258 Carlton Avenue #2

$10,000

for rent

Base rent only. Price may not include required fees and charges.

1,800 ft²

$66 per ft²

6 rooms

4 beds

1.5 baths

Three-family home
Fort Greene

Under NYC law, you can't be charged a broker fee if you didn't hire a broker.

Learn more

Listed by

Ariane Dembs

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Corcoran

1 Open house

Sun, Aug 2

1–2 PM ET

By appt only

Listing by Corcoran, Limited Liability Broker, 1 Pierrepont Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Report listing

Available

9/7/2026

Days on market

Listed today

Last price change

No changes

About

Nestled on a picturesque tree-lined block just moments from Fort Greene Park, this beautifully preserved upper duplex offers the perfect blend of historic charm and generous living space. Enter through your own private stoop into a home rich with original details, including elegant crown molding, wide-plank hardwood floors, and soaring ceilings.

Policies

Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.

Home features

Dishwasher
Hardwood floors
View
Garden
Washer/dryer

Building amenities

No info on building amenities

About the building

258 Carlton Avenue

258 Carlton Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11205

Three-family house inFort Greene

3 units

3 stories

1899 built

For rent

1 available units for rent

Documents and permits

View documents and permits

Learn more about 258 Carlton Avenue

Property history

Prices shown are base rent only. For total monthly price and additional fees, see .

Date	Base rent	Event
7/31/2026	$10,000	Listed by Corcoran
10/29/2018	$5,800	No longer available
10/11/2018	$5,800	Listed by Corcoran
10/12/2016	$5,750	No longer available
9/22/2016	$5,750	Listed by Corcoran

Explore Fort Greene

Transit

Location	Distance
Cat Lafayette Av	0.26 miles
Gat Fulton St	0.28 miles
Gat Clinton–Washington Avs	0.28 miles
BDNQR2345at Atlantic Av–Barclays Ctr	0.42 miles
2345at Nevins St	0.42 miles

View transit on Google Maps

View on Google Maps

About Fort Greene

Sales

Median asking price

4 beds

$3.99M

Rentals

Median asking base rent

4 beds

$4,800

With bustling flea markets, a world-renowned performance space, trendy boutiques, fabulous restaurants, and a rich literary and artistic tradition, Fort Greene attracts residents looking for a slower pace of living without sacrificing the vibrancy of urban life. Historic brownstones and row houses make up most of the available real estate, and it's common to find neighbors catching up on their stoops. Intense Brooklyn pride is in evidence on the main drag of Fulton Street, where a Notorious B.I.G. quote is painted on the side of a prominent building - "Spread love it's the Brooklyn way."

Learn more about Fort Greene