Comps Used for Bank Appraisals vs. Reality
Started by Maraman
about 17 years ago
Posts: 165
Member since: Nov 2008
Discussion about
As the decline in the market continues to move forward, I am curious how bank appraisers will find appropriate comparable sales to value the property. Many of the closed transactions that they are looking at are based on contracts that were signed a year or two ago. It seems to me they (or Fannie or Freddie)could get burned by not taking this into consideration. It seems to me the last thing that they want to do lend money at the purchase price when the value has declined below that level. Do any bankers or brokers know if banks are becoming suspicious of the accuracy of comps on deals signed years ago or if their are too few recent comps to serve as a basis for valuation.
actually, every bank now demands to see 3 recent comps in the area (with in 6 months or earlier and either pending sales or recent listings to ensure that the comps and appraisal isn't stale
I had an appraisal done at 45 john last week for our apartment. It was based on recent sales in other buildings in the financial district area (like 99 John). I was happy that it appraised for over the price we bought it at a year ago, especially considering other signed contracts in the building weren't given much weight in the appraisal. The appraisal was done by Chase.