Asking 30% down from comps on UWS
Started by JohnDoe
over 17 years ago
Posts: 449
Member since: Apr 2007
Discussion about 263 West End Avenue #6D
Maintenance: $1,565 way high
Based on the sales of #2D and #4D, this is an early 2004 price.
Does anyone have any intel on why the maintenance is so high? Does this start to build the case that higher maintenance apartments actually have higher-percentage declines in a down-market?
i think it supports the fact that problem apartments (airshaft views, walk ups, bad neighborhoods, high maintenance, etc) are much more critically viewed during declines.
Apt 3C also for sale and its old listing from 2 years ago
http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/sale/72759-coop-263-west-end-ave-upper-west-side-new-york
shows us that maintenance in this building is up 25% in two years. This alone would account for some price decrease even if the market wasn't down.
Its helpful to look at changes in maintenance when disucssing price drops over a few years. Unfortunatly I don't know of an easy way to do this unless there is an apartment in the building that has changed hands twice in the timeframe.
Can't figure why 263WEA would have particularly-high maintenance. Not an unusually-big mortgage, not overstaffed, taxes seem in line. Could be that those 14 floors of mostly ho-hum one-bedrooms are out of whack in their share allocations relative to the larger apartments on 15 and higher, where the setbacks and terraces start. Maybe one-bedrooms were seen as more valuable back in 1947 when the building went co-op.
I'm wondering, though, whether our ideas of what maintenance ought to be are behind the times. E.g. the old $1psf=low, $1.50psf=OK, $2psf=high numbers have been around as long as I can remember, while taxes, payroll, and everything else have gone up. I don't know that $1,600 for a regular one-bedroom is high or OK, but for sure it's not low.
Johnathan Miller (the appraiser) said that contacts on teh UWS were down 25% or so 1-2 months ago, so this seems to follow with that.