Offer on original price or on reduced price?
Started by newbie2008
over 18 years ago
Posts: 14
Member since: Jun 2008
Discussion about
Now that we're seeing more price decreases - I was wondering if I'm supposed to make an initial offer (negotiate) based on the original asking price or the reduced price? For example, if original asking price is $1 mil and the reduced price is $900K - do I make my original bid based on 5% off the $1 mil or the $900K? My broker seems to suggest that my initial offer should be based on the original price but that doesn't seem right either. Any other suggestions?
In this market, I'd offer 6-10% off the reduced price. You can always negotiate up if necessary.
i would negotiate off the reduced price. i don't know why your broker is suggesting to base on the original price - you are correct in that it doesn't seem right. look at it another way - if you were the seller, wouldn't it be strange if a potential buyer made an offer based on the original asking price.
Another thought - your offer is a dollar amount anyway.
If the current listing price is $900k, that is now the asking price. $1MM no longer exists. Perhaps there's more to the story, but your broker sounds like he wants you to pay more than necessary to increase his commission. My sleaze alarm went crazy reading your post.
So, starting from $900k, how does tha apartment compare to comps. Did your broker do a comps analysis for/with you (somehow I'm going to guess not)? It may still be wildly overpriced, in which case your bid should reflect that.
If it's priced close to comps at $900k, try to judge the needs of the seller. Is it empty (the seller's carrying two homes, bleeding $ every month)? Has it been on the market a long time (besides the current listing, check the previous listings here to see if was listed before)? Any clues from the seller's broker regarding the seller's motivation level)? Google the address, there may be some clues or valuable information on the building. Assuming you have good comps, you should try to get as much of a feel as you can for the seller's situation to determine how aggressively below comps you want to bid. At the very least, bid a little bit below comps to allow the seller room to counter. Unless, of course, you feel a need to factor in a decline of value in the coming market, in which case you need to go lower.
Sorry - just to clarify, my broker didn't DIRECTLY say that my offer should be based on the original asking price but when I gave her my offer # - she said that I have to be careful not to lowball too much b/c seller just reduced his price amd I don't want to discourage the seller from negotiating. Hence, I got the impression that she thinks I should've based it on the original offer.
Appreciate everyone's help.
this is why-brokers SUCK- lets be honest, in today's mkt, sellers should be happy to receive a bid, the reason why sellers lower their offer is because the selling price wasn't realistic, it wasn't lowered because it hasn't sold, it was lowered because the selling price wasn't attracting offers "No ACTION", your broker should show you the history on the unit- show you the comps in the building on that line, should know how long on the mkt? And remember its not low-balling its negotiating. you should have a talk with your broker remind the broker what side they are on- and remind them that they are replaceable and if needed to should be ready to negotiate their fees to make the deal work. your broker sucks! and screams newbiew and green- and are only concerned about themselves.
remember on a $1Million dollar unit the commission is$60k (co-broker $30k), its not just for turning a door, its for negotiating, think about it, when properties are priced correctly, they sell (quickly).
You shouldn't anchor your offer off of the seller's price AT ALL.
You should run comps on what the apartment is "worth"/find an alternative apartment that you like, and that will tell what price your target apartment should clear at.
From there, the bidding process is just a strategy to end up at that clearance price minus a smidge.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
If you based your offer on the original asking price, then you are not getting the benenfit of the reduction. Is your broker suggesting that you just ignore the price reduction? I think it is commmon sense that you bid off the reduced price and as another poster noted you can always come up.
Ali r. has the correct answer here, which is esentially that your question is wrong. An offer is based on comparables and the intangible other values of the unit to you. It has ZERO to do with asking price. The asking price may inform how you approach the seller and how much you explain how you arrived at your offer, or the offer price may help you anticipate how the seller may respond, but that's about it.
"The buyer makes the price. Not the seller" - Thomas Hobbes
"discourage the seller from negotiating" - is nonsense in buyers market.
Combined answer of ali and kylewest cover the subject.
In my experience a broker is much more interested in closing a deal (and thus collecting a commission) than trying to marginally increase their commision. My interpretation is that the broker is trying to get you to start as high as possible, as the higher you start, the greater the chance of closing a deal.
Keep in mind that the broker is working for him/herself, although the broker will have a fiduciary responsibility either to the buyer or to the seller, but not both (is this really a buyer's broker?). In practice, that rarely gets in the way of the broker working for him/herself.
Also don't underestimate your value as a buyer in this market, although I would not (yet?) characterize the immediate situation as a "buyer's market." When we hear of sellers competing for the lowest price for a bidder (a different kind of bidding war), that would definitely be a buyer's market.
front_porch & kylewest: if I base my target price on comps & most of these comps are from 2007 - then wouldn't I end up with an "overpriced" number, since it sounds like the general perception is that nyc real estate was overpriced anyway?
"overpriced" in quotation marks is a good way to reflect on it ... if people paid - if there were a buyer and a seller with a meeting of the minds - then it was priced right. Real estate may be or may have been expensive, but as long as transactions take place, pricing is right.
I see where newbie2008 is heading with this. If comps are based on units purchased in an overinflated market, wouldn't they just perpetuate that, an over inflated market?
newbie2008, that's what I was talking about when I said "Unless, of course, you feel a need to factor in a decline of value in the coming market, in which case you need to go lower." UrbanDigs has recently talked about clients factoring a 5-7% drop below comps in their bids, though he also said that they'll sometimes respond to counters at less of a discount. Of course, the drop in (many?) parts of the market may be much bigger than that. VVerain is right about what sets market price, so what are YOU willing to pay for the apartment? If it's less than last year's comps (and if you've looked at the "Indicate Market Movement With Comps" thread you'll see there are cases where that's happening) and no one is willing to py more, AND the seller is willing to sell at that price, you've just set the new market value, lower than last year. You wouldn't be the first.
Tenemental - makes sense...
Your offer should be based on comps and what you think it's worth (e.g., rental comps). Dont pay too much attention to the asking price.
Newbie:
There are two kinds of comps: sold comps and on-market comps.
Sold comps are important for a number of reasons -- chiefly, because they're what lenders look at when deciding to give you a mortgage. So if you're looking at a home for $800K, and all the sold comps are $600K, that should give you pause because your unit probably won't "appraise out." The lender (at least back in the days when lenders actually stopped you) will not feel that the unit is worth what you're paying for it. In that sense, you're overpaying.
But in a market with relatively low volatility, that's not really an issue. Maybe the sold comps are up 10%, maybe they're down, but you're paying in line with some general notion of value.
As a buyer, however, you are not only concerned with rough ideas of absolute value -- you want to maximize the purchase power of your money. Are you getting *relatively* the best apartment you can get for what you want to spend? That's the question.
And the way to answer that question is to detach yourself from the messages the seller is giving you about the negotiation -- including pricing history.
I know I'm running on, but let's do an extended metaphor -- say you go to a Porsche showroom and you absolutely HAVE to have the red Carrera that's on the floor. Fine. But you're going to overpay to get it.
What you want to try and do, as a buyer, is to widen your circle of choice so that there are other goods that you think are decent substitutes -- if you can buy any red Porsche Carrera, you can shop dealers. If an older model at a slightly reduced priced would make you happy, better still. If you're willing to buy a Lexus at some price, better still.
So in other words, your best position as a buyer is to identify multiple apartments that you would buy, and then price them against each other -- "well, I like that one, but for $40,000 more, I could get a terrace."
What you want to bid on apartment A is then determined not by what the pricing history was on apartment A -- which is in the SELLER'S control -- it's what alternative apartment B you can get for your money. And the choice to substitute apartments is psychological, but it's in YOUR control.
This who-sets-the-terms-of-negotiation bit explains why new developments are so often, um, "overpriced." Whether it's the curtain wall construction or the Dornbracht fixtures or the never-been-lived-in psychology, a new development marketer convinces you that they're selling you THE red Porsche, and that no other apartment is a substitute. Once you buy into that premise, you're parting with your money.
ali r.
{downtown broker}
NO, banks go off of new sales, not old ones, they don't want to see anything older then 6 months, they also want to see comps in the area and different building. so the appraisals will adjust, remember as prices are negotiated down, the appraisers have to use those comps so its a trickle down theory.