New Condo Financials in complete despair
Started by dledven
over 18 years ago
Posts: 198
Member since: May 2008
Discussion about
what to do about a CONDO that was just formed (3months), new development that took over a couple of months ago, there have been some issues, where property manager has been changed over 4 times, (one mishandled funds), other conflict, third is incompetent, and 4th is beginning in a 2 weeks. the question is since there is no handle on what the real maintenance is how do you value the property? do you just run away from the building? or do you grind out and plant your feet? i just don't know where the maintenance will be? and there are no reserves, does the condo need the same reserves? no underlying mortgage? No line of credit? NO clue what to do?
you answered your own question...Next!
Is the sponsor co-operating? Am in a similar problem-There is a thread here. Its better to have the residents united. Also look at NY attorney General's website. If the condo is over 50% sold more can be done.
http://www.oag.state.ny.us/realestate/documents/Condo.Problems.pdf
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/talk/discussion/3847-sponsor-not-adhering-to-building-offering-plan
they are co-operating- everyone is united, my fear is that i don't know where the real expense base is for the building- plus with the higher costs for utilities i understand that, i think i'm most scared that it could be a bottomless pitt.
What can be done? the building is 95%sold,
If you are not already involved in the building...ARE YOU INSANE even considering it? What on earth would tell you this is a place to sink $$$ in? If you are already in, get a RE attorney--a good one.
agree with Kyle
I generally agree with Kylewest. In this case, this could be a temporary situation that may or may not have prolonged implications.
I purchased a new construction condo, and the developer was initially acting as the property manager- except for the fact that they were not paying any bills as they were supposed to nearly causing our electric and gas to be shut off. We were able to elect a Treasurer and Vice President the first year, but the President was the developer (as per the prospectus). Since the developer failed to service most of the obligations of property manager- we did not pay them for the services. Once we passed the mandatory 1 year marker of having the developer on the board, a few of us stepped up to the plate and were elected to the board and filled the role of managing the building.
As to the real expenses of the building, if you feel comfortable with understanding budgets and financials- it shouldn't be very difficult to construct a budget based on the prospectus..especially since this is a brand new building. Since there were problems (including mishandling funds) assume a scenario where there is no cash balance (I would inquire about the cash balance anyway- regardless of whether they will provide it to you). In this case there could be a small assessment, but if the budget in the prospectus was anywhere near accurate to true expenses/reserves- then the assessment shouldn't be very large.
In our case, the budget in the prospectus was way too low (every buyer into the building realized this ahead of signing contracts) and we had to pass a 30% increase in common charges once the owners were managing the board to cover a reserve (which the budget in the prospectus did not account for) and increased energy costs. In the end, we now have a very stable budget.
If you are not qualified to may this type of financial determination have your real estate attorney / accountant review the financials.
In any case, you should follow up and find out what responsibility the developer has in all of this with your real estate attorney.
New York Real Estate Institute has course on Property Management. It includes class on debt and financing