54 Cheever Place

$4,495,000

For Sale

In contract 10/29/2025

3,360 ft²

$1,337 per ft²

11 rooms

5 beds

3.5 baths

Three-family home
Cobble Hill
Resale

This home has been saved by 136 users.

Report listing

Listing by Compass, Corporate Broker, 110 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10011

Common charges

Not applicable

Estimated payment

$26,682/mo

Taxes

$749/mo

Tax abatement

No info

About

Seller’s agent

Rachel Greenstein

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Compass

Suzanne Koxvold

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Compass

Toni Nicolo

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Compass

Mia Lieberman

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Compass

description

A rare opportunity awaits on Cheever Place, a picturesque, tree-lined enclave in the heart of the Cobble Hill Historic District. This stately, 21-foot-wide townhouse, built in 1854 and delivered vacant, offers exceptional versatility as a lucrative three-family investment, a spacious two-family home, or a grand single-family residence. With its 21-by-40-foot footprint on an 88.5-foot-deep lot and a max FAR of 2.

Policies

Sorry, policy info isn’t available right now. Check back later.

Home features

Dishwasher
Hardwood floors
Private outdoor space
Garden
Washer/dryer

Building amenities

Services and facilities

Laundry in building

Wellness and recreation

No info on wellness and recreation

Shared outdoor space

Courtyard

About the building

54 Cheever Place

54 Cheever Place, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Three-family house inCobble Hill

3 units

3 stories

1854 built

For sale

1 available units for sale

For rent

0 available units for rent

Documents and permits

View documents and permits

Learn more about 54 Cheever Place

Property history

Price Change: ↓ $355,000 (-7.3%) on 9/30/25
Days on market: 104 days

Date	Price	Event
10/29/2025	$4,495,000	In contract
9/30/2025	$4,495,000	Price decreased by 7%
7/17/2025	$4,850,000	Listed by Compass
9/28/2010	$1,770,000
9/29/2010	$1,800,000	No longer available

Explore Cobble Hill

Transit

Location	Distance
at Carroll St	0.42 miles
at Bergen St	0.44 miles
at Borough Hall/Court St	0.66 miles
at Smith–9th St	0.76 miles
at Hoyt & Schermerhorn	0.77 miles

View transit on Google Maps

View on Google Maps

About Cobble Hill

Rental prices shown are base rent before any fees. Visit listings for cost and fees breakdown.

SalesMedian asking price

5 beds

$5.69M

Cobble Hill is a beautiful, historic neighborhood with some of the borough's most expensive real estate. Despite the abundance of seven-figure homes, Cobble Hill has small-town vibe evident in the mom-and-pop stores and Italian influences that dot Court Street. Walk down the sunny commercial strip and you'll pass the local butcher, the baker and the fishmonger — all family-run and equally popular among local residents and foodies from far and wide.

On the side streets, the homes tend to be large brick townhouses and brownstones owned by single families, with well-kept facades and window boxes. This is a neighborhood where homeownership is a luxury, and residents take that responsibility to heart. The blocks are clean, the community associations active, and the lifestyle warm and genteel.

Learn more about Cobble Hill