2 units for sale in this building

Skip to the end of the carousel

co_op in Carnegie Hill

1158 Fifth Avenue, #8A

$3,800,000

3 beds

3 baths

Listing by Brown Harris Stevens

co_op in Carnegie Hill

1158 5th Avenue, #4A

$3,995,000

3 beds

3 baths

Listing by Compass

Skip to the beginning of the carousel

1158 5th Avenue

1158 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10029

58 units

15 stories

1924 built

Thinking of selling your home?

Get in touch with an agent who has experience selling in this building.

Carrie Chiang

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Corcoran

10

NYC Co-op sales in the last 10 years

15+

years selling in Carnegie Hill

View full profile

Take the next step on a unit in this building.

See a problem with this building?Report it here

About

1158 Fifth Avenue was built in 1924 and designed in the French Renaissance style by C. Howard Crane and Kenneth Franzheim. The building has 15 floors and 68 apartments, some of which overlook Central Park. The building’s location allows for access to the park as well as cross-town transportation on 96th Street. Amenities include a bike room, fitness room, laundry room (W/D allowed) and private storage. Pet friendly, the building allows up to 40% financing.

Facts

Development status: Completed
Architect: C. Howard Crane and Kenneth Franzheim
District: Community District 111City Council District 4Police Precinct 23
Building class: D4
Documents and permits: View documents and permits

Available units

#4A

$3,995,000

Resale

3 beds

3 baths

2,500 ft²

Listing by Compass

#8A

$3,800,000

Resale

In contract

3 beds

3 baths

- ft²

Listing by Brown Harris Stevens

Unavailable sales

			Status				Floor plan
09/14/26	#910A	$9,900,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	5 beds	7 baths	- ft²
07/20/26	#PHC	$8,995,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	5 beds	5 baths	4,200 ft²
02/27/26	#11A	$3,910,000	Sold (asking: $3,950,000; -1.01%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	2,250 ft²
10/07/25	#PHB	$13,500,000	Sold (asking: $12,000,000; 12.50%)	5 beds	5+ baths	3,798 ft²
06/07/22	#9C	$3,600,000	Sold (asking: $3,795,000; -5.14%)	3 beds	3 baths	- ft²
01/18/22	#4C	$3,280,000	Sold (asking: $3,350,000; -2.09%)	4 beds	3 baths	- ft²
01/04/22	#14AB	$12,500,000	Sold (can't find government record)	8 beds	4.5 baths	- ft²
12/22/21	#PHA	$11,400,000	Sold (asking: $12,500,000; -8.80%)	4 beds	2+ baths	- ft²
12/20/21	#1D	$600,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
11/24/21	#5C	$2,950,000	Sold (asking: $3,150,000; -6.35%)	3 beds	3 baths	2,300 ft²
07/09/19	#1AMAIS	$4,995,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	5 beds	4.5 baths	3,450 ft²
05/23/19	#1A	$4,725,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
11/23/18	#MAIS1A	$4,995,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	4 beds	4.5 baths	- ft²
06/29/17	#9D	$2,500,000	Sold (asking: $2,600,000; -3.85%)	3 beds	3 baths	2,000 ft²
06/19/17	#8B	$5,550,000	Sold (asking: $5,750,000; -3.48%)	4 beds	3 baths	3,000 ft²
02/02/17	#3C	$3,250,000	Sold (asking: $3,650,000; -10.96%)	3 beds	3 baths	- ft²
03/29/16	#7D	$2,250,000	Recorded closing	-	- baths	- ft²	-
07/24/15	#10D	$3,250,000	Sold (asking: $3,250,000; 0%)	3 beds	2.5 baths	- ft²
03/19/15	#PH-16/17B	$10,000,000	Sold (asking: $9,950,000; 0.50%)	4 beds	4 baths	- ft²
02/20/15	#3D	$2,950,000	Sold (asking: $3,100,000; -4.84%)	3 beds	3 baths	2,000 ft²
11/06/14	#5D	$3,400,000	Sold (asking: $3,495,000; -2.72%)	3 beds	3 baths	- ft²
10/22/13	#PH16/17B	$14,500,000	No longer available on StreetEasy	4 beds	4 baths	- ft²
04/09/13	#3A	$3,000,000	Sold (asking: $3,300,000; -9.09%)	3 beds	3 baths	2,500 ft²
11/15/12	#7C	$3,125,000	Sold (asking: $3,395,000; -7.95%)	4 beds	3 baths	- ft²
07/30/12	#8D	$2,850,000	Sold (asking: $3,250,000; -12.31%)	3 beds	3 baths	- ft²
05/01/12	#5B	$2,900,000	Recorded closing	4 beds	4 baths	3,000 ft²	-
07/21/11	#15D	$2,600,000	Recorded closing	3 beds	3 baths	- ft²	-
11/30/10	#7B	$3,795,000	Sold (asking: $3,795,000; 0%)	3 beds	3 baths	- ft²
07/21/10	#2D	$2,100,000	Sold (asking: $2,195,000; -4.33%)	4 beds	3 baths	2,100 ft²
05/17/10	#11CD	$6,300,000	Sold (asking: $6,300,000; 0%)	6 beds	5 baths	- ft²
06/17/08		$3,250,000	Sold (asking: $3,450,000; -5.80%)	3 beds	2 baths	2,300 ft²
09/13/07	#MAISA	$5,025,000	Sold (asking: $5,250,000; -4.29%)	5 beds	3.5 baths	- ft²	-

Unavailable rentals

						Floor plan
11/01/23	#5B	$25,000	4 beds	4 baths	3,000 ft²
09/27/13	#6A	$15,250	3 beds	3 baths	2,250 ft²
07/05/12	#15C	$17,000	3 beds	3 baths	- ft²
07/26/11	#506	$4,995	2 beds	2 baths	1,400 ft²	-