foreigners and mortgages - saving NYC RE?
Started by bugelrex
over 18 years ago
Posts: 499
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
The claim is that foreigners are propping up NYC RE market.. However its naive to think that the majority of them are paying cash. Where do they generally get their mortgages from? With UK lenders starting to melt, they must be quite hestitent to loan for speculative purchases.. European lenders next? What affect will stricter lending requirements around the globe have on these foreigners ?
Foreigners will not save NYC real estate. Not buyers from the U.K., not from Spain, not from Italy (I'll stop). See BBERG atricle below form earlier today.
It is hard to imagine investing in real estate an ocean away when your home market is in such disarray. And honestly there are not that many Russian billionaires. And they are not stopping the drop in prices even is Sloane Square.
U.K. House Prices Decline Most in 15 Years, HBOS Says (Update3)
2008-06-05 07:08 (New York)
(Adds Bank of England decision in third paragraph.)
By Brian Swint
June 5 (Bloomberg) -- U.K. house prices fell the most in 15
years in May as lenders restricted access to mortgages and the
prospect of a recession deterred buyers, a HBOS Plc report showed.
The cost of an average home dropped 3.8 percent to 184,111
pounds ($359,000) from a year earlier, the U.K.'s biggest mortgage
lender said in a statement. That's the biggest annual decline
since April 1993. Prices slipped 2.4 percent on the month and are
now the lowest since September 2006.
The report adds to evidence the U.K. housing market is
heading for its biggest downturn since the early 1990s and
dragging down the rest of the economy. The Bank of England, which
today left its benchmark interest rate at 5 percent, has signaled
that faster inflation is limiting its scope to lower borrowing
costs.
``The latest data on the housing market are undeniably
alarming,'' said Howard Archer, chief European economist at Global
Insight in London, who expects prices to fall 12 percent this year
and next. ``The marked deterioration in sentiment over the housing
market also heightens the risk that house prices will fall sharply
over the next couple of years.''
The HBOS figures show the housing market slowdown may be
worsening. Nationwide Building Society, Britain's fourth-biggest
mortgage lender, said last week that house prices fell 2.5 percent
in May from a month earlier, the biggest drop since its index
started in 1991.
Housing Slump
The housing slump comes as support for Prime Minister Gordon
Brown's Labour Party falls to the lowest since records began in
1943, YouGov Plc said May 30.
``Yes, house prices are falling, but one of the important
things is that employment levels are much higher 10 or 15 years
ago,'' Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling told
Parliament in London today.
The housing downturn isn't confined to the lower end of the
market. Luxury-home prices in central London, the world's most
expensive location for prime real estate, fell in May by the most
since the first quarter of 1992, Knight Frank LLP said yesterday.
Price declines in April were the most widespread since at least
1978, the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors said May 13.
``The decline in prices is at risk of turning into a rout,''
said Malcolm Barr, chief U.K. economist at JPMorgan Chase & Co.
who used to work at the Bank of England.
U.K. homebuyers are facing rising mortgage costs even after
three rate cuts from the Bank of England since December. British
banks increased the cost of home loans with a 5 percent down
payment to the highest in more than eight years in April.
Recession Risk
``The decline in prices is caused by the difficulties created
for potential house purchasers by the rapid rise in house prices
in the last few years, a squeeze on spending power and the
reduction in credit availability,'' said Martin Ellis, chief
economist at HBOS.
The threat of recession is also hurting property values,
which have tripled in the past decade. The Bank of England
predicted last month that economic growth will slow to about a 1
percent annual pace by the first quarter, the least since 1992,
and Governor Mervyn King said the economy may contract.
U.K. services from banks to airlines unexpectedly contracted
for the first time in five years and consumer confidence fell to
the lowest level since at least 2004, reports showed yesterday.
Record oil prices and food costs may prevent the central bank
from cutting rates to cushion the economy. The inflation rate
jumped the most since 2002 in April, rising to 3 percent, and a
survey by the European Commission published on May 29 showed
consumers' expectations for prices over the next 12 months are the
highest since August 1998.
Policy makers have expressed concern that wage negotiators
will lift their demands to compensate for the rising cost of
living. Pay negotiators clinched a median 3.8 percent salary
increase for about 1 million workers in the three months through
April, up from 3.5 percent in the quarter through March, a report
by Incomes Data Services showed today.
``There is little prospect of any short-term relief for the
housing market,'' said Ed Stansfield, an economist at Capital
Economics in London.
But... But... But.... the foreigners will SAVE US!!!!
Manhattan is unique! There is no other place like it in the world! Everyone wants to live here! The Dollar is cheap!
Foreign investors are typically eligible for 60-70% financing on NYC condos.
No, Martians will save us.
Do the math. Take out a US dollar loan when you earn your salary in a foreign currency. The dollar is at its all-time low. If it rises, the amount in foreign currency you will have to pay to pay your US dollar loan will increase by that exact same amount.
There is no way to hedge against that.
But add to it the fact that property prices are and are expected to continue falling. So you lose on both ends, and there's nothing you can do to hedge it.
Sounds like a great deal to me.
Not.
Actually. I bought in Manhattan 2 weeks ago but I have been living in NY for the past 4 years. The 'foreigners' that are buying are most likely people like me that have euros or other 'hard' ccy. The financing was secured at 80%. The rate was 5.625% (CitiBank) for one component of the loan and floating for the other. It would extremely difficult to do this from abroad. You need to be in situ - or have a kid studying here.
Nearly 1 in 10 Homeowners Face Loan Problems
Sign In to E-Mail or Save This
Print
Reprints
Share
Digg
Facebook
Mixx
Yahoo! Buzz
Permalink
By MICHAEL M. GRYNBAUM
Published: June 6, 2008
Nearly 1 in 10 American homeowners with a mortgage faced foreclosure or fell behind in their payments in the first three months of the year, according to a report released Thursday, a figure that offers a look into the toll caused by the collapse of the housing market.
Skip to next paragraph
David McNew/Getty Images
Nicolas Rosas prepares the lawn of a house in Altadena, Calif., that will be up for auction.
The period from January to March marked the worst quarter for American homeowners in nearly a quarter-century, according to a widely watched report put out by the Mortgage Bankers Association, a trade group.
Both the rate of new foreclosures and late payments surged to the highest levels since 1979. (The delinquency rate includes Americans who are more than a month past due on their home loans.)
A breakdown of the statistics showed problems at nearly every level of the mortgage industry.
Of the 45 million home loans included in the survey, 6.35 percent were at least one payment past due, up from 5.82 percent for the fourth quarter of 2007. (All figures are adjusted for seasonal factors.)
Foreclosure proceedings began on 0.99 percent of loans, up from 0.83 percent in the previous quarter.
Over all, the percentage of loans being foreclosed on reached 2.47 percent in the first quarter, rising from 2.04 percent at the end of December 2007.
The drop in home prices, which has affected a broad swath of the nation’s housing market, has left many homeowners paying mortgages worth more than their own homes. The housing slump is the worst of its kind since the recession of the early 1990s.
The mortgage problems were worst for homeowners who took out subprime loans, which are usually issued to applicants with less-than-pristine credit histories. But even borrowers with solid credit records have not been immune.
“While the foreclosure start rates were up for all types of mortgages, a reflection of the decline in home prices, the magnitude of the national increases is clearly driven by certain loan types and certain states,” said Jay Brinkmann, the group’s vice president for research and economics.
For example, he said, subprime adjustable rate mortgages represent 6 percent of the loans outstanding but 39 percent of the foreclosures in the quarter. Prime adjusted loans represented 15 percent of the loans, but 23 percent of the foreclosures started.
“Out of the approximately 516,000 foreclosures started during the first quarter,” Mr. Brinkmann said “subprime ARM loans accounted for about 195,000 and prime ARM loans 117,000.”
Four states — Arizona, California, Florida and Nevada — accounted for about 89 percent of the foreclosures, a disproportionately high amount of the newly reported figures. Those regions have suffered the sharpest price drops.
“The problems in California and Florida are extraordinary, and they are the main drivers of the national trend,” Mr. Brinkmann said.
More Articles in Business »
Another point that I have been trying to highlight, but the usaual suspects just ignore and insult those who actually analyze data.
"But even borrowers with solid credit records have not been immune."
Going to get worse then people ever thought. The last thing I would do is buy anytime soon. The warning signs are mounting and what makes it even more dangerous is that people are ignoring the fundamentals. This is going to hurt a lot of people when the music stops.
http://www.cnbc.com/id/24986169
93rd, they're not talking about foreigners living here with a steady job as a local or expat. They're talking about the flood of foreigners who they claim are snapping up all Manhattan real estate, which is simply nonsense.
Though I do agree with dco - I would never buy in this environment.
Well, foreigners differentiate not only by country of origins, status in US, income and currency they use, but by let’s say entity.
Would foreign REIT purchasing entire new construction building consider as "snapping up Manhattan real estate"?
{broker}
No foreign REIT purchasing an entire new construction building would not be considered "snapping up Manhattan real estate."
But don't be deceitful, barskaya, in a {broker} sort of way: when agents say that what they mean is individual investors swarming in to buy. It's a lie - I heard it in Miami years ago. The only ones who MAY want to do that are the ones at the very top end who don't need a mortgage, they can use the apartment like gold: just stuff some money there and wait for the dollar to appreciate - and hope that it does more than the dollar-price falls.
Still too high risk for a wise investor.
I was claimed that there is no way to hedge the currency risk a foreign investor would wear in financing with a dollar denominated mortgage, however, FX forwards, options, futures, and options on futures are all derivative contracts that could be effectively used to hedge this risk.
steve, being a broker taught me not to make broad assumptions, based on previous broad assumptions.
Investment is a very specific thing that takes to consideration many factors: location, debt, positive/negative monthly cash flow, tax benefits and so on…
What I don’t see anymore is investors who are willing to carry negative monthly cash flow, but gain on quick equity grows.
Other than that each specific deal should be carefully calculated and measured against specific investor situation. If deal makes sense, it’s a wise investment.
jrd, how? You own a piece of property and a mortgage / tax / maintenance with a constant flow of payments. You cannot hedge a fixed asset, and you cannot enter into that sort of contract for each and every monthly payment because a) the amounts are too small; and b) even if they weren't the transactions costs are too high.
Each contract has a fixed maturity. Are you truly suggesting that you would enter into twelve contracts worth maybe $5,000 a piece to hedge that risk?
Each year, BTW, when the fluctuations in the short term are so small?
steve, you are correct that to *perfectly* hedge the risk would be at best cumbersome and at worst impossible.
However, the largest risk such a buyer is wearing is the dollar denominated ballance on the mortgage, the value of which is (at least initially) decreasing slowly. If you wanted to hedge this risk, you would put on a number of futures contracts in the front (most liquid) month to approximate the balance of the mortgage, and roll these contracts forward as the contract nears expiration. Over time you would roll fewer contracts forward. This is a first order approximation and to really get this right you would need to take into account the tax implications of the hedge.
My only point is really that hedging currency risk is a very common thing in international commerce, that it is quite commonly done, and that there are very liquid venues for doing so.
bugelrex, i know Lloyd's in london finance's mortgages for foreginers or whomever wants to purchase based on a basket of currencies, you have to put at least 25 % down.
Yes, lloyds will lend here to foreign nationals but I am pretty sure they only offer 6month or 1yr ARMS at best.
I know we are up with a small lender who is targeting these borrowers. They offer 70LTV up to $2m, 65LTV to $4m and 55LTV up to $7m. Obviously they do their due dilligence. They offer 5/7/10 yr ARMS.
the offer we got was for three years and the interste rates were very low and based on the ratio between several currencies, and if we put 30 % down then the basket of currencies goes up to 10 different ones. it's actaully pretty good if you have the down payment
Sounds like a good deal if you can afford the down payment. Do they offer IO? What happens after 3 years?