More than 65% of New York City residents are renters, so whether it is your first time searching for an apartment or the 10th, you are not alone. Our guide to renting in NYC shares everything you need to know about the ins and outs of renting, from how much rent you can afford to tips for breaking a lease (hey, it happens!).
Other topics covered in this guide to renting in NYC include how to go about finding the best apartment for you (and roommates if you need them), what to expect at a lease signing, paperwork and fees you'll need to rent a place, whether you should use a broker, and much more.
Ready to search for your new apartment? Start here.
You know the drill about both car insurance and health insurance. But when it comes to your apartment’s coverage, you may be wondering, what is renters insurance? Do I really need it? And we get it. If you’re budget-minded, it’s probably not at the top of your to-do list, because it may cost hundreds and hundreds. Or perhaps you think your landlord’s policy will cover your costs if disaster strikes. Well, you may be surprised to learn that these beliefs are not accurate. Here’s what you need to know about renters insurance in NYC to get up to speed.
Brooklyn Rentals on StreetEasy Under $3,000Article continues below
Prospect Lefferts Gardens
635 Flatbush Avenue
$2,200base rent
Studio |
1
Clinton Hill
104 Washington Avenue
$2,550base rent
1 |
1
Prospect Lefferts Gardens
1277 Nostrand Avenue
$2,600base rent
1 |
1
Sunset Park
448 43rd Street
$2,800base rent
1 |
1
Homecrest
2319 East 16th Street
$2,500base rent
2 |
1
Bushwick
1381 Decatur Street
$2,800base rent
1 |
1
Prospect Heights
720 Bergen Street
$2,850base rent
Studio |
1
Gravesend
2230 Cropsey Avenue
$2,576base rent
1 |
1
Kensington
798 Mcdonald Avenue
$2,599base rent
1 |
1
Crown Heights
1675 Lincoln Place
$2,497base rent
2 |
1
Homecrest
1745 East 12th Street
$1,700base rent
Studio |
1
Greenwood
132 29th Street
$3,000base rent
2 |
1
What Is Renters Insurance?
In a nutshell, renters insurance provides coverage for many incidents relating to your belongings and living space. More on that shortly! But here is your most significant need-to-know. “A lot of people mistakenly think their landlord’s insurance will cover all things related to their apartments, but that’s hardly the case,” said Jeff Schneider, president of Gotham Brokerage. “It’s why renters insurance exists.”
Jersey City Rentals Under $3,000 on StreetEasyArticle continues below
Jersey City
19 Cottonwood Street
$2,800base rent
2 |
1.5
Jersey City
347 Union Street
$2,300base rent
3 |
1
Jersey City
152 Clendenny Avenue
$2,100base rent
2 |
1
Historic Downtown
186 Wayne Street
$2,700base rent
Studio |
1
Jersey City
49 Fisk Street
$2,204base rent
Studio |
1
West Side
190 Culver Avenue
$2,500base rent
Studio |
0
Journal Square
62 Newkirk Street
$2,400base rent
1 |
1
Historic Downtown
354 Varick Street
$2,150base rent
Studio |
1
Jersey City
105 Old Bergen Road
$1,900base rent
2 |
2
Bergen/Lafayette
134 Baldwin Avenue
$2,350base rent
Studio |
1
Bergen/Lafayette
134 Baldwin Avenue
$2,950base rent
1 |
1
Jersey City
413 Ocean Avenue
$1,750base rent
1 |
1
What Does Renters Insurance Cover?
Understanding renters insurance hinges on knowing the different types of coverage offered. Depending on the policy, you can expect coverage for loss or damage to personal property for various reasons, from fire to theft. But, here’s a pro tip: Coverage can mean different things. Some policies will cover the depreciated cost for stolen or damaged belongings, while other plans, which typically cost more, will cover an item’s replacement cost.
“Also, a standard renters insurance policy covers personal liability,” says Robert Stevenson, an insurance agent at State Farm. “For instance, if a guest falls down the stairs in your duplex, your policy will cover some of the medical bills. Let’s say your in-unit washer leaked into the downstairs apartment. A policy can cover some of the damage.” Another good thing to know: Personal liability coverage may cover your legal expenses if you’re sued over an incident that occurs in the place you’re renting.
But the insurance coverage goodness doesn’t end there. If your rental gets damaged to the point that it’s uninhabitable, your plan may cover a hotel stay. It can also cover your expensive laptop if it gets stolen at that coffee shop you use as an office.
Even better, “Renters insurance is one of the cheapest types of insurance you can get. On a monthly basis, renters insurance typically costs between $5 and $40.Premiums can be as low as $125 a year, which is approximately 35 cents a day!” adds Stevenson.
If you’re wondering what impacts insurance costs, prices for policies depend on the value of your assets, the type of coverage you choose, and the location of your apartment. To learn more about what a policy covers, take a look at its “named perils.” These are covered incidents, usually including theft, vandalism, fire, and water damage.
What is the most popular type of insurance claim? “What we see most often in New York is water damage from broken pipes and overflows that leak into other apartments and where the policyholder is held responsible for the damage,” says Stevenson.
And here’s a huge heads up: Many policies do not cover natural disasters. So if you’re in a high-flood area, you might want to consider getting flood insurance on top of renters insurance. If you want to find out if you live in a high-risk zone, check out FloodHelp NY’s website.
Manhattan Rentals Under $3,000 on StreetEasyArticle continues below
Little Italy
169 Hester Street
$2,850base rent
1 |
1
Lenox Hill
324 East 73rd Street
$2,995base rent
1 |
1
Washington Heights
509 West 174th Street
$2,769base rent
2 |
1
East Harlem
304 Pleasant Avenue
$2,299base rent
Studio |
1
Morningside Heights
1270 Amsterdam Avenue
$2,600base rent
Studio |
1
East Harlem
2032 Second Avenue
$2,500base rent
1 |
1
Kips Bay
449 Second Avenue
$2,775base rent
Studio |
1
Upper West Side
305 West 90th Street
$2,895base rent
Studio |
1
Yorkville
527 East 88th Street
$2,795base rent
Studio |
1
Central Harlem
2374 Adam Clayton Powell Boulevard
$2,300base rent
Studio |
1
Hell’s Kitchen
444 West 49th Street
$2,625base rent
Studio |
1
Yorkville
234 East 89th Street
$2,700base rent
Studio |
1
How Much Insurance Coverage Do You Need For a Rental?
An insurance agent will work with you to ensure you have the right amount of coverage you need. But it’s still important to figure out what your belongings are worth.
“The coverage will reimburse you for covered damage, loss, or theft of your possessions up to a certain dollar amount, so you’ll want to make sure you get that amount right,” Stevenson said.
To settle on the right dollar amount, you should perform a home inventory. First, you’ll need to list all of your belongings, when you acquired them, and either the purchase price or the current value. After you total these values, you’ll have an estimated number of what your property is worth. You can also add photos of specific items — such as a computer or an expensive piece of jewelry — to the inventory to help with future insurance claims. It’s a wise move to keep both a digital and a hard copy of your inventory list.
Queens Rentals Under $3,000 on StreetEasyArticle continues below
Rego Park
99-15 66th Avenue
$1,950base rent
Studio |
1
Jamaica Hills
84-50 169th Street
$1,776base rent
Studio |
1
Jamaica Hills
85-40 160th Street
$2,495base rent
2 |
1
Rockaway Park
148 Beach 116th Street
$3,000base rent
2 |
1
Rockaway Park
148 Beach 116th Street
$2,677base rent
Studio |
1
Rockaway Park
148 Beach 116th Street
$2,677base rent
Studio |
1
Forest Hills
103-30 68th Avenue
$2,650base rent
1 |
1
Ridgewood
1924 Palmetto Street
$3,000base rent
2 |
1
Astoria
30-93 Steinway Street
$2,800base rent
2 |
1
Glendale
71-52 68th Street
$2,300base rent
1 |
1
Woodside
55-01 31st Avenue
$2,800base rent
1 |
1
Astoria
30-52 34th Street
$2,900base rent
1 |
1
How Do I Find Renters Insurance?
Most major insurance companies offer renters insurance, so if you have a favorite, be sure to reach out to them. Stevenson suggests working directly with an agent. “The agent will walk you through the different processes, including what to do in the event of a claim.”
Schneider suggests renters should also call around to get quotes to compare their options. “You can look online, but it is not the same as talking to an insurance representative. Most agents are happy to chat on the phone, and there’s no charge for it,” he adds.
So what is the bottom line? At the very least, renters insurance can offer peace of mind, making it better to have than not.