basing it less on time than on prices.
I am in the market, and will buy when I see fundamentals make sense - by which I mean
(a) buying costs 10 - 20% more than renting (not 2X as it is now), and/or
(b) assumed growth included in the price of purchase is close to zero (i.e., if the price doesnt appreciate at all, i wont lose a lot of money vis a vis renting)
when will this happen? 1 yr, 2yr, perhaps longer. i am, quite frankly, in no hurry.
I aggresively looked to buy for the last 6 months after selling the co-op I lived in for 17 years. I wanted a bigger place to live with my fiance. When wqe found a great place and finally convinced one the seller she was asking an insane price and had to come down some, she agreed to the first part and then pulled the property from the market rather than reduce the asking price. After that, we've seen a lot of apartments that were laden with compromises that I was unwilling to accept at the current market prices. So I'll leave the money from my co-op sale to work for me and I've rented a place that I love and will serve us well for now. I'll keep looking (albeit less franetically) and suck it up if I find the perfect place and have to break my lease. But I am in absolutely no rush since this market seems to get incrementally mushier and mushier with each day that passes, and I'm happy to let sellers feel the heat for a change.
As far as being an investor goes, I will buy at any time that I find what I believe to be a truly exceptional unit that I know I can always rent out for solid positive cash flow. Even during the last severe downturn, certain specific properties that have unusual amenities (stellar layouts, size, light, views, finishes, location, penthouses, wrap terraces, fireplaces, etc.) still rented out at very high prices. But one must be doggedly clear about what is truly exceptional, and run hard math on the specific unit.
I'm not interested in timing a market. Things go up and down. Truly exceptional properties always do extremely well - my viewpoint based on 25 years +/- experience.
I will wait at least a year because I think it will be ugly for Wall St this year, and that will only realize itself after the next bonus cycle in Q1 09. Also, I think it will take some time for mortgage co's to start to provide attractive credit again (I am assuming jumbos for co-ops). Of course, if I come across the old lady who's stepped on a banana peel . . .
Kylewest,
Did you have a capital gain from your recent coop? If you are planning on buying another place sometime soon, why didn't you purchase something within the time period to avoid taxes on capital gain?
just curious.
I recently cancelled my contract on an new development when they did not meet the contract deadline for closing b/c I think there's going to be a significant drop in NYC prices w. good opportunities in the next 12 mos. Banks and consequently bankers in NY are getting slammed- bonuses will be way down, and unfortunately, thousands will lose their jobs. Markets are down in Europe. Profound drop in the stock markets in China and India. Per the WSJ, law firms are cutting back on new hires. Per WSJ worldwide, hedge funds lost money last year. All this at a time when enormous supply of new construction is in the pipeline for NYC. In addition a lot of condo sales in the past few yrs has gone to investors who are much more likely to bolt when the prices start to fall (as they did in Florida, Las Vegas, etc. It's wishfull thinking on the part of brokers and some owners to think NYC real estate is not going to suffer.
In the near term time is on the buyer's side.
ba294: I think you might misunderstand the capital gains law. The "rollover" provision to defer (not avoid) capital gains only applies to investment properties--not to one's primary residence. This changed a little ways back and many people didn't get the memo. For a primary residence, if you have lived in it for at least 2 years (I think that's the time requirement) you get a cap gains exemption for up to $250,000 if single, $500,000 for a married couple. This is NOT something to play games with the IRS about. Try to make your weekend house your primary residence for tax purposes and woe be to you if you're audited. And vice versa. For that second home, the rollover would apply. So, once you sell your primary home, there is no tax advantage to buying a new home sooner than later.
I'm not interested in trying to pick a bottom. I know that mentality is the easiest way to get burned. Nor am I trying to perpetuate a doom/gloom or crash/burn panic for my own benefit.
I just think that the gap between the actual state of the economy and the state of the economy implied by NYC RE prices has widened significantly. Meaning that the actual economy has deteriorated, but RE is still priced as though we are still in a pre-credit-crisis environment. Sure, some sellers are offering incentives towards closing costs and perhaps some have even reduced their asking prices slightly from their aspirational levels but I think for the most part, sellers have bought into the broker-spin that the market is still strong and are in a state denial about what is going on with the job market, inflation, credit tightness, growing inventory, looming NYC tax-revenue squeeze and Wall Street bonus-outlook for next year.
I am confident that in the near-to-medium term, it's more likely that RE prices will adjust downward to reflect the true state of the economy than the economy improving back up to early-2007 levels - no matter what any selling-broker will tell you. When RE prices start reflecting reality, I'll be comfortable getting in. Until then, I take comfort in knowing that each passing day that properties sit idle on the market and inventory grows is another day my analysis is validated.
imom: "When RE prices start reflecting reality, I'll be comfortable getting in."
And if that is the common sentiment, then everyone who feels like you do will rush to buy, and the prices go up again, and this board perpetuates unchanged for eternity...
The thing is this: people who cannot afford something should not be able to buy it and bury themselves in debt. So the market, or natural selection of the market, with pain gurgling sounds will correct itself and it is normal.
I was doing this rent vs buy calculation based on Streeteasy data. When I compared a similar unit (size, area etc), the monthly carrying cost to own a condo apartment is atleast 60% higher than the rent. It is over atleast 40% for co-ops. No one in their right mind will want to buy an apartment in this market climate.
Westelle: You are only partly correct. Yes, if prices adjust to a more justifiable level (downward), people will start to buy. We've seen that appropriately priced properties (a few sellers actually understand that we are in tough economic times) have been selling. Aspirationally priced properties or difficult properties (awkward layout, no view, inconvenient location, etc) continue to sit on the market because their owners are still in denial.
However, not all prices for all properties will adjust downward simultaneously and not all buyers will buy simultaneously. The RE market is not a liquid market like commodities or forex. RE prices take time to adjust and transactions take time to be executed. So if RE prices start to come down (assuming the economy stays where it is and does not deteriorate further), buyers will start to enter the market. But prices won't come down so quickly that it creates a "rush to buy" or a stampede of people jumping into the market. What is more likely is that sellers will gradually adjust their prices to what the market will bare (downward) and we may see an uptick in volume of transactions being closed at lower price levels than we are at today. It's called "market clearing equilibrium." We're not at that point today, which is why sales volume is down and inventory is rising. Buyers and sellers, for the most part, are not on the same page as to were the market is at.
And about your second point - Yes, people should not buy what they cannot afford. That's how the housing crisis got started. If you are implying that the reason I am not buying at this level is because I can't afford it, you are wrong. I CAN afford the current asking prices of the properties I am looking at. I just happen to believe they are overvalued and that they will become cheaper in the near-medium term. Just because you can afford to buy something doesn't necessarily mean you should buy it right away.
I agree with everyone that timing the market would only lead to heartbreak. I think the credit mess might also cause problems for buyers trying to come in with 10% on condos (putting aside that co-ops want at least 20%). dco raises a good point - even if prices do go down, first time buyers without a bag of capital might still find themselves in a hard place trying to get financing from the newly conservative lending banks. I plan on buying for the long term - so I'm also waiting to find something that I'd really be happy coming home to.
I wonder if the Streeteasy site will actually facilitate more potential buyers doing the rent vs buy calculation now that data can easily be found on comparable units (especially in large buildings). It takes some pretty amazing assumptions (and a strong desire to shrink your net worth) to conclude that buying makes sense right now - or even after a 20% fall.
kylewest,
I had just thought since you had lived for a while the appreciation was greater than 500k. If my primary residence (>2years out of 5) has capital gain of >500k and want to rollover to something bigger and pocket the 500k without the tax, is that possible? For instance, 500k -> 1.5M. I sell the apt for 1.5M then buy one for 1M, can I pocket then 500K? Thanks
ba294,
No that would not work. The rollover concept was the prior tax break for primary residences. Unlimited gains, but had to rollover within two years, as I recall. So in your example the full $1mm gain would have been tax free if you rolled over into a home within two years of at least that value. Now the tax-free gain is limited to $500k if married (but note you pay only 15% cap gain on the amt over that), and no rollover of the gain is required.
ba294: KISS is correct in that there is no longer a rollover provision for any amount in a primary residence. I thought I said that above, but perhaps I wasn't clear. There is NO exception for a primary residence no matter what permutation of selling/purchasing you come up with. After deducting your cost basis, you get the $250K for singles and $500K if married exempt from capital gains and must pay the tax on the remainder.
kylewest, I wasn't clear when you spoke about the sale of a second home. Did you say the rollover was in effect then?
The rollover provision to defer capital gains can be used, with a fair number of restrictions, for investment properties which would generally mean second homes.
Really? Wouldn't you have to rent it out to make a second home an investment property?
KISS: as I said, "with a fair number of restrictions." Anyone looking to do this needs to talk to an accountant and/or RE attorney for the details. If you rent it for 10 months a year and use it for 2 months...if you live in part of the house on weekends but rent out the rest of it full time...if you rent it to a family member... these are the kinds of twists you need specific advice about from someone who knows your circumstances. But the fact remains, no rollover for primary residence. May have rollover available for additional homes you own.
kylewest, I don't think you can't live in the second house at all to use that provision, or use the house at all, to take the investment real estate rollover. It's the same rules as putting it in an IRA, if I'm not mistaken. Eventually, however, you will have to pay capital gains when you stop rolling over. It is merely a deferment.
NYS and NYC tax capital gains as regular income. If you have huge gains, don't expect to get the 15% capital gains tax rate. It will be taxed at 26% under AMT, and most likely your NYS / NYC income tax will not be fully deductible.
Steve, I don't think I said anything contrary to what you said.