Question for those who think the RE market is doomed
Started by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about
I agree that the market is slowing down and it may not make sense for some to buy right now (we bought last year and I am not a broker, but have used a couple useless brokers over the years, so skip the "broker alert" posts please). But, if you think there is a 100% chance that the market will go down the toilet over the next couple years, why do you spend your time on a website devoted to listing sales and rentals? I assume that means you are not looking to buy property if you think it is a terrible idea. Just a question - not looking for insults (although I am certain they will follow).
broker alert!
Good to see you are having a conversation with yourself. That adds a lot to this forum. Maybe some quiet reflection time is in order.
don't feel bad about buying on the dead high....i am just guessing that is what you did....i could be wrong....but may i ask you a question.....if you already bought a place why are you on this website????????????
Int rates coming down. Hedge funds making money left and right. Foriegners buying up every condo. The market may slow or flatten, but it isn't crashing unless we have another 9-11.
ok brain and why are interest rates coming down?????? HMMMM.....nothing to do with the economy maybe going to hell in a hand basket....and the tiny problem with a sector of the mortgage industry that generated about 20% of all loans last year?.....don't worry be happy....the stock market has nothing to say about things of this nature....things always go up until they don't
check out the hame page of cnn.com.......read and learn
3 years agoI saw this coming, this is what I did.
I used credit derivatives to short the subprime tranches, I took a beating for awhile but now its really really paying off
You think everyone is losing money right now? Your the same guy I have to convince not to invest in the GPA account in his 401k. The sky is not falling Chicken Little.
why is everyone so hostile? I am one who thinks RE prices will fall, but visit the website b/c I just find real estate interesting and as I was considering buying before I came to this conclusion I'm curious to see what's out there and what others think about the state of the market.
To poster #1- I've been buying real estate for the past 30 years and I really like it and I really like reading other people's opinions and ideas and respect the honest posters and honest questioners. The insulters and pointless comment makers like #2,3,4,5,7,10 are a nuisance, but the real people make up for it.
My observation (and personal problem) is that I've bought a lot of stocks over the years whose value has just gone away. The value of the five pieces of real estate I have left fluctuates, but so far at least, none is less than I paid for it and I've enjoyed living is some nice places.
And, to those posters who call others morons or idiots or losers - please don't. Just help us, by sharing your experience and knowledge, to know to what you know so we can do better.
Finally, if Car and Driver had to depend on readership all of whom were actually buying Astons and Rolls and Mercedes, they wouldn't have much circulation. Same here - can't we NYC real estate wannabes be allowed to read and enjoy these post?
my firm has been short the home builders for two years and now we are making money hand over fist. (and Toll Bros isn't building in Manahattan) We are not the rest of the country. Everyone want to be here.
#17~poster #13 here, you are incorrect
#17 Toll Bros are building in Manhattan. See, for instance, http://www.streeteasy.com/nyc/building/110-3-avenue-manhattan
I just bought a terrific new build in the Village, and STILL expect the NYC real estate market to come in, for sure. But I also expect to live in this particular place for 15 or 20 years (hopefully more!), and so if the market goes down, and then eventually comes back, I don't care.
What I DO care about is that when I sign my mortgage in about 30-60 days, I believe that I'll be looking at historically low interest rates. So even if the market goes down by (let's say) 25% over the next three years, it's certainly possibly that interest rates will go up by the same amount. That would put interest rates at just under 8% in three years.
I'd rather have locked in my 'dream' place at historically low rates knowing I'm going to live there a very long time, and as 10 years turns into 20 and 20 years turns onto 30, I'll still be paying (20 years out) the same small monthly payment (especially when adjusted for inflation at that future time) with an interest rate of 6.25%. Because I don't see my condo as an investment (or maybe I should say that I do not count the equity in my condo to be part of my net worth), it seems prudent to me to lock in a place if I think it's a great place in great location with all the appropriate bells and whistles, knowing that I'm going to be there a long time.
The market going south doesn't really deter me - and I'm guessing that many of the buyers purchasing homes in NYC in the $2.5+ or $3MM+ level feel the same way. The 'correction,' or 'crash,' or whatever you want to call it, is already expected and factored in when they're making a purchase - they're not buying to flip in six months - they're reasonably informed consumers. After all, I didn't get to the financial point in my life that I am currently by not being able to connect the dots!
good for you, goodluck.
but in the end it will be: how much can you afford and will you have the same income in 15-20 years, will you be working at all? those are real questions
I own, my sister rents. She was informed on the first of March that her lease (which expires at the end of April) will not be renewed and she is not welcomed as a month-to-month tenant. The landlord is converting building of studio and one bedrooms to family sized apartments. My sister has no desire to move, doesn't have the time to find a new place, and is facing much higher rents wherever she looks. She is torn between wanting to drag out her departure with knowing that she really needs her landlord as a reference for her next application.
Experiences like this are part of the reason I own. It gives me a sense of stability and control. I'm not living at the whim of a landlord, management company, and market trends. If I am paying a few dollars more for that, fine by me.
I agree with 22. I think a lot of the negative posters on this site assume everybody buys for investment purposes and that gains/losses are the only useful criteria in evaluating whether to buy. Owning you own place that you can do work to and do not fear being kicked out of is worth a lot. Owners also lock in their monthly costs (except maintenance and tax) for up to 30 years. Huge difference then dealing with 5%+ rent increases each year.
Poster #21:
Poster #20 here. In the end, as I said, as I don't count my home to be part of my net worth for retirement (eventually!), affording the home is not an issue. And whether I'm working in 15-20 years doesn't matter either. First off, that was factored in (of course) before I decided to buy. Realistically, I won't need to be working in fifteen or twenty years. In addition, as I said before, you have to remember that whatever my monthly mortgage payment is (for argument's sake, let's say it's $1000), that in twenty years, that $1000 payment will be equal to a mortgage payment of $550 today, due to inflation. So the monthly mortgage payment will be much easier to 'afford,' and I won't have to earn the same amount of annual income (realistically, I'll pay off my mortgage way in advance of that, but I'm going through the numbers for the sake of discussion).
That's the best part of buying - even if your investment does go down at some point during the thirty year period of the mortgage (and what investment DOESN'T go down at some point over a thirty year period), you STILL get to leverage the ever increasing power of inflation by paying the same fixed morgage IN 2007 DOLLARS for thirty years, PLUS all the interest on those mortgage payments is deductible! AND you're building equity all at the same time.
I agree with 22... my decision to buy this year was due to various factors involving renting my apartment. Rent has increased 9% per year. After performing various calculations and also consulting a financial advisor, it was in my best interest to buy. I'm not one of those idiotic flippers who buy just to earn quick $$$. I'm planning to live there for years. It should be made 100% clear that it's a hard decision to save up thousands of dollars; then handing it all over as down payment. The only question that I ask myself is why am I paying thousands of dollars in rent to someone when I can invest it in my own home? $50,000 in annual rent is 1/3 of my paycheck... it is rather disturbing how much I spend just having a roof over my head per year. Thus, I agree with poster #22.
It's amazing how just a short while ago, people like #22-#25 were trying to argue prices wont go down, they can't, this is nyc
now their argument has shifted to OK, prices will go down, but now I'm willing to lose a bit of money each month to not have to deal with a landlord, i'll live their for 30 years, etc....
just funny how arguments change when facts begin to reveal themselves as the real news begins to emerge about how !@$@#$ the housing market is
you guys crack me up
finally everyone is in agreement (one way or the other) that prices are and will continue to fall in Manhattan...i'm renting and will continue for the next year.
#26, since you are so wise, please tell me exactly how long you have been predicting a drop. If you are so smart and all knowing, I'm sure you got in beforehand, bought lots of property and sold them all just before prices slipped. I have had enough of litening to the people who started 6 years ago saying prices will drop all of a sudden now taking credit for predicting it. What about the 5 years many of you were wrong? Anybody can sit around, make a prediction about real estate (prices either go up, stay the same or drop) and then wait until they are right to become vocal. You will be right 33% of the time - not a hard guess to make. So unless you used your supernatural powers to predict the future to actually make a ton of money, zip it when acusing people of changing their arguments.
#28, new poster here, not to sound like a "wise man" but it has been pretty obvious that for quite some time that RE would cool off and then go down in the city. Number of reasons, if you look at the right indicators. Manhattan is still part of america and is not completely insulated as you may think. this is only the beginning of not a correction but a worldwide meltdown.
btw, if you want to make money, then short the lenders if you have the money. my portfolio has increased 200% in the last 6m doing exactly that.
Can someone please give a specific day or month real estate prices in NYC will go down I am trying to time this dam market.
To maximize your profit, you should find out the exact time the real estate prices will go down. That way you don't have to tie up your capital for extra minutes.
I have predicting a drop since 1995! HA I am finally right!!!
Toll Brothers derives 99.7% of its revenue from outside Manahattan. K Hovenian is similar.
I just bought a 2MM place and I have zero worry. It forced me to take a whole bunch of money out of stock 2 months ago and interest rates are now going down. I hope the sub-prime debacle gets even worse so we see 4% on the 10Y T-Bond.
that was good timing on pulling out of the stock market... I'm happy sitting on cash for the moment, I am very curious as to where the Manhattan real estate market will go if wall street has an icky '07 bonus season. No one can deny that a lot of young wall street hedonists have been living the high life on their bonuses. Remember all the broker babble from the trenches when their bonuses hit about how the market picked right up... What happens when the music stops?
#35 you are an idiot, good time to be out of the market? lol you are naive.
you ever heard of selling short?
i made over 2m this month alone selling short on the subprime lenders-
Yeah, and I had George Mason in the Final Four last year. I also went to 100% in Feb 2000.
Watching the market from a distance, largely through this site, and about to make a move to Manhattan, I have to say that the shit seems to be flying off the shelves: I see no slowdown. From January until March I've watched places appear and then hit contract in about three weeks. Stressful. Any thoughts / advice? I'm preparing myself to make trips on a dime to see places the minute I get the listing. How long can you wait? When is the peak for supply / demand? Will things cool off after Labor Day regardless?
#38: I am also looking. There is plenty of inventory and more coming. Some of the stuff "flying off the shelves" is pulled listings. Take your time.
Plenty of inventory--mmm where in the co-op market? It appears that close to 100% of the posters are predicting or forecasting a real estate depreciation. Let's see if everyone is right time will tell. I am anxiously waiting for the depreciation in prices like everyone else on this board so I can buy for the cheap and get a good deal.
To 26, From 22: I purchased my first apartment in the early 90's. I bought a larger apartment in the same building in 2001. I've seen my property values rise and fall. Just as I've seen my stock portfolio and retirement acounts rise and fall. It doesn't matter that property values sometimes fall. What matters is long term growth. If I lived in a burnt-out-run-down-industrial town, I would worry about long term contraction. This isn't a concern in NYC.
It hasn't been a buyer's market for the past few weeks since the investigation of New Century Financial in January 2007. The media sort of blew it out of control last week. Even with these accumulating findings of subprime loans, the market is still going strong. I've been looking for an apartment since last summer. I was told to wait... wait... wait... and see if the market cools down. I've always been told the winter is the best time to shop for housing versus spring, summer, and fall as those seasons are usually busy. Most newly developed condos are already 90% sold out with the remaining being very expensive. The only properties that seem to be affordable are co-ops. However, I'm just too impatient to bow down to those board members. Another downside I've found about co-ops is that it's pre-war and very difficult to get permission to renovate. In January, I saw a huge 1-bedroom 800sqft co-op in Chelsea for $400K. It was definitely a deal. But the dealbreaker was after inquiring about renovating the kitchen, bath, and closets really got me on the edge. The neighbors I've spoken to said it's highly unlikely to renovate with board approval and that might take months... or might even never get a reply. I finally found my place, which is a condo, and am definitely awaiting the closing date.
If the market is definitely on a downfall due to subprime loans, why haven't we seen that many foreclosures in Manhattan under 90th st? If you go to the nyc dept of finance website, they post a list of foreclosures in the city. The number of foreclosures vs the number of apartments in the city would astound you. It's less than 0.5%!!!
I don't think the risk in Manhattan is in foreclosures. People who are paying 500K+ usually aren't subprime mortgage consumers... the risk is that we're coming into a bear market on wall street and that the cash doesn't get doled out to the highest paid employees in bonus $$.
#42, while you'r right, condos are easier, rennovating a coop depends on the board for that particular building. Some are more liberal than others, you can't generalize. And not all coops are prewar.
I concur with #43; one reason I think why NYC hasn't suffered the same heat as the rest of the nation is because coops, which represent at least two-thirds of all residential buildings in NYC (as I understand) are more strict than banks when it comes to approving residents. For example, someone fitting into the 'subprime' catetory who would finance 99% with an ARM or interest only mortgage would never qualify to purchase a coop, many of which require a minimum 20% down and don't allow ARM's.
can someone please explain how many condos are coming to the market in the next year and how many people buy condos in nyc on a yearly basis?
only about 10% of the buildings (non rental) in Manhattan are condos.