bad time to buy
Started by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about
first time buyer needs to really now what you honestly think about buying now. is this the begining of the end? if we plan on holding on to this property for at least 7 years are we okay? please provode your input. we are only financing 30% of it
ps we are buying in a well established neighborhood 15 minute from manhattan
why are you putting so much cash down?
we probably would not qualify for a larger mortgage
Personally I don't think you should try to time the market. If you can afford it and its a good property, good price and you have reserve cash, I think you should do it. 7 years is a long time and even at 3% a year, you can still make some money. Think about how much money you'd waste if you rented for the next 7 years. The renters were saying the exact same thing 5 years ago before an incredible run and they'll continue to say it through a "housing pullback" and miss the next run.
well... i wouldn't count on whether you qualify or not for a large mortgage unless you have really bad credit. I am a first time home buyer with good credit. there are programs to help 1st time home buyers... plus you get the best rate. my rate is 5.68 for a conformed 30-yr fixed rate mortgage. it was locked last monday. the lender qualifies you based on debt to income ratio and loan-to-property value ratio. i would try 30% down. Let the lender decide if you need to put more.
Unless you are trying to buy a property and flip it, there is no "bad" time to buy an home. My father bought his apartment during what at the time was a record peak of the NYC real estate market. Everyone told him he was crazy for spending (drumroll) $6,000 on a 2 bedroom apartment and that he would lose his shirt. Does anyone think this would have been a substantially better investment had he waited for the price to drop 5%? 10%?
10 years ago I could of bought this apt and made a lots and lots of money but I thought it was too expensive at the time. Now the same apartment is for sale and I'm thinking about buying it this time but I may not because I feel it's to expensive.
$6000??? was that in the early 1900s?
There was an very interesting article tody in the NY Times that really made me think. It was about a coop building in Manhattan - a building that is located in midtown, right by MoMA. The article weas discussing a particular building and the long time coop owners there, and discussed at length the prices paid for different units. As an example, a woman in the coop bought a unit EXACTLY 30 years ago in 1976 for $35,000 that is now valued at well over $900,000.
So she saw the real estate recession of the 70's (when she bought), the big run up in the 80's, the next recession in the 90's, and finally the current situation now. Calculated, she's earned OVER 12% per annum compounded on this unit over the past 30 years, and of course (assuming a 30 year fixed mortgage) has been paying a (very) small manthly mortgage payment based on her initial purchase price. Even when people were yelling at one point or another in that 30 year cycle "Don't buy - the sky is falling and the markest's going to crash!" or "The market's going crazy up - buy now because it's your last chance!" she just rode it all out. And made a very nice annualized return, plus got the tax advantages, plus had a very low fixed payment, plus built equity, plus had to live someplace.
It just goes to show that if your time horizon is long enough, and you're not trying to 'time the market' or flip for profit, over the very long run, you're probably just fine buying. The important thing is NOT to listen to all the noise, and to be careful that if and when you do buy, you really try to do the very best you can in terms of location and quality of your home.
problem is, the "very long run" isn't feasible for most people. I agree that over a 30 year time horizon it's better to own than rent, but what if your time horizon is 5 years?
#10, can you provide the link to the article? I couldn't find it in today's NYT; thx.
Poster #10 here:
The link is http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/15/garden/15rockefeller.html
Regarding horizon, when I first moved to the city, my friends ad I said we wouldn't be here for more then 3-5 years... ten years later we're all still here and looking to stay another 3-5.
What does 15 minutes from Manhattan mean? If it means across the river in NJ that is a lot different than Brooklyn Heights.
Timing of the market is not only about resale value...if i had bought 10 years ago...1 bedrooms were $100k vs now....$600k, my monthly mortgage would be considerably lower and i would have more excess cash......buying now @$600k would mean an expensive mortgage...im in it for the longhaul but would prefer to pay a lower mortgage over the 30 years...so not really an issue if property goes up or down after i buy it...
In the early 1900's, you could buy a townhouse for less than $6000. $6000 for a two bedroom in a prime neighborhood was probably in the 1950's.
Mhillqt - mortage costs are also a function of interest rates - and they are more at historical lows now.
who is your mortgage broker? help
my mortgage broker is the best! honest, upfront, and totally friendly. i bet you'll enjoy her rates as it is the best you'll find.
the only way for the fed to "save the economy" from this housing crash, is to print money, and pump up inflation, this will drive interest rates up and hence housing affordability down. The may be exactly the wrong time to buy - NYC is not isolate from the rest of the USA.
Good can't wait for the housing prices to come down. Could you please tell me the time and the day the prices will drop.
My mortgage broker (who I've spoken about before on this blog) is Norman Calvo at Universal Mortgage in Manhattan on West 34th Street. I've done four real estate transactions with him in the past five years, and think he's done an excellent job. Can't reccomend highly enough...
Given that the OP is planning on putting so much down in the purchase of an apartment, he/she should consider his ability or inability to time the alternative investments for that cash. Is it a good time to buy-and-hold in the stock market? Can he accurately time more active stock trading? Will a "safe" investment like CDs or money market accts. mean a slow death to inflation (by which I mean the real rate of inflation, not the bogus US government official rate)? And, on the other hand, does the OP truly and with confidence love the home he's considering buying?