Foreclosure moratorium?
Started by drg
over 18 years ago
Posts: 77
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about
So from today's Crain's business news, was wondering what everyone thought the impact of a foreclosure moratorium (for 12 months) would be on Manhattan real estate? Two things that I would point out: 1) probably little effect on actual supply of apartments since most co-ops have required bigger downpayments and more liquid assets, so owners were unlikely to be stretched from the start given these... [more]
So from today's Crain's business news, was wondering what everyone thought the impact of a foreclosure moratorium (for 12 months) would be on Manhattan real estate? Two things that I would point out: 1) probably little effect on actual supply of apartments since most co-ops have required bigger downpayments and more liquid assets, so owners were unlikely to be stretched from the start given these conditions--thus fewer foreclosures in Manhattan overall. Of course, as condos have become a bigger and bigger piece of the real estate "pie" in the last 20 years, this insulating effect may have been lessened somewhat. 2) a foreclosure moratorium would likely make financing more difficult to find. First banks don't want to lend in markets if they have no means at their disposal to collect on overdue payments, so is it possible they withdraw from NY state?; secondly, if funds are tied up in bad loans with the banks having no recourse to collect, then those funds cannot be loaned to other, more qualified, borrowers; and finally, lenders will be more stringent in their requirements on who they lend to so as to not have to deal with bad loans down the road. This last point isn't necessarily bad, but I would think it would lead to a smaller buyer pool and thus, a dampener on prices. Here is the article: Foreclosure fight moves to NY Senate Bank panel takes up moratorium, but guv's bill gains May 10. 2008 3:48PMBy: Daniel Massey A showdown looms in the state Senate over a bill that would impose a one-year moratorium on foreclosures. The legislation, which the Assembly passed by an overwhelming majority last week, has drawn the ire of the banking industry and some Republicans, who seem prepared instead to support a bill proposed by Gov. David Paterson. Foreclosure filings in the state rose 40% in the first quarter from the year-earlier period, to about 14,000, according to RealtyTrac, and more New Yorkers are falling behind on their mortgage payments. With federal legislation stalled, state Democrats and Republicans and their allies say that something needs to be done, but that's where the agreement ends. “The industry's answer is 'We don't need regulation,' but that's what they were saying 10 years ago, and you see the mess we've gotten into,” says Josh Zinner, co-director of the Neighborhood Economic Development Advocacy Project. Democrats and housing activists say that a one-year moratorium combined with a strengthening of the governor's plan—which focuses on assisting those facing foreclosure and avoiding another crisis—would help address the issue. But the idea of stopping the clock for subprime borrowers who make minimum monthly payments determined by a judge is anathema to lenders, who say it would make it harder for creditworthy New Yorkers to get mortgages. Senate Republicans appear to be getting behind the Paterson bill. Emphasis on governor's bill “If something is going to happen in this area, it's going to involve the governor's program bill,” says Hugh Farley, R-Schenectady, chairman of the Senate Banking Committee. But housing advocates are gearing up for a fight in the chamber, where, spearheaded by Acorn, they have persuaded Republican Sen. Frank Padavan of Queens to sponsor the moratorium measure. “If Sen. Padavan and his colleagues are serious, they will follow the Assembly's lead and pass this legislation without delay,” says Acorn Executive Director Bertha Lewis. The Paterson legislation, which came out of the Banking Department, steers clear of the tricky moratorium question. It would require lenders to send a notice to borrowers at least 60 days before beginning a residential foreclosure action and would mandate that the parties meet with a judge to work out a settlement. It also expands the state's anti-predatory lending laws and rules governing borrowers' ability to repay loans. Advocates say that bill needs even more protection for borrowers, but mortgage industry experts say it goes too far and would inhibit lenders' ability to provide credit. Hearing today The debate will continue before the Senate Banking Committee today as mortgage and housing groups testify on the governor's proposal. It's unclear how the Assembly would react if a watered-down Paterson bill is approved by the Senate. Banking and financial services companies spent $7.3 million on lobbying statewide in 2007, according to the state Commission on Public Integrity. Banking industry political action committees donated a total of at least $426,000 to Senate and Assembly members—a significant amount in a nonelection year—according to the New York Public Interest Research Group. At least $168,000 of that amount went to Senate Republicans, and at least $107,000 was donated to Assembly Democrats. Observers of state politics say that the moratorium might have served a purpose, even if it doesn't become law. “What it does is provide an impetus and momentum to bring attention to the issue,” says Patricia Salkin, director of the Government Law Center of Albany Law School. “Somehow, you always wind up with a new law where all the different perspectives have had a chance to weigh in.” BY THE NUMBERS For New York City: 74% Increase in mortgage payments late by 60 days in the first quarter from a year earlier 66% Increase in foreclosures in the first quarter from a year earlier Sources: PropertyShark.com; TransUnion.com [less]
Add Your Comment
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog
Most popular
-
10 Comments
-
1 Comments
-
9 Comments
-
10 Comments
-
8 Comments
Recommended for You
-
From our blog
NYC Open Houses for November 19 and 20 - More from our blog