Slide 1 of 12Skip to the end of the carousel

1 of 12

Seller's agent

Matthew Bizzarro

Licensed Real Estate Broker

Bizzarro Agency

This home has been saved by 20 users.

Listing by Bizzarro Agency, Limited Liability Broker, 8 West 126th Street, New York, NY 10027

Report listing

37 Nagle Avenue #1C

$390,000

For Sale

Temporarily off market 2/11/2026

- ft²

4 rooms

2 beds

1 bath

Co-op
Fort George
Resale

Maintenance fees

$1,155/mo

Estimated payment

$3,579/mo

Taxes

Included in maintenance fees

Tax abatement

No info

About

Seller’s agent

Matthew Bizzarro

Licensed Real Estate Broker

Bizzarro Agency

description

All showings are by appointment only.

Location and livability come together in this two-bedroom residence in scenic Fort George.

Upon entering the unit, the remodeled kitchen will be on your right. Mealtimes will be enhanced by custom cabinetry, stainless steel appliances including a French door fridge and gas range, natural stone counters, and pendant globe lights over a waterfall dining counter.

Policies

Parents buying allowed
Pets allowed
Cats and dogs allowed
Pied-a-terre allowed

Home features

Dishwasher
Hardwood floors
Private outdoor space
Garden

Building amenities

Services and facilities

Bike room
Elevator
Laundry in building
Live-in super
Parking
Garage, Valet
Storage space
Locker/cage

Wellness and recreation

Children's playroom
Gym

Shared outdoor space

Courtyard

About the building

37 Nagle Avenue

37 Nagle Avenue, New York, NY 10040

Co-op building in Fort George

- units

- stories

- built

For sale

0 available units for sale

For rent

0 available units for rent

Documents and permits

View documents and permits

Learn more about 37 Nagle Avenue

Property history

Price Change: ↓ $35,000 (-8.2%) on 12/8/25
Days on market: 337 days

Date	Price	Event
2/12/2026	$390,000	Temporarily off market
2/11/2026	$390,000	No longer available
12/8/2025	$390,000	Price decreased by 8%
10/2/2025	$425,000	Listed by Bizzarro Agency
9/4/2025	$399,900	Delisted by New Heights Realty