Will the proximity of hosuing projects affect your property?
Started by prple777
over 18 years ago
Posts: 27
Member since: May 2008
Discussion about
We found a gorgeous apartment up in East Harlem, but we are kind of hesistant to buy because of its close proximity to a housing project (the project is located on the next block). What do you think? Will this affect future sales?
compare that with the Caledonia built by Related Companies on West 17th (or so) street, just next door to the projects.
The saying is buy the worse house on the nicest street...not the other way around.
East Harlem is inundated with NYCHA housing projects. In fact there are about 30,000 apartment units of public housing with nearly 75,000 people living in them. These projects are the tallest buildings in the neighborhood by far -- often 20 stories-- and are set on superblocks, sometimes encompassing 6 regular city blocks. The residents of the public housing do not only get free housing from the government. They get free medical care at the city owned hospitals like North General on East 119th Street; free food at food banks and at the projects; free public schools; free transportation often by jumping the farebox. Living for free in Manhattan is so attractive to these people that thousands of illegal immigrants are pouring in from West Africa, Mexico, and the entire third world to take advantage of the generous NYC social welfare system. In their free time, these people enjoy shooting guns in nearby Marcus Garvey Park on East 120th-East 124th Street. In fact on Memorial Day weeeknd 2008, 8 people wer shot. So the answer to your question is yes, you will love living in an expensive condo beside the projects: I'd recommend bidding over $1 million.
Columbus: Public housing isn't free. Rent is pegged at 30% of family AGI. It's a lousy system, and there's probably a fair amount of fraud and abuse, but it isn't free. And with 140,000 names on the waiting list, I don't think the projects are a magnet for illegal immigrants either, though I guess some do move in with relatives who have NYCHA apartments.
Getting back to the subject, I basically agree with julia, except for two things: First, you get more home for your money on a crummy block, so the trade-off makes sense for a lot of people; second, if prple777 stays in that apartment long enough, there's a possibility of a windfall if the city ever gets around to bulldozing all of its high-density public housing as a tragic failure of good intentions.
West81st. Is that actually your answer. WOW 777 look else where. If crime starts to climb and it's already started you will take a bath on that investment. There is ZERO chance this city would ever "ulldoze" a project. Can you imagine relocating 30,000 people at one shot.
Dear West81st, it must be easy for you to maintain an ivory tower view of Harlem as a working class panacea while you are dining on salmon and white truffles at trendy new restaurants like eightyone on the Upper West Side. But let me tell you directly as someone who moved from 81st Street to 116th Street, there are literally thousands of illegal immigrants who move to Harlem from impoverished third world countries and consumer the social welfare that is lavished upon them by the taxpayers of Manhattan. I see it every day as I head off to work -- they sit on the sidewalks. When I get home -- they are still sitting on the sidewalks. Meanwhile, 50% of my income from working all day goes to taxes. I would challenge you to take the subway up from your glorious Upper West Side, walk the streets of Harlem, and see if I have not accurately described the conditions.
And you can not compare Harlem to the Caledonia in West Chelsea...two totally different hoods and totally different residents...African-American and West Indies in Harlem and Latin American in Chelsea...two different work ethic's as well
Columbus:
1) What portion of your taxes do you think go to public assistance programs?
2) No one pays 50% of their income in taxes. The highest possible *marginal* rate in NYC for federal+state+local+payroll taxes combined is 46.65%, and effective tax rates will always be lower than that. If you can't afford to eat at eightyone, your effective tax rate would be much lower than that.
3) Illegal immigrants aren't eligible for most kinds of social welfare; in fact, legal immigrants aren't eligible for many kinds.
4) Do you really think the people that sit on the sidewalk of your house constitute a statistically meaningful portion of the groups you seem intent on condemning? Sometimes I go to SoHo in the morning and I see rich people doing nothing but shopping, and when I go home later on I see the same people still just shopping! Clearly, rich people do nothing useful and only shop.
Jordyn,
Rich people shop with THEIR OWN MONEY! Surely you understand the difference.
I'm sure I won't be the first person to tell you this:
You have a skewed version of reality.
People sit around on the sidewalk with their own money, too. What's your point?
They sit with their welfare money. That is not their own money. That is the difference.
Who that has their own money sits on the sidewalk? That is nonsensical.
Since when do you need welfare money to sit on the sidewalk? That's nonsensical.
jordyn - the point is that the people sitting on the sidewalk with their own money that comes from working people's money. What a demagogue logic you use.
This conversation is dumb.
The original point I was making was that trying to judge a large population based on the tiny fraction that you happen to see in a particular circumstance is silly (i.e., I assume that most rich people actually work for a living and do something to earn their money rather than just shopping all of the time, just as I assume that there are many people that live in the housing projects that do something other than sit on the sidewalk all day).
While we're at it, though, the fact that rich people shop with their own money is irrelevant, though. It doesn't cost anything to sit on the sidewalk! So people that are sitting on the sidewalk are using exactly as much of other people's money as the rich people are: none.
Just think when Senator Obama becomes President we'll all be trying to get into public housing as we'll be taxed out of our apartments/homes, restaurants, etc. See you at the shelter in '09!!!
Obama will not be the president.
Julia, good point. I of course hope you are wrong about that one!
Stakan, I, of course, hope you are correct!
Apt_boy: I lived in the projects for 4 years while I was growing up. Due to my work ethic you can call this African-American woman "condo_girl". Sorry to disappoint your stereotyping.