Real estate prices in this city are scary enough, but if you’ve ever gone deep into the depths of StreetEasy in search of a great deal, chances are you’ve seen some even creepier stuff. In a market as competitive as New York, staging is everything, yet grainy photos of poorly lit, shabbily upholstered rooms reminiscent of horror movie sets abound. In honor of Halloween, here are some of our favorite eerie listings on StreetEasy.
Shrink-Wrapped Staten Island Scary
“Beautiful one family detached colonial home just waiting for you to come and enjoy the luxury.” — Listing description
The listing page only features photos of the ground floor, which makes you wonder — what’s lurking upstairs? My money’s on an evil twin in a padlocked room. Or maybe Norman Bates in his mother’s clothes.
Macabre Mill Basin Manor
Sinister Staircase in Fieldston
Eerie Entryway in Grymes Hill
Brooklyn Abode’s Spooky Parlor
Greenwich Village Basement of Horror
Bronx Backyard’s Abandoned Carousel
Dining Rooms Perfect for a Seance
Related: