Skip Navigation

Why I love NY...

Started by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006
Discussion about
I am helping my sister find a studio to buy. She is looking to spend about $425K. Knowing the NY market, she expects to put 20-25% down in a co-op and need about 2 years mortgage and maintenance liquid after making the down payment. So she is basing her price point on the 125K she has in savings. She earns $75K a year and is comfortable with but not enthusiastic about, the prospect of a... [more]
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

You sister can definitely find a studio for much less than $425. I also am looking and am in the price range of $325-375 and there are tons of studios in that price range. Look on streeteasy. At $75k salary before taxes she would be creating a painful situation with a high mortgage. You also have to consider maintenance of $550- 800 a month.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Your scenario is not just a New York one. That is how this mortgage debacle has come about. Credit credit credit, debt debt debt. People have always wanted to live beyond their means & now with all this easy credit, they can - temporarily.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

This is probably made up because I bought in '04 in a similar situation and barely qualified with similar numbers except for a 1br condo. There's no way 70k would get 1.1M.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Also keep in mind that a pre-approval when buying a coop is really nothing more than a gauge of how much the bank is willing to lend. A coop board will typically have tighter standards, and it sounds as if your sister's expectations are realistic.

Also keep in mind that once her mortgage is set, payments are fixed over time so compared with rent increases she'll save money in the long run.

Of course there's also the maintenance portion, so make sure she gets a good lawyer and does enough due dilligence on the building to est how often maintenance increases, the financial strength of the building, etc.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

I agree with 4. If she bought a $1.1M apartment, the mortgage alone would be over $5K permonth and that is before taxes and maintenance. She would not even take home $5K per month on a $75K salary. There is no mortgage company in the world that would set you up with a mortgage that you absolutely could not pay even if you devoted 100% of your take home pay to the monthly bill.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Agreed....the 1.1M comment is either a misunderstanding between the bank and the borrower, or a fabrication. My wife and I make around 300k, and got a pre aproval recently for only about 1.2 mm. We both have good credit. 1.1m on 75k doesn't make much sense.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

how much can one afford with 130-150k??

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Depends a lot on other debt (e.g., student loans, car payment, credit cards, etc.). If you make $150K, you proably take home about $8-9K per month. If you spend 30-40% on housing, that means you can handle a monthly payment of about $3K-4K for mortgage, taxes and maintenance. That translates to about a $400-500K mortgage. Add 10% to that for a condo downpayment or 20% for a co-op downpayment and you get an apartment for between $440K and $600K. Just quick and unscientific math though. Go to a mortgage site and use the "what can you afford calculator."

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by ssskit
over 19 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Dec 2006

Well, I make about $180k and can easily afford my $860k place w/$700 maintenance and tax abatement. After the tax benefit, it's about $1k more than my rent was.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by ssskit
over 19 years ago
Posts: 69
Member since: Dec 2006

Well, I make about $180k and can easily afford my $860k place w/$700 maintenance and tax abatement. After the tax benefit, it's about $1k more than my rent was.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#11...I cannot understand how you can afford $860k on $180k before taxes. Unless you put down 50% it doesn't make sense

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

I believe that a mortgage broker would pre-approve a $1.1M mortgage on a $75K salary. So many brokers will determine eligibility based on the initial payments of a mortgage with a ver short-term, very low teaser rate. The broker has an incentive to give a high mortgage, and little downside if the borrower defaults. An underwritter might feel differently, but pre-approvals don't go to underwriting.

With the sub-prime market being illustrated in the news, I have seen several stories of people with very low incomes and mortgages that are way beyond their means. It sounds as though the mortgage broker was counting on the borrower being unable to understand the terms of the mortgage.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#13, get a commitment letter from a broker for 1.1M with 75k and I'll believe it. I bet you'll get laughter before a commitment letter.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Brokers don't provide committment letters. The mortgage company provides the committment letter. All the broker can do is match the borrower to the lender.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#14, I think #13 was pretty clear that he was talking about pre-approval and not a commitment letter. He said "An underwritter might feel differently, but pre-approvals don’t go to underwriting."

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

180k = 15k a month - mortage on 860k with 10% down and tax abatment is about 5k month, take in consideration about 12k year in tax refunds you are looking at 4k month - that leaves you with about 11k / month to spend on the rest of your taxes and living...... can you live on 11k a month?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

You can spend a tax refund - it isn't cash. I think you have to do everything pretax because that's the cash reality.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#18, you don't have to wait for your tax return. You can adjust your withholdings or estimated taxes throughout the year.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

I am aware that you can adjust your deductions - the question is "how can you live on 11k of disposable income a month' - sarcasm

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

I make around 150k and I get back only around 4-5k back after taxes, 401k, insurance, etc. I just don't understand how people come up with these 5k mortgage payment numbers. Maybe i'm missing something here.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

That's weird - and my base salary (not incl. bonus) is 125k and i didn't put a 401k allocation yet this year but will. So after taxes, insurance etc. I get about 6200 per month (no kids or special deductions etc.). So that's strange that with more salary, you get less back.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

at 150k - how much mortgage interest did you pay? - if you are puttin up 40k-50k year in mortage interest - you get back an ADDITIONAL 12k a year

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

That's a lot wrong with his calcs - #22. . . .he seems to be bleeding even from his salary alone. . . .i dont understand

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

16, a preapproval is useless if you can't actually get a loan for it no? so i again say, show me a commitment letter.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

You have to look at this from the broker's perspective. He wins if he can convince the buyer to take out a larger mortgage. Not nec the largest mortgage approved, but anything larger than the client had in mind. So if a client seeks a 300K mortgage, is pre-approved for a 600K mortgage, and the pre-approval encourages the clients to look at more expensive properties and results in a 400K mortgage...the broker wins.

The dynamics are no different from the credit card industry. There is a complex but direct relationship between credit limits and balances. The more a credit card company tells someone the can borrow, the more the client borrows. External approval and validation, even from a total stranger, generally encourages more borrowing. A very, very small percentage of card holders ever meet the balance on a card. But someone who maintains a $500 balance on a card with a $2,500 credit limit will probably increase their balance a few hundred dollars if the credit limit is extended to $10,000. That doesn't mean the credit card company actually thinks they would be made whole if the client actually charged the full $10K. T

Tell someone that they are highly credit worthy, and they generally use more credit.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#17, by your math, you do not pay income tax, so good luck living in your apartment until the IRS come calling. At $180K, you take home about $10K per month, so after your mortgage, you have a bout $5K to spend. $5k to live on if you have any other debt (e.g., student loans, car, etc.) is not a lot of room.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

$5k per month is NOT a lot to live on?! Wow no wonder renters can't afford to buy.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

yeah i agree with 28 - if after all those costs - you have $5k to live on and are one person - that is a lot!

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Give them enough rope to hang themselves! To the best of my knowledge, we're still not teaching young people in the schools about credit & personal finance; I hope I'm wrong.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

28 here, $5k a month is almost $200 a day... if you can't live on that, you definitely should not be buying anyway.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

It all comes down to how you want to spend your money. I have a nephew who is still renting but he's in the Caribbean at Thanksgiving & skiing in France over New Year & if you're trying to keep up with the senior partners, no, $5000 a month isn't a lot of money.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Well clearly partying and traveling and keeping up with the jones is more important then owning, saving and financial independence. Read "The Millionaire Next Door" because you're really in no shape to be buying if you aren't rich and your lifestyle is like that...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#28's math is completely screwed up. He is assuming he is not paying fed taxes, states taxes, nyc taxes, social security taxes, 401k, medical insurance, dental insurance, cable, cell phone, electricity, gas, food, etc etc. How much money do you really have after everything??

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

28 is saying after taxes - your take home pay - as he is referencing #27 who has netted out stuff already.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#34's reading skills are completely screwed up. Not to mention half that stuff still does not come close to $5000. And why do you have gas in there? You clearly do not live here or a paycheck to paycheck spender.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#36 not gasoline, but gas as in the heating stove. Some places pay for it, other don't..mainly prewar.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#36, it might not come close to 5k but will come very close to 2-3k. Look at your 401k, if you are putting the max for this year, 15.5k that'll be around 1.3k per month. Added NY/NYC taxes, you get 2k. Add some insurance and fed taxes, social taxes, you hit 3k.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

THe disposable income started post-tax - so you wouldn't take out tax again.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

401k is pre-tax, plus the original calculation estimated a $10k takehome off a 180k salary.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

New poster here. This may help. My base salary is exactly $180K, and I am a Manhattan resident. I receive a 6 figure bonus that is paid in the begining of the calandar year for the preceding year. Prior to the payment of my bonus my monthly take home is about $9,000 (this is net of all taxes, usual payroll deductions (e.g., medical/dental), 401k, and social security. After the bonus is paid, my monthly take home becomes just shy of $10,000. It goes up, because I fund the 401k for the year out of my bonus, and social security taxes for the year have been met from the bonus. Hope that this helps.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

would you find it difficult to live with $5k per month and do you own?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

this is the dullest conversation ever ...

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Poster 41 here. We are in contract to buy in a new development - we currently rent. The $180K base salary is for me. I also have a wife and infant. Because of that and the fact that a very significant percentage of my overall comp came from my bonus plus my wife's income, the sufficiency of $5k per month in our case would not be relevant.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

fascinating

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Once again, $180k is before taxes. When talking about salary people should use after tax income.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

hope your sis like pb&j every night..$425 is completely out of her ballpark on a 75k salary

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

The reality is, NYC has priced out anyone not making a six figure salary and a healthy bonus. It's the only city I've lived in where making $250K is like making 75K anywhere else. Good luck to your sister. Her 75K is really like making 20K anyplace else; will she be able to put foos on the table?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

i make 130, am i priced out??

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

I don't think a $425K apartment is out of the question on a $75K salary. OP mentioned $125K in savings, so the buyer has some financial discipline. Assuming a 25% down payment, the buyer is looking at about 40-45%% of their income going towards housing. Not ideal, but not out of the question.

If other costs are low, no debt, no car, low priced insurance, etc...I think it is doable.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

$75K in NY is NOT like $20K elsewhere. Not even close.

Housing in NY is more expensive than other cities, yes. But for someone who doesn't own a car (big savings over other cities), doesn't pay for parking, doesn't insist on buying their groceries at Fairway or dining out at expensive restaurants every week, doesn't shop at Barneys, takes mass transit instead of cabs, and so forth...Housing is really the only thing that costs more.

I would rather earn 75K in NY (about 4K/mo take-home) than live anywhere else in the US on 20K.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#51...that was the best comment.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

#32 Who cares about Caribbean at Thanksgiving & skiing in France over New Year, with 5k left over you can still buy the winnebago and travel the good old USA without having to worry about hotel expenses.

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

where are you going to park that winnebago?

Ignored comment. Unhide
Response by anonymous
over 19 years ago
Posts: 8501
Member since: Feb 2006

Central Park?

Ignored comment. Unhide

Add Your Comment