What Would You Want From A Brokerage Firm?
Started by urbandigs
over 18 years ago
Posts: 3629
Member since: Jan 2006
Discussion about
Question for you guys? Seeing that the brokerage industry has such a poor reputation, and putting aside a moment that alot has to do with individual agents who conduct business in their own manner to get their commission, WHAT SERVICES WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE OFFERED FROM A BROKERAGE FIRM that is not currently offered? I have my own ideas, but would love to hear directly from the buyers/sellers/homeowners/renters themselves. What is not offered out there, that should be, to make the real estate transaction process more service oriented?
Well, in a perfect world...
- Meaningful analysis of comps and trends (rather than the sales hype we currently get).
- Standardized quantitative and qualitative profiles of buildings, including:
- status of finances;
- aging and repair record of major systems;
- safety information, including security, hazmat, fire suppression, and evacuation planning:
- to the extent possible, data on owners/shareholders, including years in residence;
- Standardized quantitative and qualitative profiles of blocks and neighborhoods;
- Management of school visits.
How much more of this pie-in-the sky can you handle, Noah?
well I asked for it...thx for input!
A fiduciary responsibility to their clients regardless of whether they are buy or sell side clients.
A stated professional responsibilities and code of conduct with the client in mind.
not much, just honesty.
I go for honesty, integrity, and professionalism. Advise me how to get the best real estate value for my money vs which purchase is quickest, easiest, and most lucrative for themselves or their company. Put the client first, knowing that when they do, they will reap the benefits in the end. The truth is, the model is broken. Buyers should pay their agents for the time they spend regardless of whether a purchase is made and sellers should pay their agents for trying to market their property as lucratively as possible. For both buyers' agents and sellers' agents to be dependent on the seller for their livelihoods is just asking for abuses to the system. It is tough for a buyer's broker to actually look for the best deal for the buyer when collusion with the seller's broker for a higher price reaps higher rewards. The model is broken, but I don't think it is ever likely to get fixed.
I'd like to see the range of services offered individually. With the tools that exist today, someone may be able to do very good market analysis/comps, but maybe needs help marketing their property, or negotiating, etc. Or the oppsite.
I'd like my agent to be cluefull and honest, but not pretend to know everything.
great stuff guys, thanks. I too agree with the easy part: Honesty, Integrity, & Professionalism. Reputation is hard to break, and I've spent years blogging about what I see out there in the hopes that the brand of urbandigs wins those 3 character traits.
The idea of transforming this into a new age brokerage firm intrigues me, but in my mind, I think control is something that can be provided to buyer and sellers. Control and access to information and data. Cant go into details here, but please keep these thoughts coming. I agree the model is flawed, but finding a new model that goes against the biggest players here in Manhattan, even if its better, may be a recipe setup to fail. Or maybe it will be bought out as a threat. Who knows. I know there is a new way of transforming how real estate business is transacted that is better than today's.
Thats all I know.
I had agents falling all over each other to sell my apartment. It has certain flaws that I pointed out and was assured weren't problems. They are. This was in the later part of February--while Bear Stearns hadn't imploded yet the stock market had been going down since November--again I pointed this out. No problem--three teams of agents from the big three--all playing deaf when I brought things up. My apartment was in pristine shape--nothing had to be decluttered etc--looking back I wish it hadn't been in such good shape as they wouldn't have been so eager.
Now the problems I pointed out and Bear Stearns--my apartment went on the market that weekend--are being pointed out as the reason for the lack of activity
So more than anything else I would appreciate honesty and being listened to. I could do the comps myself easily. Clara Hemphill has an excellent series of books on schools in Manhattan--while it's good for the broker to be knowledgeable and know good furniture cleaners etc I would consider those things to be the buyer or sellers responsibility
Marketing-that's not my expertise when it comes to something I own. I need the realtor to have a clear marketing plan. I don't want to meet the buyer until the closing so they have to do the negotiating. I need to be appraised of interest or not and why or why not but I don't want to know about everybody who has seen the apartment. I only want to know when they have seen it at least twice and are ready to make a bid
I need the broker to be very enthused and talk up the property. I don't want them to be actively selling too many properties at once.
Then there are little touches: it's nice if a broker brings flowers and other things. I know they do in a hot market but I'm still paying 6%--I'm sweating more and making less--it's still a great commission.
Because I can live in my summer house, I'm not there. Hopefully that makes it easier for the broker to bring people whenever. I want them to make the arrangements with my cleaning person and with the building--as much as they can
I have never forgot the scene in American Beauty where Annette Benning stood on a ladder and cleaned a chandelier. Really I want her to be my broker but....
I think we all have different needs but one goal. We want to sell or buy, for as much or little, and as painlessly as possible Unfortunately this isn't a painless time so I need the broker to be my cheerleader
I don't think you will set up to fail if you bring variations of models. Threats--anybody good in anything is perceived as a threat by somebody. That's something you have to factor in and get over. I don't mean that harshly--I know how hard it is to have integrity in Manhattan
I'm not the enemy because I'm selling and don't want to be perceived as such by prospective buyers. My coop board is angry because I'm selling for less than they want me to though they will approve a buyer for that price or up to 10% down. It's time for buyers to realize that many sellers are being realistic and the broker is the person who can show that