164 Underhill Avenue

$3,400,000

for sale

4,441 ft²

$765 per ft²

15 rooms

4 beds

6.5 baths

Multifamily home
Prospect Heights
Resale

This home has been saved by 88 users.

Listing by Corcoran, Limited Liability Broker, 1 Pierrepont Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Report listing

Common charges

Not applicable

Estimated payment

$19,213/mo

Taxes

$2,021/mo

Tax abatement

No info

About

Seller’s agent

Ellen Gottlieb

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Corcoran

Description

Perfect 1031 Tax Exchange Property!

Welcome to 164 Underhill Avenue, a remarkable property nestled in the heart of Brooklyn's coveted Prospect Heights neighborhood. This fully renovated five-family residence blends modern luxury with classic charm, making it an outstanding investment opportunity or a spacious home for an owner-occupant. Spanning 4,441 square feet, the property offers four bedrooms and seven bathrooms, providing both space and privacy.

Policies

Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.

Home features

No info on home features

Building amenities

No info on building amenities

About the building

164 Underhill Avenue

164 Underhill Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11238

Multifamily building inProspect Heights

5 units

2 stories

1900 built

For sale

1 available units for sale

For rent

0 available units for rent

Documents and permits

View documents and permits

Learn more about 164 Underhill Avenue

Property history

Price change: No changes
Days on market: 105 days

Date	Price	Event
5/5/2026	$3,400,000	Listed by Corcoran
5/11/2026	$3,400,000	No longer available
2/9/2026	$3,400,000	Temporarily off market
10/21/2025	$3,400,000	Listed by Corcoran
1/14/2016	$2,549,000	No longer available

Past listing photos

3/12/2015

Explore Prospect Heights

Transit

Location	Distance
23at Grand Army Plaza	0.21 miles
23at Eastern Parkway–Brooklyn Museum	0.28 miles
BQat 7th Av	0.31 miles
Sat Park Place	0.47 miles
Cat Clinton & Washington Avs	0.52 miles

View transit on Google Maps

View on Google Maps

About Prospect Heights

Sales

Median asking price

4 beds

$2.45M

Rentals

Median asking base rent

4 beds

$6,995

Prospect Heights offers a vibrant mix of old and new Brooklyn. Often referred to as a fallback for people unable to afford Park Slope, the area has recently become known for its own unique personality - as well as its rising real estate value. The commercial strips of Vanderbilt and Washington Avenues offer a mix of bodegas and inveterate neighborhood standbys next to a new spate of hipster-centric bars and restaurants. Turn down any side street, however, and you can encounter gorgeous old brownstones surrounded by quiet greenery.

Learn more about Prospect Heights